Selectivity prediction

Selectivity of chromatographic separation is known to be varied by changing both the nonstationary phase composition and adsorbent nature. It is shown that the less are the values of the reached selectivity coefficient the higher are the requirements to column effectiveness. In this connection the choice of stationai y phase with high and predicted selectivity coefficient for the compounds being separated is still remains a topical problem of high-performance liquid chromatography. 

Hence our analysis and prediction, selected Tor logical clarity, reverse the actual chronology. Our prediction of the visible spectrum from the ultraviolet spectrum is more straightforward than was the reverse prediction. Notice that the ultraviolet spectrum utilizes all of the notches involved in producing the visible spectrum. In contrast, none of the visible frequencies involves notch 1, the key to the ultraviolet spectrum. 

Bakke et al. (1982) have shown how montmorillonite catalyses chlorination and nitration of toluene nitration leads to 56 % para and 41 % ortho derivative compared to approximately 40 % para and 60 % ortho derivatives in the absence of the catalyst. Montmorillonite clays have an acidity comparable to nitric acid / sulphuric acid mixtures and the use of iron-exchanged material (Clayfen) gives a remarkable improvement in the para, ortho ratio in the nitration of phenols. The nitration of estrones, which is relevant in making various estrogenic drugs, can be improved in a remarkable way by using molecular engineered layer structures (MELS), while a reduction in the cost by a factor of six has been indicated. With a Clayfen type catalyst, it seems possible to manipulate the para, ortho ratio drastically for a variety of substrates and this should be useful in the manufacture of fine chemicals. In principle, such catalysts may approach biomimetic chemistry our ability to predict selectivity is very limited. 

The cumulated Jt-system of allenes has been described as consisting of two comparatively unperturbed double bonds with regard to its reactivity towards nucleophiles or electrophiles [10]. Early reports on radical additions to 1,2-dienes, however, already pointed to peculiarities of the allene system concerning its reactivity towards intermediates with unpaired electrons [11-14], It was soon realized that no such correlation between polar and steric substituent effects existed, similar to what had been uncovered for the reaction of radicals with olefins, in order to predict selectivities in radical additions to cumulated dienes [4, 15],... 

In recent years, interest in radical-based transformations of allenes has been renewed for two major reasons. First, a number of useful intramolecular additions of carbon-centered radicals to 1,2-dienes have been reported, which allowed syntheses of complex natural product-derived target molecules to be accomplished in instances where other methods have failed to provide similar selectivities. Further, a large body of kinetic and thermochemical data has become accessible from results of experimental and theoretical investigations in order to predict selectivities in addition reactions to allenes more precisely. Such contributions originated predominantly from (i) studies directed towards an understanding of the incineration process,... 

Figure 11.4 Models and guidelines for predicting selectivities in radical additions to allenes. R = H and/or alkyl, OH, SCgHs, CO2CH3. X = CX3 (X= H, F, Cl), C2H5, CH(CH3)2, Sn(CH3)3, SC6H5, SeC6H5, Cl, Br.

Figure 13.3 (a) Plot of selectivity score versus promiscuity score applied to MDDR. Red dots are marketed drugs. Marketed drugs clearly cluster when compared to other compounds in different drug discovery phases (green dots), (b) The predicted selectivity of compounds in different phases of the drug discovery process. 

Ab initio calculations have also been used to predict selectivity in such cycloadditions (112,113,118). These smdies show that the reactants approach each other in a plane with the two new bonds forming at the same time, which appears to be concerted although not necessarily synchronous. Only one energetically favored transition state was found, and the average lengths of the newly forming bonds are scarcely affected by the presence of substiments on the alkene moiety. This result... 

To control the step size adaptively we need an estimate of the local truncation error. With the Runge - Kutta methods a good idea is to take each step twice, using formulas of different order, and judge the error from the deviation between the two predictions. Selecting the coefficients in (5.20) to give the same a j and d values in the two formulas at least for some of the internal function evaluations reduces the overhead in calculation. For example, 6 function evaluations are required with an appropriate pair of fourth-order and fifth-order formulas (ref. 5). 

An interesting test for the validity of this simple model is to predict selectivities in the pentene system. According to the carbonium ion model the reaction path for this system should be as follows ... 

Selectivity is more important than efficiency (AO in determining resolution because Rs is directly proportional to selectivity, but is proportional only to the square root of efficiency (see Fig. B4.2.5 along with Equation B4.2.1 and Equation B4.2.2. Hence, a four-fold increase in efficiency is required to double resolution, as compared with a two-fold increase in selectivity. In practice, selectivity depends partly on the chromatographic technique employed but can usually be controlled by manipulating experimental conditions, such as the pH and ionic strength of the mobile phase. Because this can be done easily and predictably, selectivity is the factor that is exploited to achieve maximum resolution in column chromatography rather than efficiency, which is fixed by the particle size and uniformity of the medium selected. 

