Fock space multireference coupled-cluster

L. Meissner and R. J. Bartlett, J. Chem. Phys., 94, 6670 (1991). Transformation of the Hamiltonian in Excitation Energy Calculations Comparison Between Fock-Space Multireference Coupled-Cluster and Equation-of-Motion Coupled-Cluster Methods. 

J. F. Stanton, R. J. Bartlett, and C. M. L. Rittby,/. Chem. Phys., 97,5560 (1992). Fock Space Multireference Coupled-Cluster Theory for General Single Determinant Reference Functions. 

A Fock space multireference coupled cluster method was described by Rittby and Bartlett <91TCA469>, applied to the calculation of ionization potentials and excitation energies of 1,2,4,5-tetrazines, and compared with conventional ab initio calculations and experimental results. 

Multireference coupled cluster methods, which started development more recently, are generally divided into two types. Hilbert space CC methods use multiple reference functions to obtain a description of a few states, including the reference state (for a review see (4)). Fock space methods (for a review see (5)), on the other hand, provide direct state-to-state energy differences, relative to some common reference state. The Fock space approach is particularly well-suited to the calculation of ionization potentials (IPs), electron affinities (EAs), and excitation energies (EEs). For principal IPs and EAs, FSCC is equivalent (6, 7) to the EOM-IP and EOM-EA CC methods (1, 2, 7, 8). In this paper, we will focus primarily on the IP problem. 

By adopting the no-pair approximation, a natural and straightforward extension of the nonrelativistic open-shell CC theory emerges. The multireference valence-universal Fock-space coupled-cluster approach is employed [25], which defines and calculates an effective Hamiltonian in a low-dimensional model (or P) space, with eigenvalues approximating some desirable eigenvalues of the physical Hamiltonian. The effective Hamiltonian has the form [26]... 

In the Fock space coupled cluster method, the Hartree-Fock solution for an iV-electron state, 0), is used as the vacuum. The Fock space is divided into sectors, (m,n), according to how many electrons are added to and removed from 0). Thus, the vacuum is in the (0,0) sector, single ionizations are in the (0,1) sector, one-electron attached states are in (1,0), and (1,1) are single excitations relative to 0). The orbitals are also divided into active, which can change occupation, and inactive, for which the occupation is fixed. All possible occupations of the active orbitals in all possible sectors constitute the multireference space for the system. 

The results of three sets of Fock-space coupled cluster calculations using 2Ai CCh as the (0,0) reference are also displayed in Figure 1. FSCCSD gets the proper shape of the PES even without triple excitation effects, and the inclusion of triples makes small adjustments to the shape of the surface. (Note that, as in the IP calculations, the FSCCSD+T (3) results lie between FSCCSD and FSCCSD+T(3).) This behavior is what we might expect from a method that is designed in a multireference framework. 

Because of its size-extensivity and faster convergence with respect to excitation level Coupled cluster theory has replaced Cl theory as the dominant approach in ab initio correlation calculations. Like MBPT the theory is still mainly applied in cases where the exact wave function is dominated by a single determinant, but multireference methods have been formulated and begin to enter mainstream quantum chemistry. Generalization of the algorithms to the relativistic no-pair level can again be achieved via the spinorbital formulation of the methods. I will first discuss the single reference method and then consider the Fock space method [40] that uses multi-reference wavefiinctions for ionized or excited states. 

Studies of rare earth or transition metal complexes often necessitate use of multireference wave functions. Among the Coupled Cluster type methods one can distinguish two main lines of approach to incorporate multireference character in the reference wave function. In the Hilbert space method one computes a single wave function for a particular state, while in the Fock space method one tries to obtain a manifold of states simultaneously. Since the latter method [40] has recently been implemented and applied in conjunction with the relativistic Hamiltonian [48-50] we will focus on this approach. 

Figrire 8 An overview of quantum chemical methods for excited states. Bold-italic entries indicate methods that are currently applicable to large molecules. Important abbreviations used Cl (configuration Interaction), TD (time-dependent), CC (coupled-cluster), HF (Hartree-Fock), CAS (complete active space), RAS (restricted active space), MP (Moller-Plesset perturbation theory), S (singles excitation), SD (singles and doubles excitation), MR (multireference). Geometry optimizations of excited states for larger molecules are now possible with CIS, CASSCF, CC2, and TDDFT methods. 

In this section we will introduce some wavefunction-based methods to calculate photoabsorption spectra. The Hartree-Fock method itself is a wavefunction-based approach to solve the static Schrodinger equation. For excited states one has to account for time-dependent phenomena as in the density-based approaches. Therefore, we will start with a short review of time-dependent Hartree-Fock. Several more advanced methods are available as well, e.g. configuration interaction (Cl), multireference configuration interaction (MRCI), multireference Moller-Plesset (MRMP), or complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF), to name only a few. Also flavours of the coupled-cluster approach (equations-of-motion CC and linear-response CQ are used to calculate excited states. However, all these methods are applicable only to fairly small molecules due to their high computational costs. These approaches are therefore discussed only in a more phenomenological way here, and many post-Hartree-Fock methods are explicitly not included. 

For systems with more than two open shells, it is in general necessary to resort to multireference methods. This section has dealt only with state-specific coupled-cluster methods, also known as state-universal methods or Hilbert space methods, for which a considerable amount of effort has been expended on nonrelativistic multireference methods. The alternative, which is much more suited to multireference problems, is the valence-universal or Fock space method, which has been developed for relativistic systems by Kaldor and coworkers (Eliav and Kaldor 1996, Eliav et al. 1994, 1998, Visscher et al. 2001). 

---