Quantum mechanical descriptions of molecules

At the same time that Heisenberg was formulating his approach to the helium system, Born and Oppenheimer indicated how to formulate a quantum mechanical description of molecules that justified approximations already in use in treatment of band spectra. The theory was worked out while Oppenheimer was resident in Gottingen and constituted his doctoral dissertation. Born and Oppenheimer justified why molecules could be regarded as essentially fixed particles insofar as the electronic motion was concerned, and they derived the "potential" energy function for the nuclear motion. This approximation was to become the "clamped-nucleus" approximation among quantum chemists in decades to come.36... 

In the quantum mechanical description of molecules (atoms and clusters) one problem has been the identification and validity of adiabatic separations of electronic ip) md nuclear (R) coordinates [30] This problem has been with us ever since the Bom-Oppenheimer (BO) theory was published in 1927 [1,2]. But this approach, as implemented in quantum chemistry, has serious deceiving aspects. 

It is relatively easy to talk and gesture about how chemistry either does or does not reduce to physics. It is much harder to spell out exactly what is required to make good on the claim that chemistry does (or does not) reduce to physics. Philosophers have a concept of supervenience. In the case we are focused on here chemistry putatively reducing to physics—supervenience requires that every chemical change be accompanied by a physical change. This is nearly universally held, for example, if two molecules are identical in all physical respects, they will not differ chemically. However, supervenience is not sufficient for the reduction of chemistry to physics. There could be downward causation, where it is the chemical facts and laws that drive the physical facts and laws, not the other way around. Robin Hendry (Chapter 9) argues that those committed to the reducibility of chemistry to physics have not ruled out the possibility of downward causation, and moreover, he presents substantial evidence from the manner in which quantum mechanical descriptions for molecules are constructed and deployed by chemists in favor of downward causation. Quantum mechanical descriptions of molecules that have explanatory and descriptive power are constructed from chemical—not physical—considerations and evidence. Here in precise terms, we see chemistry supervenient on physics, but still autonomous, not reducible to physics. 

A more rigorous definition of a biradicaloid geometry employs the concept of natural orbitals and their occupancies, which are well defined at all levels of quantum mechanical description of molecules in the Born-Oppenheimer approximation at a biradicaloid geometry, two of the ground state natural orbital occupation munbers are approximately equal to unity (the others, of course, are close to two or close to zero). 

In general, quantum mechanical descriptions of molecules imply that we may explore three types of molecular features structural parameters, energy or energies of molecular states, and responses to perturbations. The last of... 

This same tactic was applied to the analysis of chemical reaction dynamics. Lacking a complete quantum mechanical description of molecules, chemists recognized that they could alter the electronic structure of a molecule by functionalizing it with nonparticipating substituents. The degree to which the substituents perturbed a molecule s electronic structure could be assessed via spectroscopy and made quantitative in the form of a so-called substituent parameter (cf. Hammett, 1970). The prineipal requirement of the chosen spectroscopic parameter is that it be... 

This discussion may well leave one wondering what role reality plays in computation chemistry. Only some things are known exactly. For example, the quantum mechanical description of the hydrogen atom matches the observed spectrum as accurately as any experiment ever done. If an approximation is used, one must ask how accurate an answer should be. Computations of the energetics of molecules and reactions often attempt to attain what is called chemical accuracy, meaning an error of less than about 1 kcal/mol. This is suf-hcient to describe van der Waals interactions, the weakest interaction considered to affect most chemistry. Most chemists have no use for answers more accurate than this. 

Unfortunately, the Schrodinger equation for multi-electron atoms and, for that matter, all molecules cannot be solved exactly and does not lead to an analogous expression to Equation 4.5 for the quantised energy levels. Even for simple atoms such as sodium the number of interactions between the particles increases rapidly. Sodium contains 11 electrons and so the correct quantum mechanical description of the atom has to include 11 nucleus-electron interactions, 55 electron-electron repulsion interactions and the correct description of the kinetic energy of the nucleus and the electrons - a further 12 terms in the Hamiltonian. The analysis of many-electron atomic spectra is complicated and beyond the scope of this book, but it was one such analysis performed by Sir Norman Lockyer that led to the discovery of helium on the Sun before it was discovered on the Earth. 

Wavefunction The quantum mechanical description of a system such as an atom or molecule. Information about the system is derived by operating on the wavefunction with the appropriate operator. 

In the quantum-mechanical description of atoms and molecules, electrons have characteristics of waves as well as particles. In the familiar case of the hydrogen atom, the orbitals Is, 2s, 2p,... describe the different possible standing wave patterns of electron distribution, for a single electron moving in the potential field of a proton. The motion of the electrons in any atom or molecule is described as fully as possibly by a set of wave functions associated with the ground and excited states. 

An understanding of the structure of molecules requires a proper quantum mechanical description of the covalent bond that cannot be captured by the use of central pair potentials. We therefore extend our linear combination of atomic orbitals (LCAO) treatment of the s-valent dimer to three-, four-, five-, and six-atom molecules respectively. Following eqs (3.46) and (4.17), we write the binding energy per atom for an. -atom molecule as... 

