Strychnine Woodward

In the post-World War II years, synthesis attained a different level of sophistication partly as a result of the confluence of five stimuli (1) the formulation of detailed electronic mechanisms for the fundamental organic reactions, (2) the introduction of conformational analysis of organic structures and transition states based on stereochemical principles, (3) the development of spectroscopic and other physical methods for structural analysis, (4) the use of chromatographic methods of analysis and separation, and (5) the discovery and application of new selective chemical reagents. As a result, the period 1945 to 1960 encompassed the synthesis of such complex molecules as vitamin A (O. Isler, 1949), cortisone (R. Woodward, R. Robinson, 1951), strychnine (R. Woodward, 1954), cedrol (G. Stork, 1955), morphine (M. Gates, 1956), reserpine (R. Woodward, 1956), penicillin V (J. Sheehan, 1957), colchicine (A. Eschenmoser, 1959), and chlorophyll (R. Woodward, 1960) (page 5). ... 

Three new papers bearing on the structure of strychnine have become available too late for inclusion in this summary of recent work. Woodward, Brehm and Nelson have compared the ultra-violet absorption spectra of strychnine and Leuchs s strychnone (p.. 559) and used the results for a discussion of the relationship of the two alkaloids. Prelog and Kathriner have investigated the oxidation of strychnine, i/t-strychnine and brucine by permanganate in weakly acid solution and Bailey and Robinson from a study of the brucones have confirmed the conclusion of Woodward et al. that Leuchs s strychnone is a true indole derivative. Mention must also be made of a paper by Clemo and King on new reduction products of strychnine, of which a preliminary account has been published with a summary of the ensuing discussion. 

Comparatively few alterations have been made since 1989 in the structures accepted for well-known alkaloids. A slight but important change has been adopted in the formula of strychnine and contributions to the chemistry of that alkaloid and its associates are still being made, though the formula seems now so well established that Woodward has recently suggested and discussed a scheme for the biogenesis of strychnine on which Robinson has commented favourably. Robinson has also proposed a scheme for the biogenesis of emetine. This involves a modification in the formula of that alkaloid, which is supported by Dewar s interpretation of the results of recent chemical work on emetine by Karrer et al., by Spath and by Pailer. ... 

Woodward s strychnine synthesis commences with a Fischer indole synthesis using phenylhydrazine (24) and acetoveratrone (25) as starting materials (see Scheme 2). In the presence of polyphosphor-ic acid, intermediates 24 and 25 combine to afford 2-veratrylindole (23) through the reaction processes illustrated in Scheme 2. With its a position suitably masked, 2-veratrylindole (23) reacts smoothly at the ft position with the Schiff base derived from the action of dimethylamine on formaldehyde to give intermediate 22 in 92% yield. TV-Methylation of the dimethylamino substituent in 22 with methyl iodide, followed by exposure of the resultant quaternary ammonium iodide to sodium cyanide in DMF, provides nitrile 26 in an overall yield of 97%. Condensation of 2-veratryl-tryptamine (20), the product of a lithium aluminum hydride reduction of nitrile 26, with ethyl glyoxylate (21) furnishes Schiff base 19 in a yield of 92%. 

The structural homology between intermediate 4 and isostrych-nine I (3) is obvious intermediates 3 and 4 are simply allylic isomers and the synthetic problem is now reduced to isomerizing the latter substance into the former. Treatment of 4 with hydrogen bromide in acetic acid at 120°C results in the formation of a mixture of isomeric allylic bromides which is subsequently transformed into isostrychnine I (3) with boiling aqueous sulfuric acid. Following precedent established in 194810 and through the processes outlined in Scheme 8a, isostrychnine I (3) is converted smoothly to strychnine (1) upon treatment with potassium hydroxide in ethanol. Woodward s landmark total synthesis of strychnine (1) is now complete. 

Scheme 4.1 Oxidative cleavage of an electron-rich aromatic ring was a key component of Woodward s proposal for a biogenesis of the Strychnos alkaloids and a key step in his subsequent synthesis of strychnine...

More recent examples of biomimetic synthesis are the syntheses of thebaine [11] and usnic acid [12], as well as strychnine [13], morphine alkaloids [11] [14] and a great number of terpenic compounds [15]. On the other hand, hypothetic prebiotic considerations may also simplify tremendously the synthetic plans. Such is the case, for example, of the work of Eschenmoser on vitamin B12 who, after synthesising it in collaboration with Woodward by a linear sequence of almost fifty steps [16], investigated the prebiotic origen of this complex molecule. The experimental work undertaken in this direction demonstrates that the amount of "external instruction" required for "self-assembling" the different structural elements present in this molecule is surprisingly small. This fact could eventually lead to a very simple synthesis of vitamin Bj2 starting from a-amino nitriles which would involve only a few steps [17]. 

