Thermodynamics consistency rate constants

The hyperbolic expression can be derived from a picture in which the mechanical motion involves a deterministic power stroke. Although this power stroke model can be generalized to include thermodynamically consistent rate constants (see (3)), the description of the mechanical transitions as deterministic processes is not consistent with microscopic reversibility and is incorrect. 

More importantly, as written, the partial derivative implies that a single rate constant is to be varied, holding all the others constant, and indeed this is the way it is implemented in many sensitivity analysis routines. The index y runs out to 2Areactions because each reaction has two rate constants, one for the forward direction, and one for the reverse. However, in order for the model to remain consistent with the laws of thermodynamics, the rate constant for the reverse of reaction y must vary simultaneously with the forward reaction, since the two rate constants must maintain a detailed-balance ratio related to the AGreaction, Eq. (2). This can be assured by specifying that the partial derivative is taken only for the forward reaction, while holding the thermochemistry fixed. Note that this also cuts the number of partial derivatives to be computed in half. These sensitivities should then be supplemented with sensitivities to the individual species thermochemistry as in Eq. (25) overall the number of partial derivatives to be computed per model prediction M, is... 

The applications of quantitative structure-reactivity analysis to cyclodextrin com-plexation and cyclodextrin catalysis, mostly from our laboratories, as well as the experimental and theoretical backgrounds of these approaches, are reviewed. These approaches enable us to separate several intermolecular interactions, acting simultaneously, from one another in terms of physicochemical parameters, to evaluate the extent to which each interaction contributes, and to predict thermodynamic stabilities and/or kinetic rate constants experimentally undetermined. Conclusions obtained are mostly consistent with those deduced from experimental measurements. 

Seminal studies on the dynamics of proton transfer in the triplet manifold have been performed on HBO [109]. It was found that in the triplet states of HBO, the proton transfer between the enol and keto tautomers is reversible because the two (enol and keto) triplet states are accidentally isoenergetic. In addition, the rate constant is as slow as milliseconds at 100 K. The results of much slower proton transfer dynamics in the triplet manifold are consistent with the earlier summarization of ESIPT molecules. Based on the steady-state absorption and emission spectroscopy, the changes of pKa between the ground and excited states, and hence the thermodynamics of ESIPT, can be deduced by a Forster cycle [65]. Accordingly, compared to the pKa in the ground state, the decrease of pKa in the... 

Free radical addition of HBr to buta-1,2-diene (lb) affords dibromides exo-6b, (E)-6b and (Z)-6b, which consistently originate from Br addition to the central allene carbon atom [37]. The fact that the internal olefins (E)-6b and (Z)-6b dominate among the reaction products points to a thermodynamic control of the termination step (see below). The geometry of the major product (Z)-(6b) has been correlated with that of the preferred structure of intermediate 7b. The latter, in turn, has been deduced from an investigation of the configurational stability of the (Z)-methylallyl radical (Z)-8, which isomerizes with a rate constant of kiso=102s 1 (-130 °C) to the less strained E-stereoisomer (fc)-8 (Scheme 11.4) [38]. 

A point of occasional confusion arises with respect to units. In Eq. (15.22), all portions are unitless except for k T/h, which has units of sec , entirely consistent with the units expected for a unimolecular rate constant. In Eq. (15.23), the same is true with respect to the r.h.s., but a bimolecular rate constant has units of concentration" sec", which seems paradoxical. The point is diat, as with any thermodynamic quantity, one must pay close attention to standard-state conventions. Recall that die magnitude of die iranslational partition function depends on specification of a standard-state volume (or pressure, under ideal gas conditions). Thus, a more complete way to write Eq. (15.23) is... 

In specifying rate constants in a reaction mechanism, it is common to give the forward rate constants parameterized as in Eq. 9.83 for every reaction, and temperature-dependent fits to the thermochemical properties of each species in the mechanism. Reverse rate constants are not given explicitly but are calculated from the equilibrium constant, as outlined above. This approach has at least two advantages. First, if the forward and reverse rate constants for reaction i were both explicitly specified, their ratio (via the expressions above) would implicitly imply the net thermochemistry of the reaction. Care would need to be taken to ensure that the net thermochemistry implied by all reactions in a complicated mechanism were internally self-consistent, which is necessary but by no means ensured. Second, for large reaction sets it is more concise to specify the rate coefficients for only the forward reactions and the temperature-dependent thermodynamic properties of each species, rather than listing rate coefficients for both the forward and reverse reactions. Nonetheless, both approaches to describing the reverse-reaction kinetics are used by practitioners. 

A chemical kinetic model usually consists of a detailed reaction mechanism and a set of thermodynamic data for the species in the mechanism. The thermodynamic data are required to estimate the heat release of the reaction and to estimate reverse rate constants based on knowledge of the forward rate constant. 

