Frequency Error

The information crisis , i.e., the fact that, because of the error frequency, longer RNA chains have so many errors after only a few reproduction steps that they can no longer be replicated, cries out for catalysts which can guarantee more exact replication. While only protein catalysts (enzymes) had been discussed until recently, ri-bozymes are now possible candidates. More complex catalysts would have required more complex matrices but where did the matrix molecules come from This serious problem, referred to by Eigen himself as an information crisis, is sometimes referred to as Eigen s dilemma (Blomberg, 1997). 

Williams KJ, Loeb LA. Retroviral reverse transcriptases Error frequencies and mutagenesis. Cun-Top Microbiol Immunol 1992 176 165-180. 

Professor Eigen s parameters of excess production, specificity, and error frequency are very useful in describing the process of change from a U-I code to the four letter triplet code we know today. 

In this way the erroneous incorporation of valine in place of isoleucine is avoided. The sequential action of aminoacylation and proofreading sites contributes to an overall error frequency of translation of less than 1 in 10,000. 

In the meantime, the methods presented here can at best give only an approximate value of Kpa. The potential error associated with these methods is more than an order of magnitude but, due to the limited database of measured KPA values, it is not possible to estimate the maximum error or the error frequency distribution associated with extrapolating these methods to plant species and chemical classes other than those used in the original experiments. 

It is often observed that when PCR products from ancient remains are cloned, they contain a large number of random substitutions which are believed to be due to damage present in extracted DNA.10 When this error frequency is compared to that of a control template of modem, presumably undamaged DNA, the increased number of errors itself may indicate that the PCR products stem from a damaged template and thus that it likely represents an old sequence.13 However, it should be remembered that if the presumed ancient sequence in reality stems from a contaminating modem sequence present in only a few copies, the PCR product will have gone through many more cycles of polymerization before the plateau phase of the amplification is reached. For example, if an amplification product contains twice as many errors as a control DNA amplified for 30 cycles, that result could be due to errors in the initial template or to the presence of template in a 10- to 100-fold lower concentration (A. von Haeseler and S. Paabo, unpublished, 1991). Thus, because the concentration of ancient DNA is hard or impossible to determine accurately, error rates in amplification products may be difficult to use as a criterion of authenticity. 

Minimizing the polymerase error rate by maintaining certain reaction parameters may not always be experimentally feasible, but some optimization of reaction conditions to maximize fidelity should always be considered when determining variability within a viral population by the PCR. In the absence of such optimization, knowing the expected error frequency of Taq polymerase under a given reaction condition will allow a more realistic assessment of viral population variance. To this end, the amplification and sequencing of an appropriate plasmid control template will serve as an... 

A major goal of directed evolution of DNA polymerases has been to elucidate the structural elements that confer high fidelity during DNA replication. If DNA polymerases were to rely solely on the stability of nucleotides that aligned with template for discrimination of correct template-directed polymerization, the error frequency would be in the order of one mispaired nucleotide per 100 incorporated [23], The measured error rate for incorporation and extension of a mismatched nucleotide attributable to DNA polymerases lacking an error correcting exonucleolytic activity range... 

A typical distribution of errors. The bar graph represents the actual error frequency distribution 73(e) for 376 measurements the estimated normal error probability function P(e) is given by the dashed curve. Estimated values of the standard deviation cr and the 95 percent confidence limit A are indicated in relation to the normal error curve. 

As Table 29.1 shows, an error frequency of 10 2 would be intolerable, even for quite small proteins. An e value of 10 3 would usually lead to the error-free synthesis of a 300-residue protein ( 33 kd) but not of a 1000-residue protein ( 110 kd). Thus, the error frequency must not exceed approximately 10 4 to produce the larger proteins effectively. Lower error frequencies are conceivable however, except for the largest proteins, they will not dramatically increase the percentage of proteins with accurate sequences. In addition, such lower error rates are likely to be possible only by a reduction in the rate of protein synthesis because additional time for proofreading will be required. In fact, the observed values of s are... 

Under optimal conditions for poly(phe) synthesis Sulfolobus ribosomes are highly accurate, the incorporation of a non-cognate amino acid (leucine) being approximately 0.3% that of the cognate one also, the error frequency in tRNA selection does not increase at temperatures (55 C) well below the temperature optimum of the system [66,125]. A less refined spermine- (thermine)-dependent Sulfolobus cell-free system has been described by Friedman [126] who used an unfractionated cell extract (S30). 

Stochastic errors with frequency much larger than />iy will appear as a stochastic error in the measurement whereas, stochastic errors with frequency much smaller than /n will appear as a bias error in the measurement. The significance of the bias error will depend on the comparison between the error frequency and the characteristic frequency of the entire measurement of the spectrum. 

As described above, activation of the editing system stalls replication at a thymine dimer. In SOS repair, the editing system is relaxed to allow polymerization to proceed across a dimer. Relaxation of the editing system means a loss of the ability to remove incorrect bases added to the growing strand. Most of the time, pol III inserts two adenines at a dimer site. However, the distortion increases the error frequency, allowing other nucleotides to be added to the chain. This error-prone repair is the major cause of UV-induced mutagenesis. 

Statistical concepts employed in setting specifications and their relationship to product quality control include accidental and systemic errors, frequency distributions, measures of dispersion, standard deviations, standard errors, and sampling plans. In summary, specifications must be set by taking into account... 

The Synthesis of Long Proteins Requires a Low Error Frequency... 

Unlike E. coli DNA polymerases, there is no 30 to 50 exonuclease proofreading activity in the E. coli RNA polymerase and, therefore, the error rate is relatively higher (-10-410-5). Since RNA represents only a transient copy of DNA, and is not inherited through the germ line, this error frequency is tolerable. As discussed in Chapter 30, viral RNA polymerases and another enzyme, reverse transcriptase, which also lacks proofreading activity, have error frequencies in the same range as the bacterial RNA polymerase. This mutation rate is most likely beneficial to some viruses because it results in frequent alterations in viral protein sequences and thus allows the virus to escape immune-system defenses in the host (Chapter 30). 

There are 20 different aminoacyl tRNA synthetases, each of which recognizes the various tRNAs and "charges" them with the appropriate amino acid. Several recognition steps in this aminoacylation reaction help to reduce the error frequency due to incorrect tRNA charging. Aminoacylation requires the hydrolysis of ATP AMP + 2Pi. 

The amount of a second distinct type of first-order adsorption in the presence of the first Differential moles Differential time Base of natural logarithms Total error in moles adsorbed Fraction error Frequency in oycles/minute Any variable as a function of time... 

Aminoacyl tRNA-synthetases have a proofreading ability to double-check that an amino acid is linked with its proper tRNA. The proofreading ability of the enzyme and other proofreading steps (see here) in translation reduce the error frequency to less than 1 in 10,000. 

---