In less repetitive syntheses, it is possible to use remote functional groups as "control elements", a technique which depends more upon the opportunist tactics developed in the course of a synthesis rather than of a premeditated strategy. Such is the case, for instance, of the synthesis of strychnine (i) by Woodward [2], in which after synthesising the intermediate 2 a hydrogen at C(8) must be introduced onto the P-face (4), i.e., onto the most hindered concave face of the molecule (Scheme 8.1). Usually the reduction with a metal hydride would lead to the a-C(8)-H isomer (i.e., the hydride ion will atack from the less hindered face of the molecule), however in the present case the P-OH group at C(21) acts as a control element and, besides the reduction of the amide at C(20), a hydride ion attacks at C(8) from the P-face by an intramolecular transfer of the complex C(21)-0-Al-H (3). 

Level 2 The atoms or groups of atoms of the different control elements, once the control has been exerted, are used in subsequent stages of the synthesis to build up the carbon skeleton of the target molecule, so that they become an integral part of it. This is the case in Woodward s synthesis of strychnine. 

Woodward then moved across town in Cambridge to devote a year of postgraduate study at Harvard University. At the end of that year, he accepted an appointment to the Harvard chemistry faculty, a post he held for most of the rest of his life. One of his great interests at Harvard was the synthesis of large, complex molecules, the first of which was quinine in 1944. He followed that work with the elucidation of other molecular structures and the development of synthetic methods for each. Included among these molecules were penicillin (1945), patulin (1948), cholesterol and cortisone (1951), oxytetracycline (1952), strychnine (1954), lysergic acid (1954), reserpine (1956), chlorophyll (1960), colchicine (1963), cephalosporin C (1965), and vitamin (1971). 

Among the recent outstanding contributions to the chemistry of natural products is the conformational analysis designed by Derek Barton. He used it for the structural determinations of many complex molecules such as P-amyrin and cycloartenol. Robert B. Woodward was involved in the structural determinations of penicillin, strychnine, patalin, terramycin, aureomycin and the synthesis ofVitamin B12. 

L. B. Slater, Woodward, Robinson and strychnine chemical structure and chemists challenge , Ambix, 2001, 48, 161-189. 

Woodward in 1953, required 28 steps (not vety many when the complexity of the molecule is considered). More recently, strychnine has been prepared, enantiomerically pure, in 20 steps with an overall yield of 3% ... 

The final stage was reached when Woodward and his collaborators announced the total synthesis of strychnine, a truly great achievement (see Section IV) (39). 

The total synthesis was achieved in 1954 by Woodward and his collaborators (156). Before this, various unsuccessful attempts had been made to make a start toward a synthesis of strychnine (179, 180, 181, 182,) but these are now of little interest, with the exception of Robinson s idea (182) to emulate the postulated biosynthesis by attempting to synthesize the dialdehyde CCXVI, which then might be induced to cyclize by a combination of Mannich and aldol type condensations to the Wieland-Gumlich aldehyde (LV) the synthesis of CCXVI unfortunately was not realized. Much more recently, however, this idea has been used by van Tamelen et al. (184), who successfully synthesized the dialdehyde CCXVII and converted it in aqueous acetic acid-sodium... 

Woodward s synthesis of strychnine stands out as a major synthetic achievement (156). The plan of this synthesis was also strongly influenced by biogenetic considerations, but no short cuts were taken, and the synthesis proceeds step by step, at all stages fully under control. 

Strychnine was discovered and identified as the main toxic principle of Strychnos in 1818, although nux vomica, the unpurified plant extract in which it is the active component, had been known and used for both medicinal and criminal purposes for some time. Historic records indicate that the strychnine alkaloid had been used to kill dogs, cats, and birds in Emope as far back as 1640. The structure of strychnine was first determined in 1946 by Sir Robert Robinson and in 1954 this alkaloid was synthesized in a laboratory by Robert W. Woodward. This is one of the most famous syntheses in the history of organic chemistry. Both chemists won the Nobel prize (Robinson in 1947 and Woodward in 1965). 

Sometimes people do engage in intense competition. Some like it, and some believe that advances in science are not unrelated to competition. Others disagree. It may play a role. There have been famous competitions, between Woodward and Robinson, for instance, in the steroid synthesis, or in the determination of the structure of strychnine. Some people love the type of competition common in sport Who will make cholesterol first At one time, everybody was fascinated by who would be the first to achieve a four-minute mile, and I must admit that I remember that it was Bannister. Today, many people run the mile in considerably less than four minutes. Is it important who did it first It s not but it is striking. 

---