Structure theory, classical

Resonance theory [15] contains essentially three assumptions beyond those of the valence bond method. Perhaps the most serious assumption is the contention that only unexcited canonical forms, non-polar valence bond structures or classical structures need be considered. Less serious, but no more than intuitive, is the proposition that the molecular geometry will take on that expected for the average of the classical structures. This is extended to the measurement of stability being greater the greater the number of classical structures. These concepts are still widely used in chemistry in very qualitative ways. 

In this minimal END approximation, the electronic basis functions are centered on the average nuclear positions, which are dynamical variables. In the limit of classical nuclei, these are conventional basis functions used in molecular electronic structure theory, and they follow the dynamically changing nuclear positions. As can be seen from the equations of motion discussed above the evolution of the nuclear positions and momenta is governed by Newton-like equations with Hellman-Feynman forces, while the electronic dynamical variables are complex molecular orbital coefficients that follow equations that look like those of the time-dependent Hartree-Fock (TDHF) approximation [24]. The coupling terms in the dynamical metric are the well-known nonadiabatic terms due to the fact that the basis moves with the dynamically changing nuclear positions. 

Although structures involving methyl groups bonded simultaneously to two carbon atoms by means of an overlap between the hydrogen orbitals and the />-orbitals of the carbon atoms may be readily enough assimilated, the state of structural theory is such that most of the cyclic intermediate or transition state structures are dubbed non-classical. In many cases they are best depicted by molecular orbitals, usually by diagramming the component atomic orbitals in the best position for overlap. Since maximum overlap of the component atomic orbitals imposes certain geometric requirements, pre-... 

The electronic chemical potential is constant for a system in its electronic ground state, which led Parr et al. to associate the chemical potential with minus one times the electronegativity, since the electronegativity is also equalized in the ground state [7]. This equalization of the chemical potential also suggests that electronic structure theory can be expressed in a way that resembles classical thermodynamics. Ergo, Parr et al. wrote the total differential of the energy as... 

Aspects of bonding and structure/dynamics in selected carbonium ions were presented and discussed. These representative studies demonstrate the power of structural theory in the development of concepts that could lead to new and efficient processes, especially in the area of hydrocarbon chemistry and catalysis. There is no doubt that as newer theoretical and experimental techniques and models are introduced, they will be applied to the study of carbonium ions. A deeper understanding of structure/dynamics of hypervalent non-classical carbonium ions will not only deepen our knowledge of structural theory in chemistry, but could also help in the development of new processes and materials useful in our daily life. 

Among the problems confronting organic chemists, two especially seemed to test the limits of the classical structure theories, namely, benzene and acetoacetic ester, also known as ethyl acetoacetate. Arthur Lachman, a Munich-... 

Classical structure theory was developed purely from chemical facts, without any help from physics. The theory of resonance was well on its way toward formulation before quantum mechanics was discovered.. . . ... 

It is true that the idea of resonance energy was then provided by quantum mechanics. . . but the theory of resonance in chemistry has gone far beyond the region of application in which any precise quantum mechanical calculations have been made, and its great extension has been almost entirely empirical.. . . The theory of resonance in chemistry is an essentially qualitative theory, which, like the classical structure theory, depends for its successful application largely upon a chemical feeling that is developed through practice. 46... 

Pure substances. Language The Classical Structural Theory... 

In fact, as we will see, the classical structural theory provides the only means by which a chemist can visualise a synthesis. All science needs a language and the language of organic chemistry is the Classical Structural Theory. That this is so can be seen if the first attempts to synthesise quinine are considered. 

In Chapter 1 we have stated that the classical structural theory is the only way to "visualise" the synthesis of a more or less complex organic compound. However, all or most of the information given by a structural formula can also be expressed.by a matrix (see also Appendix A-1). There are different kinds of matrices for example, the adjacency matrix J, which originates in graph theory and indicates only which atoms are bonded, or the connectivity matrix C, whose off-diagonal entries are the formal covalent bond orders. For instance, the corresponding matrices of hydrogen cyanide are ... 

FIGURE 12. Transition structure for the isomerization of peroxynitrous acid to nitric acid optimized at the B3LYP/6-311- -G(d,p) level of theory. Classical reaction barrier, TS total energy and imaginary frequency (vectors represented by the arrows) are 40.8 kcalmoL (with respect to ds-GS HO—ONO), —280.86143 au and 690i cm, respectively... 

As described in Chapter I in this volume, electronic structure theory calculations are also very useful for computing C chemical shifts in carbocations. The predicted C NMR spectra and the experimental spectra, obtained in superacids under conditions where the carbocations are stable, can be compared. These comparisons are particularly helpful in differentiating between classical and nonclassi-cal structures for these electron-deficient species. 

Each of the semi-classical trajectory surface hopping and quantum wave packet dynamics simulations has its pros and cons. For the semi-classical trajectory surface hopping, the lack of coherence and phase of the nuclei, and total time per trajectory are cons whereas inclusion of all nuclear degrees of freedom, the use of potentials direct from electronic structure theory, the ease of increasing accuracy by running more trajectories, and the ease of visualization of results are pros. For the quantum wave packet dynamics, the complexity of setting up an appropriate model Hamiltonian, use of approximate fitted potentials, and the... 

The essential identity in character of the theory of resonance and the classical structure theory of organic chemistry, which has before been referred to only briefly,42 will be discussed in detail in the following paragraphs. 

I feel that the greatest advantage of the theory of resonance, as compared with other ways (such as the molecular-orbital method) of discussing the structure of molecules for which a single valence-bond structure is not enough, is that it makes use of structural elements with which the chemist is familiar. The theory should not be assessed as inadequate because of its occasional unskillful application. 11 becomes more and more powerful, just as does classical structure theory, as the chemist develops a better and better chemical intuition about it. 

Hooke s law relates stress (or strain) at a point to strain (or stress) at the same point and the structure of classical elasticity (see e.g. Love, Sokolnikoff) is built upon this linear relation. There are other relationships possible. One, as outlined above (see e.g. Green and Adkins) involves the large strain tensor Cjj which does not bear a simple relationship to the stress tensor, another involves the newer concepts of micropolar and micromorphic elasticity in which not only the stress but also the couple at a point must be related to the local variations of displacement and rotation. A third, which may prove to be very relevant to polymers, derives from non-local field theories in which not only the strain (or displacement) at a point but also that in the neighbourhood of the point needs to be taken into account. In polymers, where the chain is so much stiffer along its axis than any interchain stiffness (consequent upon the vastly different forces along and between chains) the displacement at any point is quite likely to be influenced by forces on chains some distance away. 

---