Heuristic Considerations

In the following text (Section III.3) we discuss the electrochemical response of the cells (3-6) with a mixed conductor as the central 

Immediately after switching-on a constant current both ions and electrons do flow according to their transference numbers while the voltage increases from zero to IRx (or more precisely to I(RX + R )). With increasing time the partial current of the blocked species decreases, and eventually vanishes leading to a steady state in which the total current is carried only by the nonblocked species, i.e., the electrons in cells 3 and 4 or the ions in cells 5 and 6. Hence the steady state reveals the conductivity of the nonblocked species. The comparison with the total conductivity (e.g., obtained from the IR-drop at the beginning of the experiment) also yields the conductivity of the blocked species. 

If we switch-off the current after the steady state has been reached, the voltage relaxes to the initial zero-level. The electrical behavior can be taken into account by introducing in the simple equivalent circuit (eqc) (Eq. (60)) a capacitor Cl in series to Rioa or to R,.ml (if ions or electrons are blocked) In the language of system theory the equivalent circuit of the bulk represents a PDTi-element and reads3 15 e.g., for cells 3 and 4 Par (Cx. Par (Rm , Ser ( AJrai, Cl))). 

The simple equivalent circuit (eqc) which reads for ion blocking as 

In the case of electron blocking the indices eon and ion have to be exchanged, but also the total equivalent circuit has to be complemented by circuit elements that take account of the bulk impedance of the blocking electrodes (e.g., YSZ). 

---

Intuitively, one can imagine that the field generated by an arbitrary source, located within a bounded domain of space, can be approximated accurately enough by a spherical wave at a large distance from the source. We can expect, therefore, that the asymptotic behavior of this field at infinity in the case of divergent and convergent waves can be characterized by formulae (13.161) and (13.162) as well. These heuristic considerations provide a basis for choosing only those solutions of the problem defined by (13.155) and (13.156) which satisfy additionally condition (13.161). 

When the value of the objective function at the global optimum, < >nj , is known we may obtain a reasonable stopping criterion from the following heuristic considerations. Assume that (J> is smooth and = 0 at X = 0 near X = 0, 4> may be approximated with ... 

Let us try to give a rough estimate on the constant Br, using heuristic considerations on the recursive system (2). For definiteness, let us refer to the case of the invariant torus the case of an elliptic equilibrium is very similar. Every step requires two operations, namely ... 

This suggests that any correction factor which will cause the holdup data for shear-thinning fluids to collapse onto the Newtonian curve, must become progressively smaller as the liquid velocity increases and the flow behaviour index, n, decreases. Based on such intuitive and heuristic considerations, Farooqi and Richardson [1982] proposed a correction factor, J, to be applied to the Lockhart-Martinelli parameter, x, so that a modified parameter Xmod is defined as ... 

Of course, the heuristic considerations represented by Fig. 3.1 cannot prove the rule rigorously. To obtain such proof, we can formulate the mathematical problem to be solved as follows ... 

Comparing it with a characteristic time (Eq. 5.10) obtained from dimension considerations, we can see that they differ by some constant coefficient close to 2jt. Hence, our heuristic considerations as for the effect of coupling were good enough. This important fact allows us for qualitative prediction of possible complicated... 

And other heuristic guides could kick in to give plausible, but never deductively derived, predictions . (So, for example, Paneth in the 1920s used simple reasoning based on the Periodic Table to predict that then undiscovered hafnium would occur in the same ores as zirconium. This is nonetheless a considerably looser notion of prediction than applies to standard cases from physics. See Scerri, 1994). 

The conventional approach to optimize a heterogeneous catalytic process is based on heuristics, and trial and error, which could take a considerable amount... 

Until recently, advances in calculating the free energy were not accompanied by comparable progress in rigorous error analysis and reduction. Although a variety of methods to estimate the error in calculated free energies were proposed [32, 106], they were usually somewhat heuristic or involved approximations that were not always sufficiently well supported. Only recently, considerable progress has been made on this front, in particular by Daniel Zuckerman and Thomas Woolf [107]. 

The heuristic value of equation (3) is that we can see what is required for a good initiator D and I(R ) must be as large a possible, and AHS(R+) should be small compared to AHS(RI>1+) in other words, as an efficient initiator we need a large cation whose parent radical has a high ionisation potential, and which forms a strong bond to monomer. On the last two counts the trityl cation must be one of the least suitable. These considerations indicate that the first four ions listed in Table 1 should merit detailed study as initiators for vinyl polymerisations. 

It appears therefore that although the fundamental basis of our considerations is not new, the use which we have made of the energetic analysis provides a better insight into the factors determining the electrochemical properties of organic cations in other words it is heuristically more useful. 

Up to now, we have seen how the "heuristic principles" can be applied to both linear and cyclic systems which we could call "normal systems". When some unusual structural features -such as quaternary carbon atoms, medium-sized rings or bridged systems- are found in the molecular structure under consideration, one may assume that they are derived either from a rearrangement or from an internal fragmentation [1]. 

As the nature of chemistry space depends upon the way in which compounds are represented, an absolute or universal chemistry space does not exist. Thus, any procedure that utilizes chemistry space may be subject to considerable uncertainty, and the results obtained in different chemistry spaces are likely to differ, sometimes in quite significant ways. This rather daunting circumstance has necessitated the use of practical, heuristic approaches that, while imperfect, have nevertheless performed in a reasonably satisfactory manner over the last three years. During this period about 120000 diverse, quality compounds have been added to our corporate compound collection. This does not include the many compounds obtained from combinatorially derived libraries and special target-directed (e.g., kinase) libraries. 

---