Oxygen controversy

T[[dotb]he nature of the initial attack by the water (eq. 10) is a matter of some controversy (205,206). Stereochemical and kinetic studies of model systems have been reported that support trans addition of external water (207,208) or internal addition of cis-coordinated water (209), depending on the particular model system under study. Other paHadium-cataly2ed oxidations of olefins ia various oxygen donor solvents produce a variety of products including aldehydes (qv), ketones (qv), vinyl acetate, acetals, and vinyl ethers (204). However the product mixtures are complex and very sensitive to conditions. 

Crystalline Silica. Sihca exists in a variety of polymorphic crystalline forms (23,41—43), in amorphous modifications, and as a Hquid. The Hterature on crystalline modifications is to some degree controversial. According to the conventional view of the polymorphism of siHca, there are three main forms at atmospheric pressure quart2, stable below about 870°C tridymite, stable from about 870—1470°C and cristobaHte, stable from about 1470°C to the melting point at about 1723°C. In all of these forms, the stmctures are based on SiO tetrahedra linked in such a way that every oxygen atom is shared between two siHcon atoms. The stmctures, however, are quite different in detail. In addition, there are other forms of siHca that are not stable at atmospheric pressure, including that of stishovite, in which the coordination number of siHcon is six rather than four. 

Cramer, W. A., et al., 1996. Some new structural aspects and old controversies concerning die cytochrome b /complex of oxygenic photosyndie-... 

The Phillips Cr/silica catalyst is prepared by impregnating a chromium compound (commonly chromic acid) onto a support material, most commonly a wide-pore silica, and then calcining in oxygen at 923 K. In the industrial process, the formation of the propagation centers takes place by reductive interaction of Cr(VI) with the monomer (ethylene) at about 423 K [4]. This feature makes the Phillips catalyst unique among all the olefin polymerization catalysts, but also the most controversial one [17]. 

There is significant controversy over the role of loop diuretics in the treatment of ARE Theoretical benefits in hastening recovery of renal function include decreased metabolic oxygen requirements of the kidney, increased resistance to ischemia, increased urine flow rates that reduce intraluminal obstruction and filtrate backleak, and renal vasodilation.6 Theoretically, these effects could lead to increased urine output, decreased need for dialysis, improved renal recovery, and ultimately, increased survival. However, there are conflicting... 

There is no proven antidote for hydrogen sulfide poisoning. Treatment consists of supportive measures such as evaluating and supporting airway, breathing, and circulation (ATSDR 1994). Sodium nitrite may or may not be an effective antidote, but if proper precautions in administration are observed, intravenous administration of sodium nitrite may help some hydrogen sulfide poisoned persons (Hall 1996 Hall and Rumack 1997). Hyperbaric oxygen therapy is controversial, but it may be effective for patients not treated successfully by other measures (ATSDR 1994). 

In 1775 Lavoisier discovered oxygen and the relation between air and life. This renewed the controversy about spontaneous generation, the objection to Spallanzani s results being that it was the exclusion of air (oxygen) from the flasks which prevented the development of life. 

Hydrocarbon formation involves the removal of one carbon from an acyl-CoA to produce a one carbon shorter hydrocarbon. The mechanism behind this transformation is controversial. It has been suggested that it is either a decarbonylation or a decarboxylation reaction. The decarbonylation reaction involves reduction to an aldehyde intermediate and then decarbonylation to the hydrocarbon and releasing carbon monoxide without the requirement of oxygen or other cofactors [88,89]. In contrast, other work has shown that acyl-CoA is reduced to an aldehyde intermediate and then decarboxylated to the hydrocarbon, releasing carbon dioxide [90]. This reaction requires oxygen and NADPH and is apparently catalyzed by a cytochrome P450 [91]. Whether or not a decarbonylation reaction or a decarboxylation reaction produces hydrocarbons in insects awaits further research on the specific enzymes involved. 

The electrodes in the direct methanol fuel cell (DMFC) (i.e. the anode for oxidising the fuel and the cathode for the reduction of oxygen) are based on finely divided Pt dispersed onto a porous carbon support, and the electro-oxidation of methanol at a polycrystalline Pt electrode as a model for the DMFC has been the subject of numerous electrochemical studies dating back to the early years ot the 20th century. In this particular section, the discussion is restricted to the identity of the species that result from the chemisorption of methanol at Pt in acid electrolyte. This is principally because (i) the identity of the catalytic poison formed during the chemisorption of methanol has been a source of controversy for many years, and (ii) the advent of in situ IR culminated in this controversy being resolved. 

Controversial results of oxygen radical detection in mitochondria have been described in the literature. Owing to experimental difficulties many authors were obliged to work with sub-mitochondrial particles instead of the whole mitochondria. However, it is quite possible that oxygen radical production by submitochondrial particles may be artificially enhanced due to exposure to oxygen. On the other hand, some analytical methods of superoxide detection such as cytochrome c reduction cannot be used due to the direct reduction of cytochrome by mitochondrial components. 

Redox reactions involving nitric oxide have important implications beyond their fundamental chemistry as demonstrated by the controversy in the biomedical literature regarding conditions under which generation of NO leads to the amelioration or the exacerbation of oxidative stress in mammalian systems (95). Oxidative stress is defined as a disturbance in the balance between production of reactive oxygen species (pro-oxidants) and antioxidant defenses (96). Reactive oxygen species include free radicals and peroxides as well as other reactants such as oxidative enzymes with metal ion sites in high oxidation states. The... 

---