Solvent effects, and rate

The equation does not take into account such pertubation factors as steric effects, solvent effects, and ion-pair formation. These factors, however, may be neglected when experiments are carried out in the same solvent at the same temperature and concentration for an homogeneous set of substrates. So, for a given ambident nucleophile the rate ratio kj/kj will depend on A and B, which vary with (a) the attacked electrophilic center, (b) the solvent, and (c) the counterpart cationic species of the anion. The important point in this kind of study is to change only one parameter at a time. This simple rule has not always been followed, and little systematic work has been done in this field (12) stiH widely open after the discovery of the role played by single electron transfer mechanism in ambident reactivity (1689). 

Ultimately physical theories should be expressed in quantitative terms for testing and use, but because of the eomplexity of liquid systems this can only be accomplished by making severe approximations. For example, it is often neeessary to treat the solvent as a continuous homogeneous medium eharaeterized by bulk properties such as dielectric constant and density, whereas we know that the solvent is a molecular assemblage with short-range structure. This is the basis of the current inability of physical theories to account satisfactorily for the full scope of solvent effects on rates, although they certainly can provide valuable insights and they undoubtedly capture some of the essential features and even cause-effect relationships in solution kinetics. Section 8.3 discusses physical theories in more detail. 

Because the key operation in studying solvent effects on rates is to vary the solvent, evidently the nature of the solvation shell will vary as the solvent is changed. A distinction is often made between general and specific solvent effects, general effects being associated (by hypothesis) with some appropriate physical property such as dielectric constant, and specific effects with particular solute-solvent interactions in the solvation shell. In this context the idea of preferential solvation (or selective solvation) is often invoked. If a reaction is studied in a mixed solvent. 

We now consider a type of analysis in which the data (which may consist of solvent properties or of solvent effects on rates, equilibria, and spectra) again are expressed as a linear combination of products as in Eq. (8-81), but now the statistical treatment yields estimates of both a, and jc,. This method is called principal component analysis or factor analysis. A key difference between multiple linear regression analysis and principal component analysis (in the chemical setting) is that regression analysis adopts chemical models a priori, whereas in factor analysis the chemical significance of the factors emerges (if desired) as a result of the analysis. We will not explore the statistical procedure, but will cite some results. We have already encountered examples in Section 8.2 on the classification of solvents and in the present section in the form of the Swain et al. treatment leading to Eq. (8-74). 

The reactivity of macromonomers in copolymerizalion is strongly dependent on the particular comonomer-macromonomer pair. Solvent effects and the viscosity of the polymerization medium can also be important. Propagation may become diffusion controlled such that the propagation rate constant and reactivity ratios depend on the molecular weight of the macromonomer and the viscosity or, more accurately, the free volume of the medium. 

PEDRIELLI p, PEDULLi G F and SKIBSTED L H (2001a) Antioxidant mechanism of flavonoids. Solvent effect on rate constant for chain-braining reaction of quercetin and epicatechin in autoxidation of methyl linoleate, JAgric Food Chem, 49, 3034-40. 

Co2(CO)q system, reveals that the reactions proceed through mononuclear transition states and intermediates, many of which have established precedents. The major pathway requires neither radical intermediates nor free formaldehyde. The observed rate laws, product distributions, kinetic isotope effects, solvent effects, and thermochemical parameters are accounted for by the proposed mechanistic scheme. Significant support of the proposed scheme at every crucial step is provided by a new type of semi-empirical molecular-orbital calculation which is parameterized via known bond-dissociation energies. The results may serve as a starting point for more detailed calculations. Generalization to other transition-metal catalyzed systems is not yet possible. 

Reactions in solution proceed in a similar manner, by elementary steps, to those in the gas phase. Many of the concepts, such as reaction coordinates and energy barriers, are the same. The two theories for elementary reactions have also been extended to liquid-phase reactions. The TST naturally extends to the liquid phase, since the transition state is treated as a thermodynamic entity. Features not present in gas-phase reactions, such as solvent effects and activity coefficients of ionic species in polar media, are treated as for stable species. Molecules in a liquid are in an almost constant state of collision so that the collision-based rate theories require modification to be used quantitatively. The energy distributions in the jostling motion in a liquid are similar to those in gas-phase collisions, but any reaction trajectory is modified by interaction with neighboring molecules. Furthermore, the frequency with which reaction partners approach each other is governed by diffusion rather than by random collisions, and, once together, multiple encounters between a reactant pair occur in this molecular traffic jam. This can modify the rate constants for individual reaction steps significantly. Thus, several aspects of reaction in a condensed phase differ from those in the gas phase ... 

