Transition states, templating

Control in biocatalytic systems comes from such new techniques as directed evolution [52], the formation of catalytic antibodies using transition state templates [53], and the powerful approach of site-directed mutagenesis [54], In both heterogeneous and enzymatic catalysis, rather than take what you get, we now try to design what we want and devise clever chemical and biological approaches to get it. 

Transcription (Section 28 11) Construction of a strand of mRNA complementary to a DNA template Transfer RNA (tRNA) (Section 28 11) A polynucleotide of n hose that is bound at one end to a unique amino acid This ammo acid is incorporated into a growing peptide chain Transition state (Section 3 1) The point of maximum energy in an elementary step of a reaction mechanism Translation (Section 28 12) The reading of mRNA by van ous tRNAs each one of which is unique for a particular ammo acid... 

A potential major benefit of a cyclohexene-based template was the capacity to mimic more closely the putative transition state sialosyl cation by the placement of a double bond in the correct position. While the ring conformation in Neu5Ac2en 4 is very similar to the sialosyl cation transition state 5, these two stracmres are essentially isomers due to the fact that the double bond is either between the ring oxygen and C-2 in 5 or C-2 and C-3 in 4. The synthesis and biological evaluation of... 

The latter method, the template method, involves a reaction to produce a transition state similar to the desired product using a template. The template should have a shape similar to the space of the product. The template interacts with the substrate by forming noncovalent bonds such as coordination bonds (Fig. 3). The representative and most successful examples are found in crown ether chemistry. In the chemistry, alkali metals act as templates to create a crown-ether-like transition state with an ethylene glycol substrate by using metal-oxygen coordination bonds. 

The coupling reaction of 1 (M=Zn) affords CPO 3 (M=Zn) in 55% yield in the presence of template 2 however, the absence of 2 decreases the yield to 34% [22]. With the increase of yield of 3, template 2 induces the selectivity of the reaction the yield of the by-product (cychc dimer 4 (M=Zn)) was changed from 23% (with no template) to 6% (in the presence of template). A similar CPO formation reaction was reported for the corresponding ruthenium porphyrins (3, M=Ru(CO)), in which the stability constant of the Ru-N coordination bond is 10 larger than that of the Zn-N coordination bond [23]. Although the transition state of the CPO produced by the ruthenium-based substrate is expected to be more stable than that produced by ZnPor, the yield of 3 (M=Ru(CO)) is only... 

The incorporation of an ionizable center, such as an amine or similar function, into a template can bring a number of benefits, including water solubility. A key step in the discovery of the protease inhibitor, indinavir was the incorporation of a basic amine (and a pyridine) into the backbone of hydroxyethylene transition state mimic compounds L-685,434 to enhance solubility (and potency) (Fig. 1.2) [17]. 

In order to test this proposal, several theozymes were constructed.1101 Antibody 26D9 was originally elicited in response to a piperidine-N-oxide hapten (4, Figure 2), in which the polarized N-0 bond was meant to mimic the breaking C-0 bond of the epoxide in the cyclization transition state, and the 6-membered piperidine ring was used to represent the size and shape of the 6-endo transition state Hapten 4 was used as a template to create several... 

The most interesting developments involve catalysis of simple aldol reactions. The key to reactive immunisation is the use of a hapten that is chemically reactive, rather than a passive template. This means that (i) relevant chemistry is going on during the course of antibody induction, which thus happens in the presence of intermediates involved in the reaction, and so may be modified to favor the formation of antibodies which bind these intermediates (and perhaps transition states leading to them). Furthermore (ii) it becomes possible to select for antibodies that react with, rather than just bind, to the hapten. The system used for the development of aldolase antibodies is outlined in Scheme 2... 

The ability of a chemical to act as a template is frequently attributed to a combination of thermodynamic and kinetic factors. As has been defined by Busch [3] a thermodynamic template binds more strongly to one of the products present in an equilibrium (i.e. a mixture under thermodynamic control) shifting the reaction towards the formation of this specific product which is then obtained in higher yields. In contrast, kinetic templates operate under irreversible conditions by stabilising the transition state leading to the final product. 

