Understand quantum mechanics

Cliff-. Do you think Hopi Indians may have a better chance of understanding quantum mechanics (or modern theories of physics that say time is an illusion) than non-Hopis Why ... 

Alhambra and co-workers adopted a QM/MM strategy to better understand quantum mechanical effects, and particularly the influence of tunneling, on the observed primary kinetic isotope effect of 3.3 in this system (that is, the reaction proceeds 3.3 times more slowly when the hydrogen isotope at C-2 is deuterium instead of protium). In order to carry out their analysis they combined fully classical MD trajectories with QM/MM modeling and analysis using variational transition-state theory. Kinetic isotope effects (KIEs), tunneling, and variational transition state theory are discussed in detail in Chapter 15 - we will not explore these topics in any particular depth in this case study, but will focus primarily on the QM/MM protocol. 

Omnes, R. Understanding quantum mechanics, Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1999. 

F. Laloe, Do we really understand quantum mechanics Strange correlations, paradoxes, and theorems, Am. J. Phys. 69 (2001) 655-701. 

This is the essence of science. Even though I do not understand quantum mechanics or the nerve cell membrane, I trust those who do. Most scientists are quite ignorant about most sciences but all use a shared grammar that allows them to recognize their craft when they see it. The motto of the Royal Society of London is Nullius in verba trust not in words. Observation and experiment are what count, not opinion and introspection. Few working scientists have much respect for those who try to interpret nature in metaphysical terms. For most wearers of white coats, philosophy is to science as pornography is to sex it is cheaper, easier, and... 

The indicated averaging is the classical averaging for the decoupled subsystems with the effective interactions U for each case. This is a remarkably simple result, and study of this model is a serious first step in understanding quantum mechanical effects in molecular solutions. 

The quantity of possible interpretations, with large differences among them and some of them with a desperate character, indicate that the problem of understanding quantum mechanics is still unsolved. 

The frontiers of quantum physics and quantum chemistry are constantly changing with new discoveries and even bolder theoretical speculations. In the recent past, quantum mechanics have reached to such enormous heights that even seasoned theoreticians find it difficult to comprehend theories published in their own field of expertise. In my opinion understanding quantum mechanics is very much like climbing a steep hill and then moving on a smooth valley. Once one is able to overeome the barrier, one is then able to see clearly, the beautiful philosophy behind the abstract notions. 

By this stage you may feel that quantum mechanics is not for you. If so, take heart from the Nobel Prize winner Richard Feynman, who once made the remark I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics". 

Quantum theory could now be expressed in two totally different ways wave mechanics or matrix mechanics and it was not until the early 1930s that John von Neumann supplied a mathematical connection between wave and matrix mechanics. Not surprisingly, the study of quantum mechanics is fraught with the unknown and an eminent American theoretical physicist Richard Feynman said T think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics [4]. 

The Bohr theory was extended in various ways, particularly by Arnold Sonunofeld. This old quantum theory is still used as a tool to understand quantum mechanics and to obtain LQ)proximate solutions. The old quantum theory deals with, for example, the Bohr-Sonunerfeld quantum condition (quantization of action along a path) EBK theory of A. Einstein, L. Brillouin, and J. B. KeUer and JWKB theory of H. Jeffreys, G. Wenzel, H. A. Kramers, and L. Brillouin. Unfortunately, there is no possibiUty of giving justice to the various aspects of old quantum theory in this book. 

Quantum mechanical calculations view a molecule as a collection of point nuclei and electrons with fixed masses and charges. The energy terms include the kinetic energy of each particle and the coulombic energies between the particles (repulsion between nuclei, attraction between the nucleus and an electron, and repulsion between electrons). Here we will review some basic equations of quantum mechanics to understand quantum mechanical methods, such as Hartree-Fock, semiempirical, and density functional theory methods, that have been most widely used for the clay mineral modeling where simulation size is greater than the molecular cluster with several atoms. 

As far as understanding quantum mechanics is concerned, the math has now advanced to the uncomfortable point where some of its principles say certain conclusions have to be true, and others say they can t be true, simultaneously. In other words, human beings don t seem to be able to "understand" this relatively new science. However, we certainly are making good use of it, without a full understanding. 

The outlined general design principles illustrate that the development of functional materials needs to be informed by comprehensive and concise knowledge of system-level requirements. Successful design of materials with desired physical or electrochemical properties hinges, furthermore, on advances in understanding quantum mechanics of condensed matter, molecular and surface chemistry, electrostatics and statistical mechanics at the electrified interface, thermodynamics and kinetics of electrochemical reactions, and flow and transport in nanocomposite and porous media. 

The purpose of this chapter is to provide an introduction to tlie basic framework of quantum mechanics, with an emphasis on aspects that are most relevant for the study of atoms and molecules. After siumnarizing the basic principles of the subject that represent required knowledge for all students of physical chemistry, the independent-particle approximation so important in molecular quantum mechanics is introduced. A significant effort is made to describe this approach in detail and to coimnunicate how it is used as a foundation for qualitative understanding and as a basis for more accurate treatments. Following this, the basic teclmiques used in accurate calculations that go beyond the independent-particle picture (variational method and perturbation theory) are described, with some attention given to how they are actually used in practical calculations. 