If a solution, being in contact with an electrode, contains photosensitive atoms or molecules, irradiation of such a system may lead to photoelectro-chemical reactions or, to be more exact, electrochemical reactions with excited particles involved. In such reactions the electrons pass either from an excited particle to the electrode (the anodic process) or from the electrode to an excited particle (the cathodic process). In this case, an elementary act of charge transfer has much in common with ordinary (dark) electrochemical redox reactions, which opens a possibility of interpreting certain aspects of photochemical processes under consideration with the use of concepts developed for general quantum mechanical description of electrode processes. 

For a pulse-type NMR experiment, the assumption has a straightforward interpretation, since the pulse applied at the moment zero breaks down the dynamic history of the spin system involved. The reasoning presented here, which leads to the equation of motion in the form of equation (72), bears some resemblance to Kaplan and Fraenkel s approach to the quantum-mechanical description of continuous-wave NMR. (39) The crucial point in our treatment is the introduction of the probabilities izUa which are expressed in terms of pseudo-first-order rate constants. This makes possible a definition of the mean density matrix pf of a molecule at the moment of its creation, even for complicated multi-reaction systems. The definition of the pf matrix makes unnecessary the distinction between intra- and inter-molecular spin exchange which has so far been employed in the literature. 

The molecule is often represented as a polarizable point dipole. A few attempts have been performed with finite size models, such as dielectric spheres [64], To the best of our knowledge, the first model that joined a quantum mechanical description of the molecule with a continuum description of the metal was that by Hilton and Oxtoby [72], They considered an hydrogen atom in front of a perfect conductor plate, and they calculated the static polarizability aeff to demonstrate that the effect of the image potential on aeff could not justify SERS enhancement. In recent years, PCM has been extended to systems composed of a molecule, a metal specimen and possibly a solvent or a matrix embedding the metal-molecule system in a molecularly shaped cavity [62,73-78], In particular, the molecule was treated at the Hartree-Fock, DFT or ZINDO level, while for the metal different models have been explored for SERS and luminescence calculations, metal aggregates composed of several spherical particles, characterized by the experimental frequency-dependent dielectric constant. For luminescence, the effects of the surface roughness and the nonlocal response of the metal (at the Lindhard level) for planar metal surfaces have been also explored. The calculation of static and dynamic electrostatic interactions between the molecule, the complex shaped metal body and the solvent or matrix was done by using a BEM coupled, in some versions of the model, with an IEF approach. 

For the respective quantum mechanical description of a molecule in a stationary state, a few additional aspects need to be addressed. First, the system state is characterized by a wavefunction VP, and system properties, such as the total energy or dipole moment, are calculated through integration of VP with the relevant operator in a distinct way. Note that an operator is simply an instruction to do some mathematical operation such as multiplication or differentiation, and generally (but not always) the order in which such calculations are performed affects the final result. Second, the wavefunctions V obey the Schrodinger equation ... 

Twenty years have passed since the publication of the original paper by Woolley [3] in which the incompatibility of the molecular structure concept with the rigorous quantum-mechanical description of isolated molecules has been eloquently brought to the attention of chemists. The ensuing flurry of research publications clarified several misconceptions but did little to familiarize the broader scientific audience with this important issue. Regretfully, few quantum or computational chemists are aware of these papers, which are nowadays seldom discussed or quoted. 

The quantum-mechanical description of a polyatomic system may be extrapolated from the treatment of the diatomic molecule. Starting again with the harmonic oscillator, the energy levels for the entire system (E) can be given in terms of the characteristic frequencies (v,) and quantum numbers ( ,) of a series of independent harmonic oscillators ... 

The previous chapters have focused on different methods for obtaining more or less accurate solutions to the Schrodinger equation. The natural by-product of determining the electronic wave function is the energy however, there are many other properties that may be derived. Although the quantum mechanical description of a molecule is in terms of positive nuclei surrounded by a cloud ofmegative electrons, chemistry is still formulated as atoms held together by bonds . This raises questions... 

A theory is only justified by its ability to account for observed behaviour. It is important, therefore, to note that the theory of atoms in molecules is a result of observations made on the properties of the charge density. These observations give rise to the realization that a quantum mechanical description of the properties of the topological atom is not only possible but is also necessary, for the observations are explicable only if the virial theorem applies to an atom in a molecule. The original observations are among the most important of the properties exhibited by the atoms of theory (Bader and Beddall 1972). For this reason and for the purpose of emphasizing the observational basis of the theory, these original observations are now summarized. They provide an introduction to the consequences of a quantum mechanical description of an atom in a molecule. 

A unified fully quantum mechanical description of all of the diverse radiationless phenomena has been presented. This provides an understanding of the dissipative and nondissipative aspects associated with radiationless processes in small, large, and intermediate case molecules. The full rate expression is analyzed to provide the observed energy gap law and the associated isotope effects. The theory is generalized to treat nonradiative decay rates in dense media and to evaluate the dependence of these rates on particular selected vibronic states. The relevance of this theory to the study of photochemical processes is also noted. 

---