Reaction constant variation with solvent

The arrangement of Chapters 1 to 5 of this Part of this Report by type of compound results in a dispersal of references dealing with the role of the solvent. To remedy this, some of these references have been collected together here, both to illustrate current approaches to determining the role of solvents in inorganic reaction mechanisms and the use of rate-constant variation with solvent composition trends as diagnostic tools. 

Reactivities of brosylates, mesylates and tosylates are similar (Table 3), and show relatively small variations with solvent and alkyl group (R). Tosylate/mesylate rate ratios vary from 0.5 to 2.0 in S l solvolytic reactions of adamantyl sulphonates48. Slightly higher ratios may be observed for SN2 reactions in dipolar aprotic solvents, e.g. second-order rate constants for nucleophilic substitution in n-octyl sulphonates by thiocyanate anion show tosylate/mesylate rate ratios increasing from 0.7 in methanol to 1.5 in chlorobenzene and in cyclohexane, and to 4.4 in DMSO12. 

Nucleophilic Attack at Carbon. - Rate constants for the forward and reverse formation of the tributylphosphine - carbon disulfide adduct, Bu3P -CS2, have been determined in a range of solvents. The forward reaction constant shows little variation with solvent, whereas the reverse reaction constant... 

The reason is that these alleged kp values are mostly composite, comprising the rate constants of propagation of uncomplexed Pn+, paired Pn+ (Pn+A ), and Pn+ complexed with monomer or polymer or both, without or with an associated A" [17]. Even when we will eventually have genuine kp values for solvents other than PhN02, it will not be possible to draw many (or any ) very firm conclusions because the only theoretical treatments of the variation of rate constants with solvent polarity for (ion + molecule) reactions are concerned with spherically symmetrical ions, and the charge distribution in the cations of concern to us is anything but spherically symmetrical. 

Variations in dielectric constant should alter the relative strength of acids of different charge types, since the amount of electrical work involved in a proton-transfer reaction must vary with the dielectric constant of the medium. Since a lowering in dielectric constant increases the work required to separate the ions (for example, to ionize an uncharged acid one must create an anion and a cation), any addition of organic solvent should lead to an increase of pXa values. 

Substantial variations of the organic solvent used in triphase catalysis with polystyrene-bound onium ions have been reported only for the reactions of 1-bromo-octane with iodide ion (Eq. (4))74) and with cyanide ion (Eq. (3)) 73). In both cases observed rate constants increased with increasing solvent polarity from decane to toluene to o-dichlorobenzene or chlorobenzene. Since the swelling of the catalysts increased in the same order, and the experiments were performed under conditions of partial intraparticle diffusional control, it is not possible to determine how the solvents affected intrinsic reactivity. 

It is not intended to extend this discussion of reactions of carbocations with water to consideration of the alcoholic solvents trifluoroethanol (TFE) and hexa-fluoroisopropanol (HFIP), which have been extensively studied and reviewed by McClelland and Steenken.3 However, an important point of interest of these solvents is that their reactivities toward carbocations are greatly reduced compared with water (by up to a factor of 104 in TFE and 108 in HFIP) and that differences in rate constants can be observed between cations which would react indiscriminately at the solvent relaxation limit in water. The following comparisons of rate constants for carbocations with similar pAR values reacting with hexafluoroiso-propanol241,242 reinforces the conclusion that structural variations in the cation lead to changes in intrinsic barrier and, for example, that phenyl substitution is probably associated with such an increase in going from benzyl to benzhydryl (although the benzyl cation itself is not shown). 

Because systematic variations in selectivity with reactivity are commonly quite mild for reactions of carbocations with n-nucleophiles, and practically absent for 71-nucleophiles or hydride donors, many nucleophiles can be characterized by constant N and s values. These are valuable in correlating and predicting reactivities toward benzhydryl cations, a wide structural variety of other electrophiles and, to a good approximation, substrates reacting by an Sn2 mechanism. There are certainly failures in extending these relationships to too wide a variation of carbocation and nucleophile structures, but there is a sufficient framework of regular behavior for the influence of additional factors such as steric effects to be rationally examined as deviations from the norm. Thus comparisons between benzhydryl and trityl cations reveal quite different steric effects for reactions with hydroxylic solvents and alkenes, or even with different halide ions... 

We now turn attention to a completely different kind of supercritical fluid supercritical water (SCW). Supercritical states of water provide environments with special properties where many reactive processes with important technological applications take place. Two key aspects combine to make chemical reactivity under these conditions so peculiar the solvent high compressibility, which allows for large density variations with relatively minor changes in the applied pressure and the drastic reduction of bulk polarity, clearly manifested in the drop of the macroscopic dielectric constant from e 80 at room temperature to approximately 6 at near-critical conditions. From a microscopic perspective, the unique features of supercritical fluids as reaction media are associated with density inhomogeneities present in these systems [1,4],... 

The final limitation of the pure electrostatic theory is its inability to predict solvent effects for reactions involving isopolar transition states. Since no creation, destruction, or distribution of charge occurs on passing from the reactants to the activated complex of these reactions, their rates are expected to be solvent-independent. However, the observed rate constants usually vary with solvent, although the variations rarely exceed one order of magnitude [cf. Section 5.3.3). These solvent effects may be explained in terms of cohesive forces of a solvent acting on a solute, usually measured by the cohesive pressure of the solvent [cf. Section 5.4.2). 

For determinations of reaction constants, anomeric purity is not necessary, but for the determination of initial rotations, only one anomer can be present. Pure anomers can often be obtained by slow crystallization from a suitable solvent in the presence of nucleating crystals of the desired form and in the absence of crystals of other forms. For measurements in aqueous solution, use of mM potassium hydrogen phthalate as a buffer (pH 4.4) is recommended, to avoid variation in acidity during measurements. Precautions for purification, drying, and use of organic solvents have been described by Lowry and Baker. Anomeric impurities can be removed by lixiviation with a solvent (such as aqueous alcohol) in which both anomers are slightly soluble. 

Variation in solvent density corresponds to changing the amount of CO2 in a reactor of constant volume, and hence the chemical potential and the mole fraction of a solute can be varied at constant molar (mole per volume) concentration. Obviously, such changes may have a strong impact on chemical equilibria and reaction rates, which in turn determine yields and selectivities of synthetic processes [11]. In addition, a number of solvent properties of the fluid phase are directly related or change in parallel with the density. Accordingly, such properties can be tuned in SCCO2. Variation of the so-called solvent power is the most obvious application and discussed in more detail below. 

The elementary rate constants were calculated from ratio kp/kt, obtained from the polymerization rate and initiation rate and the ratio kp/kt, estimated from the lifetime of the radical determined by the rotating sector method. The mean lifetime of the propagating radical and derived rate constants for methacrylates are shown in Tables 7—8. The variation of the propagation rate constant for methyl methacrylate with solvents is in accordance with the result obtained by Bamford et al.2 at 25 °C. Since the largest and the smallest kp value for phenyl methacrylate differ by a factor of 1.6 and for methyl methacrylate by a factor of 1.4, the estimation of the rate constants must be performed under experimental conditions in which the accumulated error is so small as to permit a distinction of the difference. Therefore, particular attention was given to the constancy of the reaction temperature ( 0.001 °C), constancy of light source, purity of monomers and solvents, and reproducibility of observed values and to the retention of the square wave in the rotat-... 

---