Like the geometry of Euclid and the mechanics of Newton, quantum mechanics is an axiomatic subject. By making several assertions, or postulates, about the mathematical properties of and physical interpretation associated with solutions to the Scluodinger equation, the subject of quantum mechanics can be applied to understand behaviour in atomic and molecular systems. The fust of these postulates is ... 

The introductory treatment of quantum mechanics presented in this textbook is excellent. Particularly appealing is the effort devoted to developing a qualitative understanding of quantum-mechanical principles. 

This venerable book was written in 1935, shortly after the birth of modern quantum mechanics. Nevertheless, it remains one of the best sources for students seeking to gain an understanding of quantum-mechanical principles that are relevant in chemistry and chemical physics. Equally outstanding jobs are done in dealing with both quantitative and qualitative aspects of the subject. More accessible to most chemists than Landau and Lifschitz. 

A marvellous and rigorous treatment of non-relativistic quantum mechanics. Although best suited for readers with a fair degree of mathematical sophistication and a desire to understand the subject in great depth, the book contains all of the important ideas of the subject and many of the subtle details that are often missing from less advanced treatments. Unusual for a book of its type, highly detailed solutions are given for many illustrative example problems. 

Bethe provided the theoretical basis for understanding the scattering of fast electrons by atoms and molecules [3, 4]. We give below an outline of the quantum-mechanical approach to calculating the scattermg cross section. 

Many groups are now trying to fit frequency shift curves in order to understand the imaging mechanism, calculate the minimum tip-sample separation and obtain some chemical sensitivity (quantitative infonuation on the tip-sample interaction). The most conunon methods appear to be perturbation theory for considering the lever dynamics [103], and quantum mechanical simulations to characterize the tip-surface interactions [104]. Results indicate that the... 

This chapter concentrates on describing molecular simulation methods which have a counectiou with the statistical mechanical description of condensed matter, and hence relate to theoretical approaches to understanding phenomena such as phase equilibria, rare events, and quantum mechanical effects. 

Clusters are intennediates bridging the properties of the atoms and the bulk. They can be viewed as novel molecules, but different from ordinary molecules, in that they can have various compositions and multiple shapes. Bare clusters are usually quite reactive and unstable against aggregation and have to be studied in vacuum or inert matrices. Interest in clusters comes from a wide range of fields. Clusters are used as models to investigate surface and bulk properties [2]. Since most catalysts are dispersed metal particles [3], isolated clusters provide ideal systems to understand catalytic mechanisms. The versatility of their shapes and compositions make clusters novel molecular systems to extend our concept of chemical bonding, stmcture and dynamics. Stable clusters or passivated clusters can be used as building blocks for new materials or new electronic devices [4] and this aspect has now led to a whole new direction of research into nanoparticles and quantum dots (see chapter C2.17). As the size of electronic devices approaches ever smaller dimensions [5], the new chemical and physical properties of clusters will be relevant to the future of the electronics industry. 

Molecular orbitals were one of the first molecular features that could be visualized with simple graphical hardware. The reason for this early representation is found in the complex theory of quantum chemistry. Basically, a structure is more attractive and easier to understand when orbitals are displayed, rather than numerical orbital coefficients. The molecular orbitals, calculated by semi-empirical or ab initio quantum mechanical methods, are represented by isosurfaces, corresponding to the electron density surfeces Figure 2-125a). 

Clearly then, the understanding of chemical reactions under such a variety of conditions is still in its infancy and the prediction of the course and products of a chemical reaction poses large problems. The ab initio quantum mechanical calculation of the pathway and outcome of a single chemical reaction can only be... 

Covers theory and applications of ah initio quantum mechanics calculations. The discussions are useful for understanding the differences between ah initio and semi-empirical methods. Although both sections are valuable, the discussion of the applications oi ah initio theory fills a void. It includes comparisons between experiment and many types and levels of calculation. The material is helpful in determining strategies for, and the validity of. ah initio calculations. 

There is a lot of confusion over the meaning of the terms theoretical chemistry, computational chemistry and molecular modelling. Indeed, many practitioners use all three labels to describe aspects of their research, as the occasion demands "Theoretical chemistry is often considered synonymous with quantum mechanics, whereas computational chemistry encompasses not only quantum mechanics but also molecular mechaiucs, minimisation, simulations, conformational analysis and other computer-based methods for understanding and predicting the behaviour of molecular systems. Molecular modellers use all of these methods and so we shall not concern ourselves with semantics but rather shall consider any theoretical or computational tecluiique that provides insight into the behaviour of molecular systems to be an example of molecular modelling. If a distinction has to be... 

Before moving deeper into understanding what quantum mechanics means, it is useful to learn how the wavefunctions E are found by applying the basic equation of quantum mechanics, the Schrodinger equation, to a few exactly soluble model problems. Knowing the solutions to these easy yet chemically very relevant models will then facilitate learning more of the details about the structure of quantum mechanics because these model cases can be used as concrete examples. ... 

---