Predictive catalysis

Heilman A, et al. Predicting catalysis understanding ammonia synthesis from first-principles calculations. J Phys Chem B. 2006 110(36) 17719—35. 

In this chapter, we discnss approaches aimed at the manipnlation of active sites to affect the ontcome of a catalytic process. Special attention will be given to scientific advances that have allowed us to begin to develop systematic strategies toward predictive catalysis. These approaches focns on bnilding a snfficient nnder-standing of the elementary step based mechanisms of catalytic processes, and the utilization of these molecnlar insights in the rational manipnlation of the active sites to achieve the desired activity, selectivity, or stability. 

An important lesson to be learned from this exposition is that chemocatalytic systems adapt their state to the reaction mixture composition or rather the chemical potential of the gas phase to which they are exposed. To predict catalysis properly one therefore has also to be able to predict the state of the catalyst surface during reaction. 

Small metal clusters are also of interest because of their importance in catalysis. Despite the fact that small clusters should consist of mostly surface atoms, measurement of the photon ionization threshold for Hg clusters suggest that a transition from van der Waals to metallic properties occurs in the range of 20-70 atoms per cluster [88] and near-bulk magnetic properties are expected for Ni, Pd, and Pt clusters of only 13 atoms [89] Theoretical calculations on Sin and other semiconductors predict that the stmcture reflects the bulk lattice for 1000 atoms but the bulk electronic wave functions are not obtained [90]. Bartell and co-workers [91] study beams of molecular clusters with electron dirfraction and molecular dynamics simulations and find new phases not observed in the bulk. Bulk models appear to be valid for their clusters of several thousand atoms (see Section IX-3). 

The first successhil use of lithium metal for the preparation of a i7j -l,4-polyisoprene was aimounced in 1955 (50) however, lithium metal catalysis was quickly phased out in favor of hydrocarbon soluble organ olithium compounds. These initiators provide a homogeneous system with predictable results. Organ olithium initiators are used commercially in the production of i7j -l,4-polyisoprene, isoprene block polymers, and several other polymers. 

It is apparent that the use of enzymatic catalysis continues to grow Greater availabiUty of enzymes, development of new methodologies for thek utilization, investigation of enzymatic behavior in nonconventional environments, and the design and synthesis of new biocatalysts with altered selectivity and increased stabiUty are essential for the successhil development of this field. As more is learned about selectivity of enzymes toward unnatural substrates, the choice of an enzyme for a particular transformation will become easier to predict. It should simplify a search for an appropriate catalyst and help to estabhsh biocatalytic procedures as a usehil supplement to classical organic synthesis. 

The application of metallocene catalysis to the preparation of polypropylenes reached a commercial stage with the production by Exxon of their Achieve range in 1996 and in 1997 by Targor, the BASF-Hoechst joint venture with the introduction of Metocene. Such metallocene polypropylenes are, however, only a small proportion of the total polypropylene market, predicted at only about 3% of the total in 2005. 

Clearly, proximity and orientation play a role in enzyme catalysis, but there is a problem with each of the above comparisons. In both cases, it is impossible to separate true proximity and orientation effects from the effects of entropy loss when molecules are brought together (described the Section 16.4). The actual rate accelerations afforded by proximity and orientation effects in Figures 16.14 and 16.15, respectively, are much smaller than the values given in these figures. Simple theories based on probability and nearest-neighbor models, for example, predict that proximity effects may actually provide rate increases of only 5- to 10-fold. For any real case of enzymatic catalysis, it is nonetheless important to remember that proximity and orientation effects are significant. 

Honk et al. concluded that this FMO model imply increased asynchronicity in the bond-making processes, and if first-order effects (electrostatic interactions) were also considered, a two-step mechanisms, with cationic intermediates become possible in some cases. It was stated that the model proposed here shows that the phenomena generally observed on catalysis can be explained by the concerted mechanism, and allows predictions of the effect of Lewis acid on the rates, regioselectivity, and stereoselectivity of all concerted cycloadditions, including those of ketenes, 1,3-dipoles, and Diels-Alder reactions with inverse electron-demand [2],... 

When the molecular weight of PS was decreased from 5.0 x 10 to (3.0-4.05) x 10, the abovementioned properties were also decreased in the presence of cationic catalysis after the destruction of PS. These predicted properties are related to the nature and the quantity of functional groups. 

The performance of VASP for alloys and compounds has been illustrated at three examples The calculation of the properties of cobalt dislicide demonstrates that even for a transition-metal compound perfect agreement with all-electron calculations may be achieved at much lower computational effort, and that elastic and dynamic properties may be predicted accurately even for metallic systems with rather long-range interactions. Applications to surface-problems have been described at the example of the. 3C-SiC(100) surface. Surface physics and catalysis will be a. particularly important field for the application of VASP, recent work extends to processes as complex as the adsorption of thiopene molecules on the surface of transition-metal sulfides[55]. Finally, the efficiciency of VASP for studying complex melts has been illustrate for crystalline and molten Zintl-phases of alkali-group V alloys. 

The applications of quantitative structure-reactivity analysis to cyclodextrin com-plexation and cyclodextrin catalysis, mostly from our laboratories, as well as the experimental and theoretical backgrounds of these approaches, are reviewed. These approaches enable us to separate several intermolecular interactions, acting simultaneously, from one another in terms of physicochemical parameters, to evaluate the extent to which each interaction contributes, and to predict thermodynamic stabilities and/or kinetic rate constants experimentally undetermined. Conclusions obtained are mostly consistent with those deduced from experimental measurements. 

The past fifteen years have seen evidence of great interest in homogeneous catalysis, particularly by transition metal complexes in solution predictions were made that many heterogeneous processes would be replaced by more efficient homogeneous ones. There are two motives in these changes—first, intellectual curiosity and the belief that we can define the active center with... 

I. Metcalfe, Electrochemical Promotion of Catalysis II The role of stable spillover species and prediction of reaction rate modification,/. Catal. 199, 259-272 (2001). 

Specific base catalysis is predicted if the extent of substrate ionization is reduced from almost complete. Depends on whether an ion pair assists in removal of leaving group. 

All these steps can influence the overall reaction rate. The reactor models of Chapter 9 are used to predict the bulk, gas-phase concentrations of reactants and products at point (r, z) in the reactor. They directly model only Steps 1 and 9, and the effects of Steps 2 through 8 are lumped into the pseudohomoge-neous rate expression, a, b,. ..), where a,b,. .. are the bulk, gas-phase concentrations. The overall reaction mechanism is complex, and the rate expression is necessarily empirical. Heterogeneous catalysis remains an experimental science. The techniques of this chapter are useful to interpret experimental results. Their predictive value is limited. 

Whether butadiene reacts with itself to give linear polymers or 8- or 12-carbon rings is a function of the catalyst and conditions used. Development of catalysts needed to give the desired products is the job of catalyst research chemists. Although catalysis is critically important in the chemical industry and much work has been done on it in research laboratories for many years, catalyst development remains more of an art than a predictable science, and the chemists involved in this type of research use methods they have learned experimentally, not from books or in classrooms. 

The pre.sent account follows a Journey in this arena from solution calorimetric studies dealing with nucleophilic carbene ligands in an organometallic system to the use of these thermodynamic data in predicting the feasibility of exchange reactions to applications in homogeneous catalysis. 

Derive the predicted rate law for the general mechanism for enzyme catalysis, assuming that the distortion... 

---