Chiral selectors applications

Site of Chiral Selector 1 Type of Chiral Selector Application Column Efficiency... 

Analysis of chiral pollutants by capillary electrophoresis (CE) is a new trend in separation science. This entry describes separation and identification of chiral xenobiotics by using CE. Attempts have been made to describe types of chiral selectors, applications, optimization of separations, detection strategies, mechanisms of chiral separations, CE vs chromatography and sample preparation methods. 

The type of CSPs used have to fulfil the same requirements (resistance, loadabil-ity) as do classical chiral HPLC separations at preparative level [99], although different particle size silica supports are sometimes needed [10]. Again, to date the polysaccharide-derived CSPs have been the most studied in SMB systems, and a large number of racemic compounds have been successfully resolved in this way [95-98, 100-108]. Nevertheless, some applications can also be found with CSPs derived from polyacrylamides [11], Pirkle-type chiral selectors [10] and cyclodextrin derivatives [109]. A system to evaporate the collected fractions and to recover and recycle solvent is sometimes coupled to the SMB. In this context the application of the technique to gas can be advantageous in some cases because this part of the process can be omitted [109]. 

From the pioneering studies of Ito et al. [117], CCC has been mainly used for the separation and purification of natural products, where it has found a large number of applications [114, 116, 118, 119]. Moreover, the potential of this technique for preparative purposes can be also applied to chiral separations. The resolution of enantiomers can be simply envisaged by addition of a chiral selector to the stationary liquid phase. The mixture of enantiomers would come into contact with this liquid CSP, and enantiodiscrimination might be achieved. However, as yet few examples have been described in the literature. 

Gas chromatography (GC) has also been used for preparative purposes, but is restricted to relatively volatile racemates such as anesthetics, pheromones or monoterpenes and, therefore, very few applications are reported. Nevertheless, in the cases to which GC may be applied, it could be considered as an economical alternative to HPLC. Most of the resolutions of enantiomers were performed on cyclodex-trin-derived CSPs [109, 144-153], and only on very few occasions were other chiral selectors used [153]. 

The first successful chiral resolutions through enantioselective membranes have been published recently, but few cases are applicable to the preparative scale, mainly due to mechanical and technical limitations. Low flow rates, saturation of the chiral selectors and loss of enantioselectivity with time are some of the common problems encountered and that should be solved in the near future. 

Most of the chiral membrane-assisted applications can be considered as a modality of liquid-liquid extraction, and will be discussed in the next section. However, it is worth mentioning here a device developed by Keurentjes et al., in which two miscible chiral liquids with opposing enantiomers of the chiral selector flow counter-currently through a column, separated by a nonmiscible liquid membrane [179]. In this case the selector molecules are located out of the liquid membrane and both enantiomers are needed. The system allows recovery of the two enantiomers of the racemic mixture to be separated. Thus, using dihexyltartrate and poly(lactic acid), the authors described the resolution of different drugs, such as norephedrine, salbu-tamol, terbutaline, ibuprofen or propranolol. 

Ideal chiral selectors to be used in preparative separations should fulfil certain properties. In general, high loadability is one of the most interesting features for large-scale purposes, but high enantioselectivity, high chemical stability, low cost and broad applicability are also very important issues. None of these properties can be considered independently. 

A compromise among all the properties mentioned herein should be established, depending on the technique used and on the particular application. Preparative separation of enantiomers is still an open subject which requires further investigation in the search of new chiral selectors and techniques well adapted to large scale processes. 

Enantiomeric separations have become increasingly important, especially in the pharmaceutical and agricultural industries as optical isomers often possess different biological properties. The analysis and preparation of a pure enantiomer usually involves its resolution from the antipode. Among all the chiral separation techniques, HPLC has proven to be the most convenient, reproducible and widely applicable method. Most of the HPLC methods employ a chiral selector as the chiral stationary phase (CSP). 

Armstrong and Jin [15] reported the separation of several hydrophobic isomers (including (l-ferrocenylethyl)thiophenol, 1 -benzylnornicotine, mephenytoin and disopyramide) by cyclodextrins as chiral selectors. A wide variety of crown ethers have been synthesized for application in enantioselective liquid membrane separation, such as binaphthyl-, biphenanthryl-, helicene-, tetrahydrofuran and cyclohex-anediol-based crown ethers [16-20]. Brice and Pirkle [7] give a comprehensive overview of the characteristics and performance of the various crown ethers used as chiral selectors in liquid membrane separation. 

As described above, the application of classical liquid- liquid extractions often results in extreme flow ratios. To avoid this, a completely symmetrical system has been developed at Akzo Nobel in the early 1990s [64, 65]. In this system, a supported liquid-membrane separates two miscible chiral liquids containing opposite chiral selectors (Fig. 5-13). When the two liquids flow countercurrently, any desired degree of separation can be achieved. As a result of the system being symmetrical, the racemic mixture to be separated must be added in the middle. Due to the fact that enantioselectivity usually is more pronounced in a nonaqueous environment, organic liquids are used as the chiral liquids and the membrane liquid is aqueous. In this case the chiral selector molecules are lipophilic in order to avoid transport across the liquid membrane. 

Mourier s report was quickly followed by successful enantiomeric resolutions on stationary phases bearing other types of chiral selectors, including native and deriva-tized cyclodextrins and derivatized polysaccharides. Many chiral compounds of pharmaceutical interest have now been resolved by packed column SFC, including antimalarials, (3-blockers, and antivirals. A summary is provided in Table 12-2. Most of the applications have utilized modified CO, as the eluent. 

Nishi et al. [110] used dextran and dextrin as chiral selectors in capillary-zone electrophoresis. Polysaccharides such as dextrins, which are mixtures of linear a-(l,4)-linked D-glucose polymers, and dextrans, which are polymers of D-glucose units linked predominantly by a-(l,6) bonds, have been employed as chiral selectors in the capillary electrophoretic separation of enantiomers. Because these polymers are electrically neutral, the method is applicable to ionic compounds. The enantiomers of basic or cationic drugs such as primaquine were successfully separated under acidic conditions. The effects of molecular mass and polysaccharide concentration on enantioselectivity were investigated. 

Phinney et al. [Ill] investigated the application of citrus pectins, as chiral selectors, to enantiomer separations in capillary electrophoresis. Successful enantioreso-lution of primaquine and other antimalarials, was achieved by utilizing potassium polypectate as the chiral selector. Changes in pH, chiral additive concentration, and capillary type were studied in relation to chiral resolution. The effect of degree of esterification of pectin materials on chiral recognition was evaluated. 

Meanwhile, a wide variety of cinchona alkaloid derivatives have been systematically developed as chiral selectors, which complement each other in their enantiomer discrimination profiles. Considering the variety of derivatives, an overall reasonably broad applicability spectrum, approximating for chiral acids a 100% success rate, is yielded and extreme enantiorecognition levels (a-values above 15) could be realized for some chiral solutes with certain selectors. Moreover, various studies carried out with the CHIRALPAK QD/QN-AX columns in industry and academia clearly document their practical usefulness for solving challenging real-life problems and this should be illustrated by the present review article as well. 

---