Classical mechanics statistics

As time went on, computers were used for increasingly complex problems in chemistry, as will be shown. In this process, the early quantum chemistry users received competition from the theoretical chemists oriented toward a broader field of mathematical chemistry. Eventually many experimentalists started to use computational tools for quantum and classical mechanics, statistical mechanics, and database searching. Parallel to these applications, almost every experimental setup had a dedicated computer to run experiments and evaluate data automatically. Laboratory automation will not be treated in this chapter. Likewise, no attempt will be made to cover the impact of computers on experimental structure determination (e.g.. X-ray crystallography). 

As discussed above, to identify states of the system as those for the reactant A, a dividing surface is placed at the potential energy barrier region of the potential energy surface. This is a classical mechanical construct and classical statistical mechanics is used to derive the RRKM k(E) [4]. 

Marcus uses the Born-Oppenheimer approximation to separate electronic and nuclear motions, the only exception being at S in the case of nonadiabatic reactions. Classical equilibrium statistical mechanics is used to calculate the probability of arriving at the activated complex only vibrational quantum effects are treated approximately. The result is... 

However, in all the rest of their approach, Robertson and Yarwood consider the slow mode Q as a scalar obeying simply classical mechanics, because they neglect the noncommutativity of Q with its conjugate momentum P. As a consequence, the logic of their approach is to consider the fluctuation of the slow mode as obeying classical statistical mechanics and not quantum statistical mechanics. Thus we write, in place of Eq. (138), the corresponding classical formula ... 

The topic that is commonly referred to as statistical quantum mechanics deals with mixed ensembles only, although pure ensembles may be represented in the same formalism. There is an interesting difference with classical statistics arising here In classical mechanics maximum information about all subsystems is obtained as soon as maximum information about the total system is available. This statement is no longer valid in quantum mechanics. It may happen that the total system is represented by a pure ensemble and a subsystem thereof by a mixed ensemble. 

In classical molecular dynamics, on the other hand, particles move according to the laws of classical mechanics over a PES that has been empirically parameterized. By means of their kinetic energy they can overcome energetic barriers and visit a much more extended portion of phase space. Tools from statistical mechanics can, moreover, be used to determine thermodynamic (e.g. relative free energies) and dynamic properties of the system from its temporal evolution. The quality of the results is, however, limited to the accuracy and reliability of the (empirically) parameterized PES. 

Optimization pervades the fields of science, engineering, and business. In physics, many different optimal principles have been enunciated, describing natural phenomena in the fields of optics and classical mechanics. The field of statistics treats various principles termed maximum likelihood, minimum loss, and least squares, and business makes use of maximum profit, minimum cost, maximum use of resources, minimum effort, in its efforts to increase profits. A typical engineering problem can be posed as follows A process can be represented by some equations or perhaps solely by experimental data. You have a single performance criterion in mind such as minimum cost. The goal of optimization is to find the values of the variables in the process that yield the best value of the performance criterion. A trade-off usually exists between capital and operating costs. The described factors—process or model and the performance criterion—constitute the optimization problem. ... 

Beyond the clusters, to microscopically model a reaction in solution, we need to include a very big number of solvent molecules in the system to represent the bulk. The problem stems from the fact that it is computationally impossible, with our current capabilities, to locate the transition state structure of the reaction on the complete quantum mechanical potential energy hypersurface, if all the degrees of freedom are explicitly included. Moreover, the effect of thermal statistical averaging should be incorporated. Then, classical mechanical computer simulation techniques (Monte Carlo or Molecular Dynamics) appear to be the most suitable procedures to attack the above problems. In short, and applied to the computer simulation of chemical reactions in solution, the Monte Carlo [18-21] technique is a numerical method in the frame of the classical Statistical Mechanics, which allows to generate a set of system configurations... 

Computational procedures following a classical mechanical picture, as it was outlined in section 2.3, can be and have been implemented by a number of people. The quantum/classical schemes belong to this family [6,123], At a semi empirical level of electronic theory, Warshel and coworkers approach is the most complete from the statistical mechanical viewpoint. For early references and recent developments see ref.[31, 124], Simplified schemes have been used to study chemical events in enzymes and solution [16, 60, 109, 125, 126],... 

Giauque, whose name has already been mentioned in connection with the discovery of the oxygen isotopes, calculated Third Law entropies with the use of the low temperature heat capacities that he measured he also applied statistical mechanics to calculate entropies for comparison with Third Law entropies. Very soon after the discovery of deuterium Urey made statistical mechanical calculations of isotope effects on equilibrium constants, in principle quite similar to the calculations described in Chapter IV. J. Kirkwood s development showing that quantum mechanical statistical mechanics goes over into classical statistical mechanics in the limit of high temperature dates to the 1930s. Kirkwood also developed the quantum corrections to the classical mechanical approximation. 

Of course, one is not really interested in classical mechanical calculations. Thus in normal practice the partition functions used in TST, as discussed in Chapter 4, are evaluated using quantum partition functions for harmonic frequencies (extension to anharmonicity is straightforward). On the other hand rotations and translations are handled classically both in TST and in VTST, which is a standard approximation except at very low temperatures. Later, by introducing canonical partition functions one can direct the discussion towards canonical variational transition state theory (CVTST) where the statistical mechanics involves ensembles defined in terms of temperature and volume. There is also a form of variational transition state theory based on microcanonical ensembles referred to by the symbol p,. Discussion of VTST based on microcanonical ensembles pVTST is beyond the scope of the discussion here. It is only mentioned that in pVTST the dividing surface is... 