Full -polarization in diradicals can give rise to zwitterionic products. First examples were studied in detail by Carpenter and coworker who investigated solvent effects on rates and product distribution in Myers-Saito cyclizations.64 Polar solvents and substitution patterns that stabilize either positive or negative charges (or both) favor the zwitterionic products. For example, the presence of a dimethylamino group leads to stabilization of cations and isolation of pyrrolo-quinolines, rather than pyrido-indoles from eneyne-carbodiimides, as reported by Wang and coworkers (Scheme 14).65... 

These results led to a separation of the observed Diels-Alder reactivities into three categories (a) increase of the rate constants on increasing the Lewis acid character of the solvent as quantified by the AN parameter this behaviour reflects the interactions between the LUMO of the solvent and the HOMO of the reactants and is similar to Lewis acid catalysis (vide supra) (b) reaction retardation by electron donation, as quantified by the D-ji parameter the HOMOsoivent-LUMOreactant interactions are held responsible for this effect, representing an anti-Lewis acid interaction which increases the HOMO-LUMO gap and hence hampers the reaction (c) the Diels-Alder reactions show very small solvent effects and are relatively insensitive to specific reactant-solvent interactions, and... 

TABLE 7.5 Solvent Effects and Combined Lewis-Acid/Micellar Catalysis Increasing the Rate Constant of Reaction (1)... 

The acid-catalysed hydrolysis of the acylal, 1-phenoxyethyl propionate (13), has been studied using the PM3 method in the gas phase. The kinetics and mechanism of the hydrolysis of tetrahydro-2-furyl and tetrahydropyran-2-yl alkanoates (14) in water and water-20% ethanol have been reported. In acidic and neutral media, kinetics, activation parameters, isotope-exchange studies, substituent effects, solvent effects and the lack of buffer catalysis pointed clearly to an Aai-1 mechanism with formation of the tetrahydro-2-furyl or tetrahydropyran-2-yl carbocation as the rate-limiting step (Scheme 1). There is no evidence of a base-promoted Bac2 mechanism up to pH 12. ... 

Reports on solvent effects on rate constants for aquation of diimine complexes include those on [Fe(5Brphen)3] + and [Fe(4,7-Me2phen)3] " " in methanol- and ethanol-water, [Fe(bipy)3] +, [Fe(phen)3] +, and [Fe(5N02phen)3] + in aqueous methyl D-glycopyranosides, and... 

Figure 2 Diagrammatic summary of selected structural, substituent, and solvent effects on rate constants (kj, at 298 K) for base hydrolysis of low spin iron(II)-diimine complexes. Ligand abbreviations not appearing in the list at the end of this chapter are apmi = (73) with = Me BOH cage = (78) with X = OH ...

Haloform reaction, 237, 296 Halogenation alkanes, 300, 323 alkenes, 179,186, 313 benzene, 138,316 ketones, 295 Hammett equation, 362 additional parameters, 374, 388, 395 derivation of, 362 deviations from, 375 empirical nature of, 395 implications of, 394 reaction pathway, and, 375 solvent effects and, 388 spectroscopic correlations, 392 standard reaction for, 362, 395 steric effects and, 361, 383 thermodynamic implications of, 394 Hammett plots, 359 change in rate-limiting step and, 383 change in reaction pathway and, 378... 

The activity of polymer-supported crown ethers depends on solvent. As shown in Fig. 11, rates for Br-I exchange reactions with catalysts 34 and 41 increased with a change in solvent from toluene to chlorobenzene. Since the reaction with catalyst 34 is limited substantially by intrinsic reactivity (Fig. 10), the rate increase must be due to an increase in intrinsic reactivity. The reaction with catalyst 41 is limited by both intrinsic reactivity and intraparticle diffusion (Fig. 10), and the rate increase from toluene to chlorobenzene corresponds with increases in both parameters. Solvent effects on rates with polymer-supported phase transfer catalysts differ from those with soluble phase transfer catalysts60. With the soluble catalysts rates increase (for a limited number of reactions) with decreased polarity of solvent60), while with the polymeric catalysts rates increase with increased polarity of solvent74). Solvents swell polymer-supported catalysts and influence the microenvironment of active sites as well as intraparticle diffusion. The microenvironment, especially hydration... 

Despite the impressive knowledge accumulated on some of the more common organic reactions, the question of true intrinsic reactivity is still at large in most cases. It is known that rates and mechanisms can be influenced by solvent effects, and that such changes can seldom be accommodated by rigorous theoretical treatments which are only applicable to isolated species. Thus, the concept of intrinsic reactivity should be, in principle, derived from chemical behaviour in a solvent-free environment. This statement is particularly relevant for reactions involving ionic species which are subject to strong electrostatic interactions with the solvent. 

---