Racemic three-phase separation

Fig. 3.5-2 Resolution of a racemic ester using lipase hydrolysis followed by a three-phase separation.

The assumed element of PCT symmetry along the interface implies a closed one-sided space, wrapped around an interface that separates regions of opposed chirality. As known from the spontaneous resolution of racemates, chirality can be the driving force of phase separation. Objects with two-dimensional chirality can interconvert in three dimensions. 

To prevent interference by ChiroCLEC, the acyl carrier intended for phosphine activation (the mixed mesitoate anhydride 212) was placed on an insoluble solid support where it can be accessed by the soluble phosphine, but not by the insoluble ChiroCLEC. Under three phase conditions, interference was prevented because the phosphine does not activate vinyl pivalate, the acyl donor intended for activation by ChiroCLEC in the form of an activated ester 214 nor does the activated acylphosphonium species 213 come into contact with the ChiroCLEC. Potential destruction of the lipase catalyst is thereby avoided, and the enantio-complementary activated intermediates convert the racemic alcohol R,S)-7 into the solid phase-bound ester 215 and the soluble pivalate 216 with excellent enantioselectivity. This is a proof-of-concept experiment that demonstrates the most difficult application, the case where two similar catalytic reactions are conducted in parallel. Furthermore, the experiment demonstrates PKR with the incorporation of achiral subunits to achieve enantiodivergence, and achieves product separation by simple filtration. 

Alak and Armstrong (107,108,112,113) investigated the influence of different silicas and binders on the separation behavior of P-cyclodextrin TLC plates. Besides nine racemates, three diastereomeric compounds and six structural isomers were separated. Wilson (109) impregnated silica plates with a 1% solution of P-CD in ethanol-dimethylsulfoxide (80 20 by volume) racemic mandelic acid was barely separated, and the antipode separation of P-blockers was not possible. Armstrong et al. (110) were the first to describe application of P-cyclodextrin as a chiral eluent additive for separations on reversed-phase TLC plates. The success of separation was strongly dependent on type and quantity of modifier applied, but above all on the concentration of P-CD. The low solubility of 3-CD in water (0.017 M, 2S C) can be improved by addition of urea sodium chloride stabilizes the binder of the RP plates. Compared to 3-CD bonded phases, a reversed retention behavior was noticed, the D-enantiomer eluting above the L-isomer. The separation of steroid epimers and other diastereomeric classes of compounds is also possible with this technique. Hydroxypropyl and hydroxyethyl P-... 

Racemic species contain equal amounts of two enantiomers and raise various issues concerning how to count the number of substances present in a sample. Most racemic species are distinct compounds (racemates) one solid compound forms, because heterochiral interactions dominate. Racemic molecules (or complexes ) may exist in the liquid state. Enantiomers may also form solid solutions or racemic conglomerates. The latter are eutectic mixtures of (-h) and (—) enantiomers two separate solid phases form, each crystal type comprises a single enantiomer (because homochiral interactions dominate). In practice, spectra of racemic and enantiomeric forms are indistinguishable, although one would be inclined to consider the racemate and the separate enantiomers as three different species. In the solid state, properties such as melting point, solubility behaviour, and density are different for the racemate and the respective enantiomers. Hence, some of their thermodynamic properties must be different. 

Three general methods exist for the resolution of enantiomers by Hquid chromatography (qv) (47,48). Conversion of the enantiomers to diastereomers and subsequent column chromatography on an achiral stationary phase with an achiral eluant represents a classical method of resolution (49). Diastereomeric derivatization is problematic in that conversion back to the desired enantiomers can result in partial racemization. For example, (lR,23, 5R)-menthol (R)-mandelate (31) is readily separated from its diastereomer but ester hydrolysis under numerous reaction conditions produces (R)-(-)-mandehc acid (32) which is contaminated with (3)-(+)-mandehc acid (33). 

Appllca.tlons. The first widely appHcable Ic separation of enantiomeric metallocene compounds was demonstrated on P-CD bonded-phase columns. Thirteen enantiomeric derivatives of ferrocene, mthenocene, and osmocene were resolved (7). Retention data for several of these compounds are listed in Table 2, and Figure 2a shows the Ic separation of three metallocene enantiomeric pairs. P-Cyclodextrin bonded phases were used to resolve several racemic and diastereomeric 2,2-binaphthyldiyl crown ethers (9). These compounds do not contain a chiral carbon but stiU exist as enantiomers because of the staggered position of adjacent naphthyl rings, and a high degree of chiral recognition was attained for most of these compounds (9). 

When solid-phase peptide synthesis was initially being developed, the question of whether or not a separate neutralization step is necessary was considered. Since it was known from the work of others that the chloride ion promotes racemization during the coupling step in classical peptide synthesis, and since we were deprotecting the Boc group with HC1, it seemed advisable to neutralize the hydrochloride by treatment with TEA and to remove chloride by filtration and washing. This short, additional step was simple and convenient and became the standard protocol. Subsequently, we became aware of three other reasons why neutralization was desirable (1) to avoid weak acid catalysis of piperazine-2,5-dione formation, 49 (2) to avoid acid-catalyzed formation of pyroglutamic acid (5-oxopyr-rolidine-2-carboxylic acid), 50 and (3) to avoid amidine formation between DCC and pro-tonated peptide-resin. The latter does not occur with the free amine. 

Cyclodextrin-based CSPs are among the most popular materials used for the chiral resolution of racemic compounds. These CSPs have a wide range of applications because they can be used successfully in all three mobile phase modes normal, reversed, and polar organic. There are numerous examples of chiral separations on CDs and CSPs based on their derivatives. Some of the important chiral separations are discussed herein. 

Chromatographic enantioseparation of chiral xenobiotics and their metabolites is a versatile tool for process studies in marine and terrestrial ecosystems [235]. In 1994, three papers focused on the enantioselective determination of toxaphene components [120,236,237]. Buser and Muller found that technical toxaphene mixtures are not necessarily racemic [237]. This observation was supported after isolation of non-racemic B7-1453 from the product Melipax which had an excess of ca. 25% of the dextrorotary enantiomer [27, 238]. The enantioselective separation of toxaphene components is almost restricted to chiral stationary phases (CSPs) based on randomly derivatized ferf-butyldimethyl-silylated /1-cyclodextrin (commercially available from BGB Analytik, Adliswil, Switzerland). So far, only a few toxaphene components were enantioseparated on other CSPs [239, 240]. Some of these CSPs are not well defined as well, and for this reason a test mixture called CHIROTEST X was suggested for initial column testing [241],... 

The mobile phase plays a crucial role in the separation process for at least three main reasons. The selectivity of the separation, retention time, and solubility of the racemate are directly affected by the mobile phase composition. Other parameters such as viscosity, solvent recovery, cost, and solvent handling properties also play a prominent role. This brief introduction is also applicable to the criteria for CSP selection for SMB. 

---