Batch and Flow Techniques

Considering the various approaches of solid-state NMR spectroscopy, contrasting advantages and limitations must be mentioned for batch and flow techniques. MAS NMR spectroscopy under batch reaction conditions with glass inserts for the preparation of the catalyst samples has the advantage that all the materials and equipment are commercially available. Because the amounts of reactants necessary for these experiments are small, only low costs for isotopically enriched materials 

MAS NMR experiments characterizing catalysts in reaction environments in flow systems may be carried out under conditions close to those of industrial processes. The formation of catalytically active surface species and the cause of the deactivation of catalysts can be characterized best under flow conditions. When flow techniques are used for the investigation of reactions under steady-state conditions, a continuous formation and transformation of intermediates occurs. The lifetime of the species under study must be of the order of the length of the free-induction decay, which is ca. 100 ms for C MAS NMR spectroscopy. 

A significant limitation of NMR experiments of working catalysts in flow systems is the necessity of using isotopically enriched materials as reactants, which leads to high costs. Furthermore, most of the flow approaches described in Section III.B are based on homemade equipments requiring large efforts to make the techniques feasible. 

---

To study rapid reactions, traditional batch and flow techniques are inadequate. However, the development of stopped flow, electric field pulse, and particularly pressure-jump relaxation techniques have made the study of rapid reactions possible (Chapter 4). German and Japanese workers have very successfully studied exchange and sorption-desorption reactions on oxides and zeolites using these techniques. In addition to being able to study rapid reaction rates, one can obtain chemical kinetics parameters. The use of these methods by soil and environmental scientists would provide much needed mechanistic information about sorption processes. 

Another consideration in choosing a kinetic method is the objective of one s experiments. For example, if chemical kinetics rate constants are to be measured, most batch and flow techniques would be unsatisfactory since they primarily measure transport- and diffusion-controlled processes, and apparent rate laws and rate coefficients are determined. Instead, one should employ a fast kinetic method such as pressure-jump relaxation, electric field pulse, or stopped flow (Chapter 4). 

A number of methods can be used to study the kinetics of soil chemical processes. These include various types of batch and flow techniques. Each of these methods was described in this chapter and their advantages and disadvantages were discussed. It is obvious that none of them is a panacea for kinetic studies of heterogeneous systems such as soils. They each have strengths and weaknesses. It also appears that when most of these methods are used, apparent rate laws are being studied. 

Regarding approach (li). distinction can be made between batch and flow techniques, with commercial apparatus available for both. 

Considerable sorption occurs before the first measurement can be made, particularly if batch and flow techniques are employed where the fastest that a measurement can be made is about 15 seconds. For such rapid reactions, chemical relaxation techniques, and preferably real-time molecular-scale techniques, can be used. The latter are discussed later in the chapter. One might ask why it is important to measure such reactions if they are so rapid. Since the reactions are occurring so far from equilibrium, back reactions are insignificant and one can determine chemical reaction rates, devoid of mass transfer processes. Therefore, chemical kinetic measurements are being made, and details about molecular processes and mechanisms can be ascertained. 

A number of soil chemical phenomena are characterized by rapid reaction rates that occur on millisecond and microsecond time scales. Batch and flow techniques cannot be used to measure such reaction rates. Moreover, kinetic studies that are conducted using these methods yield apparent rate coefficients and apparent rate laws since mass transfer and transport processes usually predominate. Relaxation methods enable one to measure reaction rates on millisecond and microsecond time scales and 10 determine mechanistic rate laws. In this chapter, theoretical aspects of chemical relaxation are presented. Transient relaxation methods such as temperature-jump, pressure-jump, concentration-jump, and electric field pulse techniques will be discussed and their application to the study of cation and anion adsorption/desorption phenomena, ion-exchange processes, and hydrolysis and complexation reactions will he covered. 

Ammons, Dougharty, and Smith have studied the adsorption of methyl-mercuric chloride from aqueous solution by activated carbon by both batch and flow techniques. The data were analysed to investigate the factors that control the breakthrough curves. Axial dispersion was found to contribute no more than 15% to the second moment of the breakthrough curve, while liquid-to-particle mass transfer contributed about 60%. On a similar topic Benediktov, Vlasov, and Yurkevich in a paper of which only the title is abstracted, discuss the determination of the degree of exhaustion of active carbon with respect to organic substances during adsorption from aqueous solutions. 

