Orbits reality

By expressing the mean-field interaction of an electron at r with the N- 1 other electrons in temis of a probability density pyy r ) that is independent of the fact that another electron resides at r, the mean-field models ignore spatial correlations among the electrons. In reality, as shown in figure B3.T5 the conditional probability density for finding one ofA - 1 electrons at r, given that one electron is at r depends on r. The absence of a spatial correlation is a direct consequence of the spin-orbital product nature of the mean-field wavefiinctions... 

In studying molecular orbital theory, it is difficult to avoid the question of how real orbitals are. Are they mere mathematical abstractions The question of reality in quantum mechanics has a long and contentious history that we shall not pretend to settle here but Koopmans s theorem and photoelectron spectra must certainly be taken into account by anyone who does. 

We can consider the hydroboration step as though it involved borane (BH3) It sim phfies our mechanistic analysis and is at variance with reality only m matters of detail Borane is electrophilic it has a vacant 2p orbital and can accept a pair of electrons into that orbital The source of this electron pair is the rr bond of an alkene It is believed as shown m Figure 6 10 for the example of the hydroboration of 1 methylcyclopentene that the first step produces an unstable intermediate called a tt complex In this rr com plex boron and the two carbon atoms of the double bond are joined by a three center two electron bond by which we mean that three atoms share two electrons Three center two electron bonds are frequently encountered m boron chemistry The tt complex is formed by a transfer of electron density from the tt orbital of the alkene to the 2p orbital... 

While orbitals may be useful for qualitative understanding of some molecules, it is important to remember that they are merely mathematical functions that represent solutions to the Hartree-Fock equations for a given molecule. Other orbitals exist which will produce the same energy and properties and which may look quite different. There is ultimately no physical reality which can be associated with these images. In short, individual orbitals are mathematical not physical constructs. 

Reality Check To construct an orbital diagram, start with the electron configuration and apply Hund s rule. 

Meanwhile orbitals cannot be observed either directly, indirectly since they have no physical reality contrary to the recent claims in Nature magazine and other journals to the effect that some d orbitals in copper oxide had been directly imaged (Scerri, 2000). Orbitals as used in ab initio calculations are mathematical figments that exist, if anything, in a multi-dimensional Hilbert space.19 Electron density is altogether different since it is a well-defined observable and exists in real three-dimensional space, a feature which some theorists point to as a virtue of density functional methods. 

The kinetic energy in the Hartree-Fock scheme is evidently too low, owing to the fact that we have assumed the existence of a simplified uncorrelated motion, whereas the particles in reality have much more complicated movements because of their tendency to avoid each other. The potential energy, on the other hand, comes out much too high in the HF scheme essentially due to the fact that we have compelled a pair of electrons with opposite spins together in the same orbital in space. 

Caulton and Fenske began with a molecular orbital diagram for CO (see Fig. 1). The two orbitals of interest here are, of course, the Scr- and 277-orbitals. The Sa-orbital, assumed in valence-bond theory to be a carbon orbital, has in reality a small contribution from oxygen also (Sa = 0.664 2s + 0.059 2s — 0.664 2p — 0.364 2p ). One can see from the choice of... 

Figure 6.6. Energy levels of the frontier orbitals of selected molecules. In reality is this picture too simple. Due to interaction with the 2s orbitals the 5cr levels lie above the lit level, but this does not change the overall stability of the molecules.

Each energy level in the band is called a state. The important quantity to look at is the density of states (DOS), i.e. the number of states at a given energy. The DOS of transition metals are often depicted as smooth curves (Fig. 6.10), but in reality DOS curves show complicated structure, due to crystal structure and symmetry. The bands are filled with valence electrons of the atoms up to the Fermi level. In a molecule one would call this level the highest occupied molecular orbital or HOMO. 

The description derived above gives useful insight into the general characteristics of the band structure in solids. In reality, band structure is far more complex than suggested by Fig. 6.16, as a result of the inclusion of three dimensions, and due to the presence of many types of orbitals that form bands. The detailed electronic structure determines the physical and chemical properties of the solids, in particular whether a solid is a conductor, semiconductor, or insulator (Fig. 6.17). 