In a recent study, some mechanistic aspects of this templated process have been determined quantitatively [28]. Using UV-Vis spectroscopy to monitor the kinetics of the macrocyclization reaction, it has been established that the rate of ring closure of the cationic precursor to the [ljimidazoliophane (4) is increased up to ten times in the presence of 0.04 mol/1 solution of a chloride source. The chloride stabilizes the transition state (i.e. a kinetic template) favouring the macrocyclization through hydrogen bonding. 

Molecular imprinting is not limited to organic polymer matrices, but can also be applied to silica-based materials and even proteins. Proteins freeze-dried in the presence of a transition state analogue as template have been used successfully as catalysts, e.g., for the dehydrofluorination of a fluorobutanone. For instance, lyophilized 3-lactoglobulin imprinted in this manner with N-isopropyl-N-ni-trobenzyl-amine could accelerate the dehydrofluorination by a factor of 3.27 compared to the non-imprinted protein see Table 5 [62]. In a similar procedure, BSA was imprinted with N-methyl-N-(4-nitrobenzyl)-S-aminovaleric acid and showed an enhancement of the catalytic effect by a factor of 3.3 compared to the control protein for the same reaction see Table 5 [113]. 

In terms of enzyme catalysis, the following factors are likely to influence the magnitude of the rate enhancement in enzymatic processes (a) proximity and orientation effects (b) electrostatic complementarity of the enzyme s active site with respect to the reactant s stabilized transition state configuration (c) enzyme-bound metal ions that serve as template, that alter pK s of catalytic groups, that facilitate nucleophilic attack, and that have... 

In both cases the rigid cyclic template ensures a highly ordered transition state. 

Transition-state stabilization The active site often acts as a flexible molecular template that binds the substrate in a geometric structure resembling the activated transition state of the molecule (see T at the top of the curve in Figure 5.4). By stabilizing the substrate in its transition state, the enzyme greatly increases the concentration of the reactive intermediate that can be converted to product and, thus, accelerates the reaction. 

A. H. Zewail If we solve for the molecular Hamiltonian, we will be theorists I do, of course, understand the point by Prof. Quack and the answer comes from the nature of the system and the experimental approach. For example, in elementary systems studied by femtosecond transition-state spectroscopy one can actually clock the motion and deduce the potentials. In complex systems we utilize a variety of template-state detection to examine the dynamics, and, like every other approach, you/we use a variety of input to reach the final answer. Solving the structure of a protein by X-ray diffraction may appear impossible, but by using a number of variant diffractions, such as the heavy atom, one obtains the final answer. 

Kinetic template effects have been postulated in more typical organic aldol condensations, where metals such as lithium and zinc are likely to coordinate both the enolate or enamine nucleophile and the aldehyde in the transition state. The examples shown in Schemes 58184 and 59185 are illustrative of these reactions and the degree of selectivity obtained. The carboxylation of ketones and nitroalkanes by methyl magnesium carbonate to produce P-keto acids and a-nitro acids respectively provides early examples of similar reactions (Scheme 60).186 187 See also Section 61.1.4.4. 

Of special interest is the eventuality of stabilizing transition states by imprinting their features into cavities or adsorption sites using stable transition state analogs as templates. Studies towards such TSA footprint catalysis have been performed by generating TSA complementary sites as marks on the surface [7.73a] or as cavities in the bulk [7.73b] of silica gel. These imprinted catalytic sites showed pronounced substrate specificity [7.74a,b] (namely in the case of cavities [7.73 b]) and chiral selectivity [7.74c,d]. 

The ligands which undergo reaction can be bound to the metal ion in the transition state or in relatively stable, isolable complexes. There is often a geometrical or stereochemical factor in ligand reactions and this factor is manifest in the so-called template reactions. 

---