Separation by distillation

Distillation is the most mature separation method in industry and its design and operation procedures are well established. Only when vapour-liquid equilibrium or other data are uncertain, are laboratory and/or pilot plant studies necessary prior to the design of a commercial unit. 

Distillation differs from absorption in that the second fluid phase is created by thermal means (ESA), vapourisation and condensation, rather than by the introduction of a second phase that usually contains an additional component or components not present in the feed mixture (MSA). 

Distillation is a separation method that utilizes the different boiling points of the various components in a mixture to effect separation. Although distillation has been employed for centuries as a separation technique, the theory of the process for any but the simplest mixtures is extremely complex. However, here we are less interested in the theoretical aspects of distillation than in the factors that influence the technique as a tool for separation. 

Answer (d) is correct. The mixture starts to boil at 92 °C there is no simple relationship between the boiling temperature of the mixture and the boiling temperatures of the pure substances. (If you selected the wrong answer don t be too alarmed there are still some modern chemistry textbooks that would tell you that the mixture would boil at 80 °C ) 

However, as a separation technique, we are not so interested in the boiling temperature as in the nature of the liquid that is collected in the receiver. 

In the above distillation, what do you think will be collected in the receiver  

You may be surprised at the separating efficiency the first drop of liquid collected consists of 70% (by mass) of benzene and 30% (by mass) of toluene that is, we have produced a 70 30 mixture from a 50 50 mixture. As you can see, the separation is not ideal. Furthermore, the first drop of liquid provides the best separation as distillation proceeds, the boiling temperature increases as the relative amount of toluene distilling over increases. So, even for components with a difference in boiling temperature as great as 30 °C, the separation is poor. Such a procedure is useful only when there is a very large difference between the boiling temperatures of the components that are to be separated. 

In a distillation column, vapor and liquid flow in countercurrent directions to each other. Liquid is vaporized at the bottom, and vapor is condensed from the top product and withdrawn from the column. A number of trays are placed in the column, or the column is packed with open material, so that the vapor phase contacts the liquid phase, and components are transferred from one phase to the other. As you proceed up the column the temperature decreases, and the net effect is an increase in the more volatile component(s) in the vapor and a decrease in the less volatile components in the liquid. Vapor is withdrawn from the top of the column and liquid from the bottom. Feed to the column usually enters part way up the column. 

A liquid adhesive, which is used to make laminated boards, consists of a polymer dissolved in a solvent. The amount of polymer in the solution has to be carefully controlled for this application. When the supplier of the adhesive receives an order for 3000 kg of an adhesive solution containing 13 wt % polymer, all it has on hand is (1) 500 kg of a 10 wt % solution, (2) a very large quantity of a 20 wt % solution, and (3) pure solvent. 

Calculate the weight of each of the three stocks that must be blended together to fill the order. Use all of the 10 wt % solution. 

Steps 1, 2, 3 and 4 This is a steady state process without reaction. 

Step 7 and 8 Two component balances and one total balance can be made. Only 2 of the balances are independent. 

---

Another possibility to improve selectivity is to reduce the concentration of monoethanolamine in the reactor by using more than one reactor with intermediate separation of the monoethanolamine. Considering the boiling points of the components given in Table 2.3, then separation by distillation is apparently possible. Unfortunately, repeated distillation operations are likely to be very expensive. Also, there is a market to sell both di- and triethanolamine, even though their value is lower than that of monoethanolamine. Thus, in this case, repeated reaction and separation are probably not justified, and the choice is a single plug-flow reactor. 

If an azeotropic mixture is to be separated by distillation, then use of pressure change to alter the azeotropic composition should be considered before use of an extraneous mass-separating agent. Avoiding the use of extraneous materials often can prevent environmental problems later in the design. 

TABLE 5.2 Data for Mixture of Alkanes to Be Separated by Distillation... 

Solutions of solids in liquids can sometimes be separated by distilling off the liquid and leaving a residue of the solid, e.g., acetone and acetamide. 

Commercial benzene may contain thiophene C H S, b.p. 84°, which cannot be separated by distillation or by fractional crystallisation. The presence of thiophene may be detected by shaking 3 ml. of benzene with a solution of 10 mg. of isatin in 10 ml. of concentrated sulphuric acid and allowing the mixture to stand for a short time a bluish-green colouration is produced if thiophene is present. The thiophene may be removed from benzene by any of the following methods —... 

The sulphuric acid treatment removes high-boiling impurities which are not easily separated by distillation. 

Electrolysis, under similar conditions, of a mixture of two carboxylic acids RCOOH and R COOH leads, in addition to normal coupling products R—R and R —R, to cross coupling R—R. If a mixture of a saturated carboxylic acid and a half ester of an ato-dicarboxylic acid is electrolysed, there are three main products, viz., a hydrocarbon (I), a mono-ester (II), and a di-ester (HI) and these are readily separable by distillation. Some unsaturated ester (IV) is often present in small quantity. 

