Absolute acidity

Solvent variation can gready affect the acidity of hydantoins. Although two different standard states are employed for the piC scale and therefore care must be exercised when comparing absolute acidity constants measured in water and other solvents like dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO), the huge difference in piC values, eg, 9.0 in water and 15.0 in DMSO (12) in the case of hydantoin itself, indicates that water provides a better stabilization for the hydantoin anion and hence an increased acidity when compared to DMSO. 

Diffuse functions are large-size versions of s- and p-type functions (as opposed to the standard valence-size functions). They allow orbitals to occupy a larger region of spgce. Basis sets with diffuse functions are important for systems where electrons are relatively far from the nucleus molecules with lone pairs, anions and other systems with significant negative charge, systems in their excited states, systems with low ionization potentials, descriptions of absolute acidities, and so on. 

In order to arrive at values of the virtually intrinsic acidity, i.e., an acidity expression independent of the solvent used (Tremillon12 called it the absolute acidity), Schwarzenbach13 used the normal acidity potential as an expression for the potential of a standard Pt hydrogen electrode (1 atm H2), immersed in a solution of the acid and its conjugate base in equal activities analogously to eqn. 2.39 for a redox system and assuming n = 1 for the transfer of one proton, he wrote for the acidity potential... 

Richardson WEI, Peng C, Bashford D, Noodleman L, Case DA (1997) Incorporating Solvation Effects into Density Functional Theory Calculation of Absolute Acidities. Int J Quantum Chem 61 207-217. 

The reader should note, however, that some acidity values have changed since first reported, owing both to changes in the absolute acidities used to anchor the relative acidity scale, and to the correction of a significant error in the 1979 ICR acidity scale. The current data compilation reflects these changes. ... 

Calculations involving anions, e.g., absolute acidity calculations, often pose special problems. This is because the extra electrons may only be loosely associated with specific atoms (or pairs of atoms). In these situations, basis sets may need to be supplemented by diffuse s and p-type functions on heavy (non-hydrogen) atoms (designated by + as in 6-311+G ). It is also possible to add diffuse functions to hydrogens (designated by ++ as in 6-311++G ). 

Reactions defining absolute acidity, e.g., the reaction above for the acidity of HF, and absolute basicity are important special cases. Some comparisons between transition states and reactants will also likely fall into this category. These will be considered in Chapter 9. 

Perhaps the two most important heterolytic bond dissociation reactions are those used to define "absolute" acidity and basicity. 

Both reactions involve dissociation of a polar covalent bond to hydrogen and both lead to a "free" proton. While absolute acidities and basicities are rarely if ever (directly) measured experimentally, they provide a good opportunity to assess the performance of different models with regard to the energetics of heterolytic bond dissociation. 

Comparisons between calculated and experimental absolute acidities are provided in Table 6-6. The reactions are even more endothermic than those for absolute basicity, due to the additional penalty arising from charge separation. With the exception of the local density 6-311+G model, mean absolute errors here are significantly larger than those uncovered in absolute basicity comparisons, even though... 

Semi-empirical calculations provide a very poor account of absolute acidities. Even ignoring the large ( 350 kcal/mol) systematic error, the calculations even fail to reproduce the ordering of acidities in these compounds. Semi-empirical models should not be employed for this purpose. 

This means that diffuse basis functions will be required, just as they were for absolute acidity comparisons. Note, however, that in the case of absolute acidities, none of the models, except the local density model, gave satisfactory results even with the 6-311+G basis set. 

Another important type of isodesmic reaction compares acid (or base) strength to that of a closely-related standard compound, for example, the basicity of trimethylamine relative to that of ammonia as a standard. This differs fundamentally from absolute acid (or base) strength comparisons, which are heterolytic bond dissociations and which significantly alter overall bonding. ... 

Richardson, W.H. et al. (1997) Incorporating solvation effects into density functional theory calculation of absolute acidities. Int. J. Quantum Chem., 61 (2), 207-217. 

Basis sets used for carbanions have to include diffuse functions because anions generally have low ionization potentials, i.e. there is a pair of (or a single) electrons in the form of a diffuse charge cloud that extends relatively far from the nuclei and therefore is easily lost. Without diffuse functions, even larger basis sets such as DZ + P are not entirely successful either in the calculation of absolute acidities or in the ordering of acidities. 