Miller and Wolfenden6 compared the rates of decarboxylation of the substrate of orotidine-5 -monophosphate decarboxylase (OMPDC) in quantitative detail, on and off the enzyme. They showed that the apparent unimolecular rate constant of decarboxylation of the substrate when bound to the enzyme is about 1015 times greater than the decarboxylation process in the absence of the enzyme. Further studies confirm that the enzyme-promoted reaction does not involve additional intermediates or covalent alterations of the substrate. The reaction consists of carbon dioxide being formed and the resulting carbanion becoming protonated. Since thermodynamic barriers are not altered by catalysis, the energy of the carbanion must be a component that reflects the energy of the environment in which it is created, one in which the carbanion that is formed is selectively stabilized. 

Practical applications of the theory of NMR lineshapes of dynamic spectra can be divided into two general groups. One concerns investigations of intra- and inter-molecular reaction mechanisms. The other deals with the determination of kinetic and thermodynamic parameters for equilibria. In the former case the verification of reaction mechanisms usually consists of qualitative comparisons between experimental spectra and those simulated for various values of the rate constants using either visual inspection or visual fitting. 

As shown in Scheme 1 (17,19,21), rapid catalytic addition of to I produces Ilia and Illb. The presence of Ilia and the absence of Illb in the products is at least qualitatively consistent with the fact that the former is kinetically favored while the latter is thermodynamically favored (17,19,21). Structure-reactivity relationships provide a preference for hy-drogenolysis of the N-C(2) bond rather than the C(8a)-N bond in Ilia producing V rather than 3-phenylpropylamine. Both Ilia and Illb are converted to decahydroquinoline (VI), mass 139 the rate constant for the latter conversion is significantly greater than the one for the former (17,19,21). The absence of significant amounts of VI in the products is consistent with its facile conversion to hydrocarbons and NH (17,19,21,35). 

Example 13.5 The Belousov-Zhabotinsky reaction scheme Field et al. (1972) explained the qualitative behavior of the Belousov-Zhabotinsky reaction, using the principles of kinetics and thermodynamics. A simplified model with three variable concentrations producing all the essential features of the Belousov-Zhabotinsky reaction was published by Field and Noyes (1974). Some new models of Belousov-Zhabotinsky reaction scheme consist of as main as 22 reaction steps. With the defined symbols X = HBr02, Y = Br, Z = Ce4+, B = organic, A = B1O3 (the rate constant contains H+), FKN Model (Field et al., 1972) consists of the following steps summarized by Kondepudi and Priogogine (1999) ... 

We have seen in Sec. IV.4 that for thermodynamic consistency a specific rate constant should be capable of being represented in the form... 

Self-consistency of postulated forward and reverse rate equations can be tested with the principles of thermodynamic consistency and so-called microscopic reversibility. The former invokes the fact that forward and reverse rates must be equal at equilibrium the latter is for loops in networks and can be stated as requiring that the products of the clockwise and counter-clockwise rate coefficients of the loop must be equal, or, for catalytic cycles, that the product of the forward coefficients must equal that of the reverse coefficients multiplied with the equilibrium constant of the catalyzed reaction. 

It has been said that only termination, but not dissociation, involves a collision partner M and that the ratio klm, ikcB, in the rate equation does not equal the dissociation equilibrium constant because the two coefficients are "not linked by detailed balancing" [16], However, this argument is without merit. In the absence of H2 (or any other species with which Br- can react), thermodynamic consistency and microscopic reversibility clearly require M to participate in dissociation if it does so in recombination. The addition of any species such as H2 that takes no part in the dissociation step may cause the system to deviate from thermodynamic dissociation equilibrium, but can obviously not alter the mechanism of dissociation. 

Rate constants and equilibrium constants should be checked for thermodynamic consistency if at all possible. For example, the heat of adsorption derived from the temperature dependence of should be negative since adsorption reactions are almost always exothermic. Likewise, the entropy change A5ads for nondissociative adsorption must be negative since every gas phase molecule loses translational entropy upon adsorption. In fact, AS < S (where Sg is the gas phase entropy) must also be satisfied because a molecule caimot lose more entropy than it originally possessed in the gas phase. A proposed kinetic sequence that produces adsorption rate constants and/or equilibrium constants that do not satisfy these basic principles should be either discarded or considered very suspiciously. 

The thermodynamics and kinetics of H+ binding to cobalt(I) and nickel(I) macrocycles have been determined. The pAia of Ni(cyclam)(H), / / 5 5 -NiHTIM(H) + and A-rac-CoHMD(H) + are 1.8, 1.9 and 11.7, respectively [14, 24, 27]. As seen from Table 3, protonation rate constants for A-rac-CoHMD depend on acid strength. The results are consistent with an associative reaction of the square-planar complex with an acid, HA. Whereas the spectrum of 7V-rac-CoHMD(H) + suggests the formation of a [Co (H )] + species with an absorption band at 440 nm (520 M cm ), Ni(cyclam)(H) + shows no significant absorbance in the 300-700 nm region [14, 24]. 

---