Chiral method development conditions

Chiral method development is often referred to as one of the most difficult fields in terms of development time. Interaction with a chiral selector is required to achieve separation but the enantioselectivity of a given selector for a given chiral molecule is a priori unknown. For some compounds, it can take several days to find suitable separation conditions when using sequential approaches. Therefore, industry most often defines generic separation strategies, which are often kept internally or are... 

In this way, we aim to give an overview of what can be used as a separation technique and which conditions will most likely give an (beginning of) enantiomer separation after a first screening. Chiral method development starter kits are also available and evaluated in some papers [2], but we will not focus on this kind of applications. 

Table 1 Initial Conditions for Chiral Method Development Using Modified Carbon Dioxide as the Mobile Phase...

Table 1 Initial conditions for chiral method development using modified carhon dioxide as the mobile phase.

Reversed phase chiral separations are desired simply for efficiency in generating results from laboratories whose instrumentation is routinely configured to run in reversed and not normal phase modes.Normal phase conditions are less attractive to the analytical chemist for this reason and deter laboratory efficiency. Typical commercial chiral LC columns found on pharmaceutical reversed phase LC chiral method development screens are listed in Table 8. Table 11 shows suggested chromatographic conditions employed in reversed phase chiral screening. 

There are many classes of CSPs applicable in different mobile-phase modes. In particular, CSPs based on derivatized polysaccharides, native and derivatized cyclodextrins, macrocyclic glycopeptides, and Pirkle-type chiral selectors operate quite well in four separation modes, i.e RP, polar organic phase, NP, and super- or subcritical fluid chromatography (SFC) conditions. It is common that a chiral compound can be separated on the same CSP in more than one separation mode [58, 160, 166, 170-176]. For example, Nutlin-3, a small molecule antagonist of MDM2, has been baseline resolved from its enantiomer in all four mobile-phase conditions (Fig. 16) [170]. Multimodal enantioseparation on the same CSP would be greatly beneflcial for chiral method development in pharmaceutical industry. 

Method development remains the most challenging aspect of chiral chromatographic analysis, and the need for rapid method development is particularly acute in the pharmaceutical industry. To complicate matters, even structurally similar compounds may not be resolved under the same chromatographic conditions, or even on the same CSP. Rapid column equilibration in SFC speeds the column screening process, and automated systems accommodating multiple CSPs and modifiers now permit unattended method optimization in SFC [36]. Because more compounds are likely to be resolved with a single set of parameters in SFC than in LC, the analyst stands a greater chance of success on the first try in SFC [37]. The increased resolution obtained in SFC may also reduce the number of columns that must be evaluated to achieve the desired separation. 

The use of mixed micelles for chiral recognition was discussed in Section 5.3.3, using cyclodextrins. In addition to cyclodextrins, however, metal-amino acid complexes can also be used in a mixed mode arrangement. Bile salts are naturally occurring chiral surfactants that can be used as alternatives to, or in addition to, SDS for chiral recognition. In the presence of SDS, the migration times are faster. Table 5.5 shows initial operating conditions that can be used in chiral CE as a start to methods development.40... 

Method development Relatively slow changing and conditioning a column is time-consuming. Rapid changing a capillary and/or chiral selector takes only few minutes. 

The mobile phase controls the separation Whereas the stationary phase provides a media for analyte interaction, the mobile phase controls the overall separation. In HPLC method development, efforts focus on finding a set of mobile phase conditions for separating the analyte (s) from other components. Exceptions to this rule are size exclusion, chiral, and affinity chromatography. 

This reaction has been modified to occur under mild conditions such as those of Masamune and Roush, Still, and Ando. In addition, chiral phosphonates (or phospho-namides) have been used for this reaction. In particular, the method developed by Still and Gennari using [bis(trifiuoroethyl)phosphono] esters, generally known as Gennari-Still phosphonates, is very useful in the preparation of Z-olefins. Illustrated is the HWE reaction using Gennari-Still phosphonates to give c/ -olefins, and its mechanism. 

---