The ionization of the acid HA in solvent S leads to a new acid HS+ and a base A. Equation (1.1) has a very wide scope and can be very well applied to neutral and positively and negatively charged acid systems. The acid-base pair that differs only by aproton is referred to as the conjugate acid-base pair. Thus, H20 is the conjugate base of the acid H30+. An obvious consequence of the concept is that the extent to which an acid ionizes depends on the basicity of the solvent in which the ionization takes place. This shows the difficulty in establishing an absolute acidity scale. Acidity scales are energy scales, and thus they are arbitrary with respect to both the reference point and the magnitude of units chosen. 

I cite three papers to show that standard continuum calculations can give satisfactory first-principles pKa values Shields and coworkers used a thermodynamic cycle with gas phase and continuum calculations to obtain satisfactory results for six simple carboxylic acids [46]. These were absolute calculations in the sense that no acid was used as a reference point, although the experimental gas phase free energy and aqueous solvation energy of the proton were resorted to. Not quite as esthetically satisfying perhaps, were relative calculations in which acetic acid was used as a reference compound [47]. Similar to the absolute acid calculations was work with phenols that was said to be among the most accurate of any such calculations for any group of compounds [48]. 

Having explored the relationships between solution pH and pKa values, we can now explore the relative acidities of various hydrogen atoms and how these values are influenced by neighboring functional groups and heteroatoms. In this arena, it is important to remember that how a reaction proceeds is largely dependent upon the relative acidities of protons (hydrogen atoms) compared to one another and not on the absolute acidity of a given proton. 

An absolute acidity scale for carbon acids has been established in DMSO from potentiometric measurements in the low pKa range and by using indicators for higher values (Matthews et al., 1975 Bordwell, 1975, 1977). Only a few data were reported for monocarbonyl compounds. For acetone... 

Absolute acid consmnption in tlie Brownie Butte impact and boundary beds was computed by Retallack [2] for several plausible parent materials. For the boundary bed, Haitian tektite parent material yielded A = 9.7 meq cm Chiexulub melt rock yielded 3.0 meq cm , and local Montana rock yielded 1.5 meq cm". Thus, Retallack concluded that absolute boundary bed acid consumption was within a range -1-10 meq cm impact bed values for acid consmnption are — one-half tliose of the boundary bed, mainly because of the facloi of 2 difference in thickness. 

Because the dissociation of an acid depends in a complex way on the chemical properties, molecular dipole and dielectric constant of the solvent, attempts to define absolute acid strength independently of the solvent have been unavailing. Nevertheless, relative strengths are independent, within a power of 10, of the nature of the solvent provided the acids belong to the same charge type, whether molecular, anionic or cationic. The independence of the nature of the solvent shown by acids of the same chemical character is even more marked. 

Kaminski, G.A. Accurate prediction of absolute acidity constants in water with a polarizable force field Substituted phenols, methanol, and imidazole. J. Phys. Chem. B 2005, 109(12), 5884-90. 

Forster photoacidity to the total (absolute) acidity of photoacids in their electronic excited state may be estimated directly from the corresponding pfQ and values. Additional questions are the extent to which photoacidity may be tuned by suitable substituents which also affect the ground state acidity of the photoacid and, alternatively, by the choice of the solvent. Table 12.3 compares the effect of several substituents on the ground- and excited-state acidities of several photoacids. The first conclusion that may be drawn from this table is that ring substituents cause the fQ and K of aromatic photoacids to change in the same direction. 

Absolute acid (commercial mixture of a- and 0-acids) Clear syrupy liq mp —25. dj4 1,59. Tends to dec during concn hence, usually marketed as a 25 50% soln. Soluble in water, alcohol. 

USE Absolute acid used to manuf certain glycerophos-... 

ArG298 = -RT InK. This experimental scale of relative acidities was converted to a scale of absolute acidities by including certain compounds as anchor points. Thus, the gas-phase acidity of PH3 was determined to be ArG29s = 363 2 kcal/mol. The entropy change for the deprotonation process was evaluated by procedures using statistical mechanics as ArS = 24.9 2 cal - mol" K From these data the deprotonation enthalpy of PH3 at 298 K was calculated to be ArH298=PA(PHi) = 370.4 2 kcal/mol [1, 2]. 

Notice the S-shaped region (from about 10 to 90% neutralization of the acid) before the equivalence point corresponding to the buffer region (mixture of HOAc andNaOAc). The close resemblance of these segments of the curve demonstrates the independence of buffer pH from absolute acid concentration when HOAc is very dilute (10 M), however, its dissociation is essentially complete so that its titration curve is like that of HCl at the same concentration. 

---