It is instructive now to turn to the correlation diagrams in Figures 11.11 and 11.12 for conrotatory and disrotatory closure of hexatriene, a six tt electron system. The disrotatory mode is now allowed, the conrotatory forbidden. If correlation diagrams for larger systems are constructed, it will be found that with each addition of two carbons and an electron pair the predicted selectivity will reverse. 

Skeie, S., Feten, G., Almpy, T., 0stlie, FI., and Isaksson, T. (2006). The use of near infrared spectroscopy to predict selected free amino acids during cheese ripening. Int. Dairy. J. 16, 236-242. 

On this restricted basis, transition metal phosphines have been modeled with accuracies similar to those of other metal-heteroatom systems11531. A number of phosphine complexes are of interest in the area of asymmetric syntheses. Due to the requirement that the geometry and the force field of the relevant intermediates have to be known for a thorough study (see Chapter 7, Section 7.4) most of the reports in this area are only of a qualitative nature. Some of the investigations are based on molecular graphics analyses, and the evaluation of the predicted selectivity has been based on van der Waals terms alone[53,233,2341. 

D. Haring and P. Schreier, Chemical engineering of enzymes altered catalytic activity, predictable selectivity and exceptional stability of the semisynthetic peroxidase seleno-subtilisin, Naturwissenschafien 1999, 86, 307-312. 

The syn-addition of hydroboranes to alkenes occurs with predictable selectivity, wherein the boron adds preferentially to the least hindered carbon. This selectivity is enhanced if sterically demanding boranes are used. 

These studies of reduction of benzenoid aromatics reveal that the solvent, the electrolyte cation, the current density and the water content are all important variables. In general it is important to have a rather negative potential (large TAA+) and a proton source (water) present under conditions where hydrogen evolution or attack on the solvent does not occur. Under such conditions difunctional molecules can be selectively reduced by control over the number of Faradays/mole which are passed. This kind of predictable selectivity should give the electrochemical method real advantage over alkali metal reductions and the possibility to use materials other than liquid ammonia and alkali metal is quite attractive. 

Tanaka has shown that in his synthesis of a variety of diastereomeric annonac-eous acetogenins (9, Scheme 3) the carbinol stereocenter can be generated with predictable selectivity by reagent control of either enantiomer of the chiral ligand [24], He applied this method in the total synthesis of murisolin (9, n= 1), a member of family of over 350 natural polyketides isolated from various annon-aceaes plants (Scheme 4). 

A useful generality in predicting selectivity is that the rate of hydrogenation falls, both absolutely and competitively, as steric hinderance around the double bond is increased (23). On this basis in a mixture of olefins, terminal olefins would be expected to be saturated preferentially to internal olefins, if a prior rapid equilibration by isomerization did not ensue. 

Cherkauer, K. J. Shavlik, J. W. (1993). Protein structure prediction selecting salient features from large candidate pools. Ismb 1,74-82. 

The log Ofj term reflects the differences in capacity ratios of the two peptide solutes Sj and Sj which differ by a functional group and is analogous to the term used to predict selectivity differences for the classical liquid-liquid partition chromatography of peptides. The influence of functional group behavior on the retention of polar solutes in reversed-phase HPLC has been the subject of several recent articles and similar trends are apparent with peptide derivatives (29-31). 

Semi-empirical approaches are available to predict selected solid-state properties of thermoplastics from molecular structure. Example predictions for about 30 types of thermoplastics, including SAN copolymers, may be found elsewhere [34]. 

In summary, the asymmetric osmylation of alkenes catalyzed by derivatives of cinchona alkaloids represents a very elegant method which enables the enantioselective cis dihydroxylation of several types of alkenes in high enantiomeric excess and with predictable selectivities. The design of specific chiral ligands for substrates that still do not afford enantiomeric excesses over 90% would be desirable for the near future. 

The activity coefficient ratio in the resin phase which is the important selectivity determining factor is not obtainable by conventional means, but its determination by indirect methods forms the basis of understanding and predicting selectivity by the conventional thermodynamic approach. 

One of the earliest, and reasonably successful, approaches to quantitatively predicting selectivity behaviour was through the thermodynamic treatment of ion exchange systems as a Gibbs-Donnan membrane equilibrium. Such a description is given by equation 5.29 which for the sake of simplicity is shown in terms of single ion activity coefficients ... 

This simple relationship was derived before as equation 5.24, and was first used by Bauman and Eichorn in 1947 to predict selectivity sequences for simple monovalent cations from mean ionic activity coefficient data for pure aqueous electrolyte solutions containing a common anion. The inaccessibility of resin phase activity coefficients to direct measurement always remains a problem with thermodynamic equilibrium treatments. Therefore Glueckauf and others developed weight swelling and isopiestic water vapour sorption techniques to determine osmotic coefficients of pure salt forms of a resin, from which the mean ionic activity coefficients of mixed resinates could be computed using a modified form of Harned s Rule. Such studies predicted selectivity coefficient values which were in fair agreement with experiment and also demonstrated the fixed ion of the resin to be osmotically inactive. 

---