Dietary supplements regulation

Government agencies have never had sufficient resources to cope with the enormous amount of deception in the marketing of herbs, dietary supplements, and homeopathic products. Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act made the problem worse. Without an adequate law, the FDA cannot curb the deceptive marketing of what DSHEA calls dietary supplements. Regulators have the power to ban homeopathic remedies but have shown no interest in doing so. 

Other legislation that may impact upon therapeutic products includes the Contraception, Sterilisation and Abortion Act 1977, the Toxic Substances Act 1979, the Toxic Substances Regulations 1983 and the Dietary Supplements Regulations 1983. 

The term dietary supplement is defined under regulation 2 of the Dietary Supplements Regulations 1985 and includes any edible substance, in a controlled dosage form, which is intended to supplement the intake of substances normally derived from food. 

Committee on Government Reform. US House of Representatives. 2001. House Government Reform Committee Six Years After the Enactment of DSHEA The Status of National and International Dietary Supplement Regulation. March 20,2001... 

Vitamin and mineral as both foods and drugs, botanicals (approved and not approved), teas as prescription and as over-the-counter Vitamin and mineral, plants, herbs, nutritional food supplements, naturopaths and homeopathic preparations, aromatherapies No definition of dietary supplements, regulations for foods, drugs, and Kampo... 

Several different niacin formulations are available niacin immediate-release (IR), niacin sustained-release (SR), and niacin extended-release (ER).28,29 These formulations differ in terms of dissolution and absorption rates, metabolism, efficacy, and side effects. Limitations of niacin IR and SR are flushing and hepatotoxicity, respectively. These differences appear related to the dissolution and absorption rates of niacin formulations and its subsequent metabolism. Niacin IR is available by prescription (Niacor ) as well as a dietary supplement which is not regulated by the FDA.28 Currently, there are no FDA-approved niacin SR products, thus, all SR products are available only as dietary supplements. 

Several studies have evaluated dietary supplements such as isoflavones, which are found in soy products and red clover. A well-controlled trial in more than 400 postmenopausal women evaluating a specific isoflavone, ipriflavone, found no benefits on bone mineral density or fracture rates after 3 years.47 Nevertheless, because these therapies are available without prescription and are not regulated by the FDA, patients may choose to self-medicate with isoflavones. Lymphocytopenia appeared in several patients treated with ipriflavone in clinical trials. Additionally, ipriflavone should be used with caution in immunocompromised patients or those with renal disease. It may inhibit CYP1A2 and CYP2C9 and may interact with drugs metabolized by those pathways, such as warfarin. 

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) regulates dietary supplement advertising. The FTC prohibits unfair or deceptive acts or practices with the advertisement of dietary supplements from retailers and manufacturers. A pharmacy would be held liable if the pharmacy published a manufacturer s ad that was considered deceptive [26]. 

When a patient wants to use a dietary supplement, the following points should be addressed inadequate regulations for quality, safety, or efficacy, differences in preparations from different manufacturers, and insufficient reporting of adverse events. 

Another factor responsible for regulating the levels of p53 by (3-carotene could be the dose employed. At high carotenoid concentrations, an increase in p53 expression was observed in SCC cells (Schwartz, 1993) and in HL-60 cells (Palozza et al 2002b). In HL-60 cells, the treatment with the carotenoid induced a remarkable increase in ROS production, accompanied by an enhanced expression of p21WAFl and by a concomitant arrest of cell cycle at the G0/G1 phase (Palozza et al., 2002b). An arrest of cell cycle, accompanied by apoptosis induction, was also observed following dietary supplementation with lutein (Chew et al., 2003). The inhibition of mouse mammary tumor growth by lutein was also supported by the observed increase in the expression of p53 and Bax induced by the carotenoid (Chew et al., 2003). 

One distinction between drugs and dietary supplements is how they are regulated by the FDA. Unlike for drugs, manufacturers do not have to provide FDA with evidence that dietary... 

Herbal, natural, and food-supplement products are often used to promote weight loss (Table 59-3). The FDA does not strictly regulate these products, so the ingredients may be inactive and present in variable concentrations. After more than 800 reports of serious adverse events (e.g., seizures, stroke, and death) were attributed to ephedrine alkaloids, the FDA decided to exclude them from dietary supplements. 

In accordance with the provisions of the Dietary supplement Health and Education Act 1994, in the United States botanical dosage forms can be marketed as dietary supplements provided the label makes no medical claim however, structure-function claim is allowed. In most countries other than the United States, botanical preparations are regulated as drugs thus posing a different set of challenges. This fact must be taken into consideration in standard setting. 

The first edition1 of this book was published approximately 13 years ago. Its primary objective was to present an overview and a "roadmap" of the process of new drug discovery and development, particularly oriented to individuals or companies entering the pharmaceutical field. It was written by one of the authors (Smith), with no contributors, and drawn on Smith s experiences in the industry and field over the course of nearly 40 years. In the second edition, the scope of the first book has been expanded and technical details in the form of hard data have been included. In addition to the editors own commentary and contributions, the major part of the book is the result of contributions of experts in the industry. New chapters on risk assessment, international harmonization of drug development and regulation, dietary supplements, patent law, and entrepreneurial startup of a new pharmaceutical company have been added. Some of the important, basic operational aspects of drug discovery and development (e.g., organizational matters, staff requirements, pilot plant operations, etc.) are not repeated in this book but can be found in the first edition. 

In 1994, the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act was passed by the U.S. Congress. This allowed herbal medications to be advertised and sold without oversight from the FDA. Specifically, it states that a substance will not legally be classified as a "drug" if it is not represented as treatment for a disease (Heiligenstein and Guenther. 1998 Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act of 1994). Thus, many herbal medicines are now sold and regulated as dietary supplements. 

Dietary Supplements. In the past 10 years, melatonin, available as a dietary supplement from health food stores or over the Internet, has become a popular sleep agent. Melatonin is a hormone produced by the pineal gland at peak levels during the night. It is believed to help regulate the 24 hour circadian sleep-wake cycle. 

The kind of natural products listed in the table above, however, are not defined in the United States today as drugs hut as dietary supplements, nutritional supplements, natural foods, or some similar nondrug product. Such products are not subject to the same standards of testing as are synthetic drugs. They are regulated by the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act (DSHEA) of 1994 (Public Law 103-417). According to that law, the makers of natural products used... 

The fourth safety concern in the use of dietary supplements, that they may actually be harmful to users, is anything hut benign. Recall that the DSHEA places the responsihihty for safety testing with supplement manufacturers themselves. Consumers can only assume that products they purchase are safe for their use and will not cause health problems. It is only when such problems actually arise and the EDA is notified that regulators can deal with the safety of a supplement. 

Many consumer advocates applauded the FDA for its efforts to impose new regulations on dietary supplements. Even the adoption of these regulations, however, would not guarantee that such products, in and of themselves, are either safe or effective. 

Vitamins are a group of unrelated chemical substances that are essential in small amounts for the regulation of normal metabolism, growth, and function of the human body. Not all of the vitamins can be synthesized in the body, and therefore, some vitamins must be obtained from an external source, such as a proper well-balanced diet or dietary supplements. 

---