Sabatier reaction

Platinum and palladium are expensive metals, so the accidental finding by Paul Sabatier 1854-1941) that nickel, a much cheaper metal, can catalyze hydrogenation reactions made hydrogenation a feasible large-scale industrial process. The conversion of plant oils to margarine is one such hydrogenation reaction. Sabatier was born in France and was a professor at the University of Toulouse. He shared the 1912 Nobel Prize in chemistry with Victor Grignard (p. 468). 

Hydrogenation of the oxides of carbon to methane according to the above reactions is sometimes referred to as the Sabatier reactions. Because of the high exothermicity of the methanization reactions, adequate and precise cooling is necessary in order to avoid catalyst deactivation, sintering, and carbon deposition by thermal cracking. 

In the Sabatier reaction, methane and water are formed over a nickel— nickel oxide catalyst at 250°C. The methane is recovered and cracked to carbon and hydrogen, which is then recycled ... 

Methanation. Since 1902, when Sabatier discovered that carbon monoxide could be hydrogenated to methane [74-82-8] the methanation reaction (eq. 12) has been the subject of intense investigation (47,48) (see Hydrocarbons, C —C ). 

The first catalytic study of Reaction 1 was published in 1902 by Sabatier and Senderens (1) who reported that nickel was an excellent catalyst. Since that time, the active catalysts were identified as the transition elements with unfilled 3d, 4d, and 5d orbitals iron, cobalt, nickel, ruthenium, rhenium, palladium, osmium, indium, and platinum, as well as some elements that can assume these configurations (e.g., silver). These are discussed later. For practical operation of this process,... 

K.17 The Sabatier process has been used to remove CO> from artificial atmospheres, such as those in submarines and spacecraft. An advantage is that it produces methane, CH4, which can be burned as a fuel, and water, which can be reused. Balance the equation for the process and identify the type of reaction CC2(g) + H2(g) -+ CH4(g) + H20(1). 

A catalytic reaction is composed of several reaction steps. Molecules have to adsorb to the catalyst and become activated, and product molecules have to desorb. The catalytic reaction is a reaction cycle of elementary reaction steps. The catalytic center is regenerated after reaction. This is the basis of the key molecular principle of catalysis the Sabatier principle. According to this principle, the rate of a catalytic reaction has a maximum when the rate of activation and the rate of product desorption balance. 

The Sabatier principle deals with the relation between catalytic reaction rate and adsorption energies of surface reaction intermediates. A very useful relation often... 

For catalytic reactions and systems that are related through Sabatier-type relations based on kinetic relationships as expressed by Eqs. (1.5) and (1.6), one can also deduce that a so-called compensation effect exists. According to the compensation effect there is a linear relation between the change in the apparent activation energy of a reaction and the logarithm of its corresponding pre-exponent in the Arrhenius reaction rate expression. 

The occurrence of a compensation effect can be readily deduced from Eqs. (1.6) and (1.7). The physical basis of the compensation effect is similar to that of the Sabatier volcano curve. When reaction conditions or catalytic reactivity of a surface changes, the surface coverage of the catalyst is modified. This change in surface coverage changes the rate through change in the reaction order of a reaction. 

Hence, we intuitively feel that the successful combination of catalyst and reaction is that in which the interaction between catalyst and reacting species is not too weak, but also not too strong. This is a loosely formulated version of Sabatier s Principle, which we encounter in a more precise form in Chapter 2 and in detail in Section 6.5.3.5. 

The results of the previous sections show that catalytic reactions proceed best if the interaction between the adsorbates and the surface is not too strong and not too weak. Sabatier realized that there must be an optimum of the rate of a catalytic reaction as a function of the heat of adsorption. If the adsorption is too weak the catalyst has little effect, and will, for example, be unable to dissociate a bond. If the interaction is too strong, the adsorbates will be unable to desorb from the surface. Both extremes result in small rates of reaction. 

Identification of such universal relations between activation energies and heats of adsorption for particular classes of reaction can be seen as a more precise and more quantitative formulation of Sabatier s Principle. It is promising tool in the search for new materials on the basis of optimized interaction strength between relevant intermediates and the surface. 

Much of the pioneering work which led to the discovery of efficient catalysts for modern Industrial catalytic processes was performed at a time when advanced analytical Instrumentation was not available. Insights Into catalytic phenomena were achieved through gas adsorption, molecular reaction probes, and macroscopic kinetic measurements. Although Sabatier postulated the existence of unstable reaction Intermediates at the turn of this century. It was not until the 1950 s that such species were actually observed on solid surfaces by Elschens and co-workers (2.) using Infrared spectroscopy. Today, scientists have the luxury of using a multitude of sophisticated surface analytical techniques to study catalytic phenomena on a molecular level. Nevertheless, kinetic measurements using chemically specific probe molecules are still the... 