Low molecular mass enol esters (e.g. acetates H.O. House, 1965) or enol ethers (e.g. silyl ethers H.O. House, 1969) of ketones can be synthesized regioselectively and/or separated by distillation. Treatment with lithium alkyls converts them into the corresponding lithi-... 

When the ortho para directing bromine is introduced first the major product is p bro moacetophenone (along with some of its ortho isomer from which it is separated by distillation)... 

When benzene is prepared from coal tar it is contaminated thiophene from which it cannot be separated by distillation because of very similar boiling points Shaking a mixture of benzene and thiophene with sulfuric acid causes sulfonation of the thiophene ring but leaves benzene untouched The sulfonation product of thiophene dissolves m the sulfuric acid layer from which the benzene layer is separated the benzene layer is then washed with water and distilled Give the structure of the sulfonation product of thiophene... 

TABLE 5.11 Binary Azeotropic (Constant-Boiling) Mixtures An azeotrope is a mixture that cannot be separated by distillation. 

This krypton—xenon mixture is usually sent to a different location for separation by distillation and further purification by catalytic and/or adsorptive processes. 

Ma.nufa.cture. Nickel carbonyl can be prepared by the direct combination of carbon monoxide and metallic nickel (77). The presence of sulfur, the surface area, and the surface activity of the nickel affect the formation of nickel carbonyl (78). The thermodynamics of formation and reaction are documented (79). Two commercial processes are used for large-scale production (80). An atmospheric method, whereby carbon monoxide is passed over nickel sulfide and freshly reduced nickel metal, is used in the United Kingdom to produce pure nickel carbonyl (81). The second method, used in Canada, involves high pressure CO in the formation of iron and nickel carbonyls the two are separated by distillation (81). Very high pressure CO is required for the formation of cobalt carbonyl and a method has been described where the mixed carbonyls are scmbbed with ammonia or an amine and the cobalt is extracted as the ammine carbonyl (82). A discontinued commercial process in the United States involved the reaction of carbon monoxide with nickel sulfate solution. 

Environmental aspects, as well as the requirement of efficient mixing in the mixed acid process, have led to the development of single-phase nitrations. These can be divided into Hquid- and vapor-phase nitrations. One Hquid-phase technique involves the use of > 98% by weight nitric acid, with temperatures of 20—60°C and atmospheric pressure (21). The molar ratios of nitric acid benzene are 2 1 to 4 1. After the reaction is complete, excess nitric acid is vacuum distilled and recycled. An analogous process is used to simultaneously produce a nitrobenzene and dinitrotoluene mixture (22). A conversion of 100% is obtained without the formation of nitrophenols or nitrocresols. The nitrobenzene and dinitrotoluene are separated by distillation. 

The principle of azeotropic distillation depends on the abiHty of a chemically dissimilar compound to cause one or both components of a mixture to boil at a temperature other than the one expected. Thus, the addition of a nonindigenous component forms an azeotropic mixture with one of the components of the mixture, thereby lowering the boiling point and faciHtating separation by distillation. The separation of components of similar volatiHty may become economical if an entrainer can be found that effectively changes the relative volatiHty. It is also desirable that the entrainer be reasonably cheap, stable, nontoxic, and readily recoverable from the components. In practice, it is probably the ready recoverabiHty that limits the appHcation of extractive and azeotropic distillation. 

The mixture can be separated by distillation. The primary phosphine is recycled for use ia the subsequent autoclave batch, the secondary phosphine is further derivatized to the corresponding phosphinic acid which is widely employed ia the iadustry for the separation of cobalt from nickel by solvent extraction. With even more hindered olefins, such as cyclohexene [110-83-8] the formation of tertiary phosphines is almost nondetectable. 

Both the Toth and Alcoa processes provide aluminum chloride for subsequent reduction to aluminum. Pilot-plant tests of these processes have shown difficulties exist in producing aluminum chloride of the purity needed. In the Toth process for the production of aluminum chloride, kaolin [1332-58-7] clay is used as the source of alumina (5). The clay is mixed with sulfur and carbon, and the mixture is ground together, pelletized, and calcined at 700°C. The calcined mixture is chlorinated at 800°C and gaseous aluminum chloride is evolved. The clay used contains considerable amounts of silica, titania, and iron oxides, which chlorinate and must be separated. Silicon tetrachloride and titanium tetrachloride are separated by distillation. Resublimation of aluminum chloride is requited to reduce contamination from iron chloride. 

Most derivatives of aniline are not obtained from aniline itself, but ate prepared by hydrogenation of their nitroaromatic precursors. The exceptions, for example, /V-a1ky1ani1ines, /V-ary1ani1ines, sulfonated anilines, or the A/-acyl derivatives, can be prepared from aniline and have been discussed. Nitroanilines are usually prepared by ammonolysis of the corresponding chloronitroben2ene. Special isolation methods may be requited for some derivatives if the boiling points are close and separation by distillation is not feasible. Table 6 Hsts some of the derivatives of aniline that are produced commercially. 