In the preceding decade, solid-state NMR spectroscopy has provided important and novel information about the nature and properties of surface sites on working solid catalysts and the mechanisms of these surface reactions. This spectroscopic method offers the advantages of operation close to the conditions of industrial catalysis. A number of new techniques have been introduced and applied that allow investigations of surface reactions by solid-state NMR spectroscopy under both batch and flow conditions. Depending on the problems to be solved, both of these experimental approaches are useful for the investigation of calcined solid catalysts and surface compounds formed on these materials under reaction conditions. Problems with the time scale of NMR spectroscopy in comparison with the time scale of the catalytic reactions can be overcome by sophisticated experimental... 

Calcium and Mg in mineral water were simultaneously determined with Methylthymol Blue by both batch and flow-injection techniques [3], FIA method using murexide as a colour agent was employed to the determination of Ca in ores and Ca-containing pharmaceutical formulations [4]. 

Two basic types of flow methods can be distinguished those with mixing and those without. The chief limitation of unmixed flow reactors is that mass transfer processes are frequently limiting and in the case of fast chemical reactions are probably always limiting. Stirred-flow reactors and fluidized bed reactors may often overcome the mass transfer limitation, and indeed these hybrid techniques may represent the best attributes of batch and flow methods. Each of these approaches i.s considered in turn. 

The effect of pH of the sample, eluent flow rate, and the amount of silica on sorption and elution experimental parameters were investigated by a new phase, which was synthesized from a high surface area silica gel with a 3-trimethoxysilyl-l-propanol group. In addition, both batch and column techniques were applied to identify the characteristics of this modified silica and its application to the preconcentration and separation of Co and Ni prior to determination by graphite furnace atomic absorption spectrometry (GFAAS). ""... 

The reasons of this behaviour were soon discovered by Schulz team29). One was purely technical. Under the conditions prevailing in the earlier experiments of Schulz and Lohr the polymerization was too slow for employment of the flow technique adopted by the authors in their earlier investigation, but too fast for the conventional batch technique. Development of a stirred reactor allowing studies of reactions with half-lifetime as short as 2 sec eliminated this difficulty 30). 

Chapter 2 developed a methodology for treating multiple and complex reactions in batch reactors. The methodology is now applied to piston flow reactors. Chapter 3 also generalizes the design equations for piston flow beyond the simple case of constant density and constant velocity. The key assumption of piston flow remains intact there must be complete mixing in the direction perpendicular to flow and no mixing in the direction of flow. The fluid density and reactor cross section are allowed to vary. The pressure drop in the reactor is calculated. Transpiration is briefly considered. Scaleup and scaledown techniques for tubular reactors are developed in some detail. 

For the Michael addition of 2,4-pentanedione enolate to ethyl propiolate, improvements in conversion were determined. This example serves also to demonstrate that proper process conditions are mandatory to have success with micro-reactor processing. A conversion of only 56% was achieved when using electroosmotically driven flow with a two-fold injection, the first for forming the enolate and the second for its addition to the triple bond (batch synthesis 89%) [151]. Using instead a stopped-flow technique to enhance mixing, a conversion of 95% was determined. 

The conversions observed followed the sequence of reactivity known from batch experiments carried out in advance. For example, only 15% conversion was found for the less reactive reagent benzoylacetone in the micro reactor experiment, while 56% was determined when using the more reactive 2,4-pentanedione (batch syntheses 78% and 89%, respectively) [8]. Using the stopped-flow technique (2.5 s with field applied 5.0 s with field turned off) to enhance mixing, the conversions for both syntheses were increased to 34 and 95%, respectively. Using a further improved stopped-flow technique (5.0 s with field applied 10.0 s with field turned off), the conversion could be further enhanced to 100% for the benzoylacetone case. For the other two substrates, diethyl malonate and methyl vinyl ketone, similar trends were observed. 

Automated titrations can be divided into discontinuous and continuous, the former representing a discrete sample analysis, as a batch titration is the usual laboratory technique and the latter a flow technique, which is used less frequently in the laboratory, e.g., in kinetic studies, but is of greater importance in plant and environment control. 

---