The important word in this sentence is predict. It is important, in my opinion, to make a distinction between existence and predictability. Prigogine himself said (much later, in La Fin des Certitudes, LG.7) Every dynamical system must, of course, follow a trajectory, solution of its equations, independently of the fact that we may or may not construct it. Thus, a trajectory exists but cannot be predicted. The impossibility of prediction is therefore related to the impossibility of defining an instantaneous state (in the framework of classical mechanics) as a limit of a finite region of phase space (thus a limit of a result of a set of measurements). For an unstable system, such a region will be deformed and will end up covering almost all of phase space. The necessity of introducing statistical methods appears to me to be due to the practical (rather than theoretical) impossibility of determining a mathematical point as an initial condition. 

III. Irrelevance of Classical Equilibrium Statistical Mechanics for the Gravitational Problem... 

III. IRRELEVANCE OF CLASSICAL EQUILIBRIUM STATISTICAL MECHANICS FOR THE GRAVITATIONAL PROBLEM... 

Having specified the interactions (i.e., the model of the system), the actual simulation then constructs a sequence of states (or the system trajectory) in some statistical mechanical ensemble. Simulations can be stochastic (Monte Carlo (MC)) or deterministic (MD), or they can combine elements of both, such as force-biased MC, Brownian dynamics, or generalized Lan-gevin dynamics. It is usually assumed that the laws of classical mechanics (i.e., Newton s second law) may adequately describe the atoms and molecules in the physical system. 

The basic theories of physics - classical mechanics and electromagnetism, relativity theory, quantum mechanics, statistical mechanics, quantum electrodynamics - support the theoretical apparatus which is used in molecular sciences. Quantum mechanics plays a particular role in theoretical chemistry, providing the basis for the valence theories which allow to interpret the structure of molecules and for the spectroscopic models employed in the determination of structural information from spectral patterns. Indeed, Quantum Chemistry often appears synonymous with Theoretical Chemistry it will, therefore, constitute a major part of this book series. However, the scope of the series will also include other areas of theoretical chemistry, such as mathematical chemistry (which involves the use of algebra and topology in the analysis of molecular structures and reactions) molecular mechanics, molecular dynamics and chemical thermodynamics, which play an important role in rationalizing the geometric and electronic structures of molecular assemblies and polymers, clusters and crystals surface, interface, solvent and solid-state effects excited-state dynamics, reactive collisions, and chemical reactions. 

Derivation of the Boltzmann distribution function is based on statistical mechanical considerations and requires use of Stirling s approximation and Lagrange s method of undetermined multipliers to arrive at the basic equation, (N,/No) = (g/go)exp[-A Ae/]. The exponential term /3 defines the temperature scale of the Boltzmann function and can be shown to equal t/ksT. In classical mechanics, this distribution is defined by giving values for the coordinates and momenta for each particle in three-coordinate space and the lin-... 

Both sets of calculations found that ring closure of 8 preferentially occurs by the same mode of coupled methylene rotations as ring opening of 7. Crudely put, the dynamical behavior of 8 can be predicted by, what would be called in classical mechanics, conservation of angular momentum. Chapter 21 in this volume provides examples of other reactions in which dynamical effects cause statistical models, such as TST, to fail to make correct predictions. 

It is true that there exist situations (corresponding to statistical ensembles) where Eq. (11) would be true in classical mechanics. Examples are given in the Feynman lectures.8 However, in general Eq. (11) is incorrect in both quantum and classical mechanics. Indeed, the type of interference of probabilities which we derive in our theory (see Section IX) is qualitatively similar for classical and quantum processes. 

Boltzmann s expression for S thereby reduces the description of the molecular microworld to a statistical counting exercise, abandoning the attempt to describe molecular behavior in strict mechanistic terms. This was most fortunate, for it enabled Boltzmann to avoid the untenable assumption that classical mechanics remains valid in the molecular domain. Instead, Boltzmann s theory successfully incorporates certain quantal-like notions of probability and indeterminacy (nearly a half-century before the correct quantum mechanical laws were discovered) that are necessary for proper molecular-level description of macroscopic thermodynamic phenomena. 

Quantum mechanics, however, is different from the other applications in that the states themselves require a concept of probability for their physical interpretation. I shall call this intrinsic probability or quantum probability to distinguish it from the above classical or statistical probability. Intrinsic probability is not covered by the definition in 1.1 and cannot be regarded as an ensemble.510... 

The uncertainty principle shows that the classical trajectory of a particle, with a precisely determined position and momentum, is really an illusion. It is a very good approximation, however, for macroscopic bodies. Consider a particle with mass I Xg, and position known to an accuracy of 1 pm. Equation 2.41 shows that the uncertainty in momentum is at least 5 x 10 29 kg m s-1, corresponding to a velocity of 5 x 10 JO m s l. This is totally negligible for any practical purpose, and it illustrates that in the macroscopic world, even with very light objects, the uncertainty principle is irrelevant. If we wanted to, we could describe these objects by wave packets and use the quantum theory, but classical mechanics gives essentially the same answer, and is much easier. At the atomic and molecular level, however, especially with electrons, which are very light, we must abandon the idea of a classical trajectory. The statistical predictions provided by Bom s interpretation of the wavefunction are the best that can be obtained. 

The statistical nature of the quantum theory has troubled several eminent scientists, including Einstein and Schrodinger. They were never able to accept that statistical predictions could be the last word, and searched for a deeper theory that would give precise deterministic predictions, rather that just probabilities. They were unsuccessful, and most physicists now believe that this was inevitable, as some predictions of the quantum theory, which have been verified experimentally, suggest that a completely deterministic theory such as classical mechanics cannot be correct. 

---