Methyl formate and propylene oxide have close boiling poiats, making separation by distillation difficult. Methyl formate is removed from propylene oxide by hydrolysis with an aqueous base and glycerol, followed by phase separation and distillation (152,153). Methyl formate may be hydrolyzed to methanol and formic acid by contacting the propylene oxide stream with a basic ion-exchange resia. Methanol and formic acid are removed by extractive distillation (154). 

In the gum rosin process, pine trees are wounded to stimulate the flow of gum. V-shaped slashes are cut through the bark, and the exudate is collected in a bucket below the slash. Production is stimulated by painting sulfuric acid on the slashes. The oleoresin (exudate) is separated by distillation into gum spidts of turpentine and gum rosin. The gum turpentine industry has decreased in importance in the 1990s because it is labor-intensive. The process is carried out in Russia, the People s Repubflc of China, Indonesia, Portugal, Brazil, and Mexico. 

Since the thermal dehydrocondensation proceeds by a free-radical mechanism (37), various radical-forrning promoters like acetone, ethanol, or methanol have been found useful in improving conversion of ben2ene to condensed polyphenyls. In the commercial dehydrocondensation process, ben2ene and some biphenyl are separated by distillation and recycled back to the dehydrocondensation step. Pure biphenyl is then collected leaving a polyphenyl residue consisting of approximately 4% o-terphenyl, 44% y -terphenyl, 25% -terphenyl, 1.5% triphenylene, and 22—27% higher polyphenyl and tars. Distillation of this residue at reduced pressure affords the mixed terphenyl isomers accompanied by a portion of the quaterphenyls present. 

The principal commercial source of 1-butanol is -butyraldehyde [123-72-8] obtained from the Oxo reaction of propylene. A mixture of n- and isobutyraldehyde [78-84-2] is obtained in this process this mixture is either separated initially and the individual aldehyde isomers hydrogenated, or the mixture of isomeric aldehydes is hydrogenated direcdy and the n- and isobutyl alcohol product mix separated by distillation. Typically, the hydrogenation is carried out in the vapor phase over a heterogeneous catalyst. For example, passing a mixture of n- and isobutyraldehyde with 60 40 H2 N2 over a CuO—ZnO—NiO catalyst at 25—196°C and 0.7 MPa proceeds in 99.95% efficiency to the corresponding alcohols at 98.6% conversion (7,8) (see Butyraldehydes Oxo process). 

Exothermicity. The catalytic reactions are often exothermic bond-forming reactions of small molecules that give larger molecules. Consequendy, the reactors are designed for efficient heat removal. They may be jacketed or contain coils for heat-transfer media, or the heat of reaction may be used to vaporize the products and aid in the downstream separation by distillation. 

Carbon Disulfide Chlorination. The chlorination of carbon disulfide [75-15-0] is a very old method of producing carbon tetrachloride that is still practiced commercially in the United States. In this process CS2 reacts continuously with chlorine in an annular reactor at 105—130°C. Product CCl is separated by distillation to a CS2 content of 0—5 ppm. By-product S2CI2 is reduced in a reactor at 450°C with hydrogen without a catalyst to give sulfur of 99.985% purity (32). Other processes use ferric chloride as a catalyst (33,34). 

Refining and Isomerization. Whatever chlorination process is used, the cmde product is separated by distillation. In successive steps, residual butadiene is stripped for recycle, impurities boiling between butadiene (—5° C) and 3,4-dichloto-l-butene [760-23-6] (123°C) are separated and discarded, the 3,4 isomer is produced, and 1,4 isomers (140—150°C) are separated from higher boiling by-products. Distillation is typically carried out continuously at reduced pressure in corrosion-resistant columns. Ferrous materials are avoided because of catalytic effects of dissolved metal as well as unacceptable corrosion rates. Nickel is satisfactory as long as the process streams are kept extremely dry. 

The dichlorobenzene isomers have very similar vapor pressures making separation by distillation difficult. Crystallization is generally used in combination with distillation to obtain the pure 1,2 and 1,4-dichlorobenzene isomers. The small quantity of 1,3-dichlorobenzene isomer produced is not generally isolated as a pure product. Environmental concerns have led to the use of improved crystalliza tion systems that contain the products with minimal losses to the environment. 

One patent (64) describes an extraction method to remove both trichloropropane and tetrachloropropyl ether from the dichi orohydrin solution by the use of carbon tetrachloride as a solvent. In this way the by-products are removed from the aqueous phase iato an organic phase from which they can be separated by distillation and disposed of ia a safe and proper manner. 

Whereas process simulation includes quantitative analysis of a design given the stmcture of the design, process synthesis involves determining the stmcture that will meet the requirements of the design as well as finding the best stmcture for the requirements. For example, if components A, B, C, and D whose relative volatOities were in the order D, C, B, and A were to be separated by distillation for which each column produced a top and a bottom fraction, five schemes of three columns arise as possible stmctures (53) (Fig. 8). 

---