We conclude, therefore, that the momentum of the electron in its orbit within the atom does not affect the direction of ejection in the way demanded by the theory of Auger and Perrin. While this does not constitute definite evidence against the physical reality of electronic orbits, it is a serious difficulty for the conception. 

Strictly speaking, an orbital is not a physical reality but refers to a particular solution of complicated wave equations associated with the theoretical description of atoms and they are referred to by the initial letter of the terms describing the spectral lines sharp, principal, diffuse and fundamental. 

A second mechanism (the polarization mechanism) arises due to the polarization of the fully occupied (bonding) crystal orbitals formed by the eg. oxygen 2p. and Li 2s atomic orbitals in the presence of a magnetic field. A fully occupied crystal (or molecular) orbital in reality comprises one one-electron orbital occupied by a spin-up electron and a second one-... 

Figure 9 indicates that chemical substitutions which oxidize Mn stabilize the layered structure against transformation only up to a point. At valences higher than +4, i.e., tetrahedral Mn orbital fillings less than d, the trend abruptly shifts (Figure 9). Although in reality such valences are rare for Mn in ccp oxides, Mn is predicted to become less stable in the layered octahedral sites with valences increasing above +4.

The diagram above shows the electronic configuration for carbon in orbital box notation. The two electrons in the p subshell are in different orbitals, but have parallel spins, and the electrons sharing the same orbitals in the Is and 2s subshells have opposite spins. The diagram also suggests that one of the 2p orbitals is empty. In reality, there is no such thing as an empty orbital. If an orbital is empty, then it does not exist. However, it is acceptable to show empty orbitals in this type of notation. 

Figure 1. Symmetry-unique SC orbitals for the gas-phase Diels-Alder reaction along the CASSCF(6,6) IRC at IRC = -0.6 amu bohr (leftmost column), TS (IRC = 0) and IRC +0.6 amu bohr (rightmost column). Three-dimensional isovalue surfaces, corresponding to / = 0.08, were drawn from virtual reality modelling language (VRML) files produced by MOLDEN [31J.

In short, the core-valence partitioning in real space offers the great advantage of being naturally best suited in problems concerned with real-space atom-by-atom decompositions of molecules. Yet, although serving different purposes, and however different they may seem, real-space and orbital-space core-valence separations appear for what they are two facets of the same reality. The route to this result was not overly exciting, I am afraid, but the final result certainly justifies our patience. 

The determination of molecular orbitals in terms of symmetry-adapted linear combinations of atomic orbitals is analogous to the determination of normal vibrational modes by forming symmetry-adapted linear combinations of displacements. Both calculations are in reality the reduction of a representa-... 

The dependence of Tc on pressure is studied for a variety of reasons. In a chemical sense, bond lengths are shortened, and orbital interactions are increased. The volume decrease leads in principle to a rise in carrier density. In reality, however, not only do vibrational frequencies change, but crystal structure and symmetry are often affected by high pressure. Numerous materials undergo semiconductor to metal phase transitions as a function of pressure. Increasing pressure can often be considered analogous to a decrease in temperature. 

There is a convenient mathematical idealization which asserts that a cube of edge length, / cm, possesses a surface area of 6 f cm and that a sphere of radius r cm exhibits 4nr cm of surface. In reality, however, mathematical, perfect or ideal geometric forms are unattainable since under microscopic examinations all real surfaces exhibit flaws. For example, if a super microscope were available one would observe surface roughness due not only to the atomic or molecular orbitals at the surface but also due to voids, steps, pores and other surface imperfections. These surface imperfections will always create real surface area greater than the corresponding geometric area. 

These various relationships between force and particle separation imply that the attractive force between particles will become infinite when they touch. In reality, other short-range forces will modify this relationship when r is very small, in particular the repulsion from overlap of atomic orbitals. The van der Waals attraction will then be balanced by this overlap repulsion. At these short distances (a few tenths of a nanometer), the van der Waals attraction will be strong enough to hold the particles fairly strongly together. This balance between van der Waals forces of attraction and overlap repulsion forces is shown schematically in Fig. 1.4, where the very steep repulsive interaction at atomic distances is due to the overlap repulsion. Hydration forces (see section 1.3.3) may also result in repulsion between surfaces at somewhat greater separations. 

---