Rhodium complex-catalyzed carbonylation selectivity

Rhodium catalyzed carbonylations of olefins and methanol can be operated in the absence of an alkyl iodide or hydrogen iodide if the carbonylation is operated in the presence of iodide-based ionic liquids. In this chapter, we will describe the historical development of these non-alkyl halide containing processes beginning with the carbonylation of ethylene to propionic acid in which the omission of alkyl hahde led to an improvement in the selectivity. We will further describe extension of the nonalkyl halide based carbonylation to the carbonylation of MeOH (producing acetic acid) in both a batch and continuous mode of operation. In the continuous mode, the best ionic liquids for carbonylation of MeOH were based on pyridinium and polyalkylated pyridinium iodide derivatives. Removing the highly toxic alkyl halide represents safer, potentially lower cost, process with less complex product purification. 

This chapter will address the development of selected stereoselective rhodium-catalyzed carbonylation reactions and their application to problems in organic synthesis. It is in no way intended to serve as a comprehensive review of rhodium-catalyzed carbonylation chemistry. The focus, rather, is on the development of stereoselective rhodium-catalyzed carbonylation reactions for use in the synthesis of stereochemically complex natural products, particularly polyketides. 

The cobalt-catalyzed reaction of carbon monoxide and hydrogen with an alkene, hydroformylation, is an extremely important industrial process, but it occurs under vigorous conditions (200-400 bar, 150-200 °C) and is not a particularly selective reaction. In the presence of ligand-modified rhodium catalysts, however, hydroformylation can be carried out under extremely mild conditions (1 bar, 25 C). The catalytic activity of such rhodium complexes is in fact lO -Ky times greater than that of cobalt complexes and side reactions, such as hydrogenation, are significantly reduced. The reactivity of alkenes in hydroformylation follows a similar pattern to that observed in other carbonylation reactions, i.e. linear terminal alkenes react more readily than linear internal alkenes, which in turn are more reactive than branched... 

Ditertiary phosphines such as (86), (92), and (98) (100) (Scheme 6) have found important uses as ligands for metal-catalyzed transformations, including e.g., palladium-catalyzed Grignard cross couplings,194,205 rhodium-catalyzed Michael additions,2 hydrocyanations,206 copolymerizations,20 and palladium-catalyzed animations.208 Rhodium complexes of (86) are catalysts for the carbonylation of methanol.188 More recently the ligand bite angle of ditertiary phosphines such as (100) has been shown to influence catalytic activity/selectivity in several important catalytic processes.209-213... 

First, for reasons of clarity, the currently-accepted mechanism of transition-metal complex catalyzed-hydrosilylation reactions will be described briefly. Furthermore, consideration of selective, if not asymmetric, reduction of certain carbonyl compounds by way of rhodium(I)-catalyzed hydrosilylation (Section 4) is included in this review because the catalytic process and stereochemical course of this reaction correlate closely with those of their asymmetric reduction under similar conditions that will be described in the succeeding section. 

The important discovery by Wilkinson [1] that rhodium afforded active and selective hydroformylation catalysts under mild conditions in the presence of triphenylphosphine as a hgand triggered a lot of research on hydroformylation, especially on hgand effects and mechanistic aspects. It is commonly accepted that the mechanism for the cobalt catalyzed hydroformylation as postulated by Heck and Breslow [2] can be apphed to phosphine modified rhodium carbonyl as well. Kinetic studies of the rhodium triphenylphosphine catalyst have shown that the addition of the aUcene to the hydride rhodium complex and/or the hydride migration step is probably rate-limiting [3] (Chapter 4). In most phosphine modified systems an inverse reaction rate dependency on phosphine ligand concentration or carbon monoxide pressure is observed [4]. 

Nomura, K. Ishino, M. Hazama, M. (1993) Selective reduction of aromatic nitrocompounds affording aromatic-amines under CO/H2O conditions catalyzed by phosphine-added rhodium and ruthenium carbonyl-complexes, J. Mol Catal,1, 273-82. 

Platinum complexes with chiral phosphorus ligands have been extensively used in asymmetric hydroformylation. In most cases, styrene has been used as the substrate to evaluate the efficiency of the catalyst systems. In addition, styrere was of interest as a model intermediate in the synthesis of arylpropionic acids, a family of anti-inflammatory drugs.308,309 Until 1993 the best enantio-selectivities in asymmetric hydroformylation were provided by platinum complexes, although the activities and regioselectivities were, in many cases, far from the obtained for rhodium catalysts. A report on asymmetric carbonylation was published in 1993.310 Two reviews dedicated to asymmetric hydroformylation, which appeared in 1995, include the most important studies and results on platinum-catalogued asymmetric hydroformylation.80,81 A report appeared in 1999 about hydrocarbonylation of carbon-carbon double bonds catalyzed by Ptn complexes, including a proposal for a mechanism for this process.311... 

Mononuclear ruthenium complexes were found to be superior to carbonyl clusters during a comprehensive comparison of a variety of catalysts in the reduction of acetone [49]. Without solvent, most catalysts were highly selective, although the activity was quite low. The addition of water to the system vastly increased yields, in agreement with Schrock and Osborrfs observations into rhodium-catalyzed hydrogenations (Table 15.9) [41],... 

Gyclization/hydrosilylation of enynes catalyzed by rhodium carbonyl complexes tolerated a number of functional groups, including acetate esters, benzyl ethers, acetals, tosylamides, and allyl- and benzylamines (Table 3, entries 6-14). The reaction of diallyl-2-propynylamine is noteworthy as this transformation displayed high selectivity for cyclization of the enyne moiety rather than the diene moiety (Table 3, entry 9). Rhodium-catalyzed enyne cyclization/hydrosilylation tolerated substitution at the alkyne carbon (Table 3, entry 5) and, in some cases, at both the allylic and terminal alkenyl carbon atoms (Equation (7)). 

Recently, it has been discovered that catalysis by rhodium compounds is more effective than by the older cobalt catalyst when tris(triphenylphosphine)rhodium chloride is treated with carbon monoxide, the catalyst bis(triphenylphosphine)rhodium carbonyl chloride is formed. This catalyst is very effective under very mild conditions (49-51). It is believed that the tr-ir rearrangement is also important with this catalyst and operates in a manner analogous to that in the cobalt-catalyzed process, since stablization of the cr complex has been shown to lead to olefin isomerization and lower linear selectivity (52). 

---