Ammonia has always been the starting material for the synthesis of aliphatic amines. Thus, processes have been developed for the condensation of NH3 with alkyl halides (Hoffman reaction) or with alcohols in the presence of various catalysts. The latter reachon, first discovered by Sabatier in 1909 [8, 9] is nowadays the main method of industrial production of light amines (e.g. methylamines 600 000 t/yr) [5]. 

Vijh (6) has suggested more recently that if one assumes the adsorbed species formed in this reaction to be a covalent one, the available data can be interpreted in terms of the Sabatier-Balandin views on heterogeneous catalysis. According to his interpretation, he has indicated a volcanic relationship between the catalytic activity (defind as the temperature at which the reaction first becomes appreciable) against the heat of formation per equivalent of the oxide catalyst, AHe. Based on this volcanic relationship, he has concluded that the rate-determining step (r.d.s.) of the reaction on the oxide catalysts such as CiO, NiO and CoO probably involves rupture of a M-0 bond. On the other hand, r.d.s. on oxides such as MgO,CaO and Ce02 would involve the formation of a M-0 bond. 

Sabatier and Balandin had predicted a relationship between catal)dic activity and heat of adsorption. If a solid adsorbs the reactants only weakly, it will be a poor catalyst, but if it holds reactants, intermediates or products too strongly, it wiU again perform poorly. The ideal catalyst for a given reaction was predicted to be a compromise between too weak and too strong chemisorption. Balandin transformed this concept to a semiquantitative theory by predicting that a plot of the reaction rate of a catal)Tic reaction as a function of the heat of adsorption of the reactant should have a sharp maximum. He called these plots volcano-shaped curvesl This prediction was confirmed by Fahrenfort et al." An example of their volcano-shaped curve is reproduced in Fig. 9.1. They chose the catalytic decomposition of formic acid... 

The curve is a graphical representation of the Sabatier principle according to which the best catalysts are those adsorbing relevant species neither too weakly nor too strongly. Volcano curves are known also for catalytic reactions (on the other hand the principles are precisely the same), the only difference being that they are called Balandin curves. 

The reactions studied were the catalytic formation of methane from carbon monoxide and hydrogen (according to Sabatier (34), normal pressure), the catalytic hydrogenation of unsaturated hydrocarbons and also of unsaturated fatty acids ( fat hardening according to Normann (35)). Here again, a certain analogy was established between... 

Grignard, Victor (1871—1935). French chemist, receipient (with Paul Sabatier) of Nobel Prize in chemistry (1912). Discovered organo-maguesium compds used for organic synthesis (See Griguard s Reaction and Reagent)... 

A heterogeneously catalysed reaction involves several steps (Mady et al, 1976) (i) mass transport of fluid reactants to the surface, (ii) chemisorption of reactants on the surface, (iii) diffusion and chemical reaction at the surface and (iv) desorption and diffusion of products from the surface. Step (iii), involving the formation of surface intermediates, is the key step. Formation of surface intermediates, which ultimately give rise to products, was first proposed by Sabatier (see Burwell, 1973) and strikingly demonstrated by Sachtler Fahrenfort (1960) in the decomposition of formic acid... 

Methane is the principal gas found with coal and oil deposits and is a major fuel and chemical used is the petrochemical industry. Slightly less than 20% of the worlds energy needs are supplied by natural gas. The United States get about 30% of its energy needs from natural gas. Methane can be synthesized industrially through several processes such as the Sabatier method, Fischer Tropsch process, and steam reforming. The Sabatier process, named for Frenchman Paul Sabatier (1854—1941), the 1912 Nobel Prize winner in chemistry from France, involves the reaction of carbon dioxide and hydrogen with a nickel or ruthenium metal catalyst C02 + 4H2 —> CH4 + 2H20. 

A simple tool is described, which provides a conceptual framework for analyzing microkinetic models of heterogeneous reactions. We refer to this tool as the Sabatier Analysis . The Sabatier Analysis of the microkinetic models developed in this section suggests that the clustering of good catalysts can be explained by the combination of the universal BEP-relation and activated re-adsorption of synthesis products onto the catalyst. 

Here max Rt is the maximal rate of reaction step i, which is calculated by assuming optimal coverages for that reaction step. This (usually multi-dimensional) volcano-curve we shall refer to as the Sabatier volcano-curve, as it is intimately linked to the original Sabatier principle [132,133]. This principle states that desorption from a reactive metal catalyst is slow and will increase on less reactive metals. On very noble metals the large energy barrier for dissociation will, however decrease the dissociation rate. The best catalyst must be a compromise between the two extremes. As has been shown above, this does not necessarily mean that the optimal compromise is obtained exactly where the maximal desorption and dissociation rates are competing. That is only the case far from equilibrium. Close to equilibrium the maximum will often be attained while dissociation is the rate-determining step, and the maximum of the volcano-curve will then be reached due to a lack of free sites to dissociate into. 

We will refer to the method of using the maximal possible reaction rates for all the reaction steps of a heterogeneously catalyzed reaction as Sabatier Analysis . This analytical method might prove useful for various purposes in the future. Here its... 

---