Rate-controlling steps identification

Loving, R.N. Rogers, J.L. Janney, M.H. Ebinger, R.E. Askins, D.A. Flanigan, "Mechanistic Condensed Phase Deuterium Isotope Effect Analysis in Decomposition, Explosion, and Combustion In—Situ Rate—Controlling Step Identification", 17th Annual International ICT Conference Analysis of... 

Another use of isotopically labeled reactants is for study of kinetic isotope effects [40,41]. The difference in zero-point energies between isotopes results in a difference in bond energies and thus in a difference in activation energies and reaction rates. The largest difference is that between hydrogen and deuterium. The effect can be of help especially in the identification of a rate-controlling step. 

Oki, S. and Mezaki, R. Identification of rate-controlling steps for the water-gas shift reaction over an iron oxide catalyst. The Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1973, 77, 447. 

Many experimental criteria have been suggested for identification of the rate-controlling step. The majority are based on curve fitting to idealized rate laws and are unreliable. The two best methods are the so-called interruption test and the determination of the dependence of (he rate on particle. size. 

The most important step in design of a commercial multiphase reactor is identification of the rate-controlling step on the large scale. Further, it requires a rate expression for this rate-controlling step in terms of known parameters. 

Smit, B.A., Engels, W.J.M., and Wouters, J.T.M. (2004) Diversity of L-leucine catabolism in various microorganisms involved in dairy fermentations, and identification of the rate-controlling step in the formation of the potent flavour component 3-methylbutanal. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol 64, 396-402. 

Without trapping. P is the product with T added, a new product Q is also formed. The identification of Q by isolation or by spectroscopy serves in the first instance to verify that the reaction really does proceed by way of an intermediate. Controls must be used to show that Q does not arise from P, as in P + T — Q. Also, but not quite so simply, one must show that Q does not arise from a direct reaction, A + T — Q. To verify that the step A — I is rate-controlling, one may attempt to show that Q forms at a rate vq = Ai [A], which is the same as vp when [T] = 0. Also, if different traps (T, T2,...) are used, the experimental rate constant will remain the same, independent of the trap chosen, when the first step is rate-controlling. 

I expect that SA of stochastic and multiscale models will be important in traditional tasks such as the identification of rate-determining steps and parameter estimation. I propose that SA will also be a key tool in controlling errors in information passing between scales. For example, within a multiscale framework, one could identify what features of a coarse-level model are affected from a finer scale model and need higher-level theory to improve accuracy of the overall multiscale simulation. Next a brief overview of SA for deterministic systems is given followed by recent work on SA of stochastic and multiscale systems. 

Simple salt reactants (131 entries). Articles concerned with decompositions of simple salts were often concerned with kinetic characteristics, many used non-isothermal data, and stoichiometric information was provided for some of these chemical changes. Several of these studies were concerned with determining trends of behaviour through comparisons between related salts. Detailed descriptions of the chemical steps and identifications of the rate-controlling processes in the mechanisms were less frequently provided. A small proportion of the papers was concerned with previously well-studied reactions such as the dissociations of carbonates (13 entries), including the effects of procedural variables on the decompositions of CaCOj (4 entries) and of dolomite (5 entries). 

Recently, more systematic and rigorous approaches have been used to study the influence of various individual parameters on the rate of reaction. They allow one to formulate rate equations in terms of the effect of the concentrations of individual components. In turn, the rate dependence with respect to the concentration of reactants and products participating in the dissolution and reprecipitation reactions permits the identification of the mechanism and the elementary steps responsible for the rate control of the various kinetic processes involved. 

Identification and quantification of the desired reaction conditions, particularly temperature and concentration, are necessary to evaluate what may happen if these conditions are not met. This is particularly true where equilibrium considerations are a significant factor in a rate determining step between or among competing reactions. Where multiple products are possible, temperature variations will often significantly alter the ratios of these products. If one of these is unstable or more toxic, this could lead to more stringent temperature control requirements in the process and equipment design. 

If, instead of contracting out, one is concerned with managing a testing laboratory, then the situation is considerably more complex. The factors and activities involved are outlined below. Within these steps are rate-limiting factors that are invariably due to some critical point or pathway. Identification of such critical factors is one of the first steps for a manager to take to establish effective control over either a facility or program. 

For effective control of crystallizers, multivariable controllers are required. In order to design such controllers, a model in state space representation is required. Therefore the population balance has to be transformed into a set of ordinary differential equations. Two transformation methods were reported in the literature. However, the first method is limited to MSNPR crystallizers with simple size dependent growth rate kinetics whereas the other method results in very high orders of the state space model which causes problems in the control system design. Therefore system identification, which can also be applied directly on experimental data without the intermediate step of calculating the kinetic parameters, is proposed. 

In this work, the influences of two different sets of manipulated inputs have been compared in the case of linear model predictive control of a simulated moving bed. The first one consisting in direct manipulation of flow rates of the SMB showed a very satisfactory behavior for set point tracking and feed disturbance rejection. The second one consists in manipulating the flow rates ratios over each SMB section. At the identification stage, this strategy proved to be more delicate as the step responses displayed important dynamic differences of the responses. However, when the disturbance concerns the feed flow rate, a better behavior is obtained whereas a feed concentration disturbance is more badly rejected. 

---