Objections to selection

As already mentioned in Chapter 1, the eompositional changes, the major shifts, that took place between cold- and warm-blooded vertebrates, and the maintenance of the compositional patterns so formed cannot be accounted for by any explanation only or essentially relying on stochastic processes. This led us (Bernard and Bernard , 1986a) to propose a natural selection mechanism acting on the genome phenotype. 

The reason why the natural selection hypothesis met with a strong opposition was, however, its apparent questioning of the neutral theory. We have now explained again (see Chapters 1-3) that, while our findings cannot be accounted for by that theory, they are compatible with it. A positive result of the objections and alternative explanations published during the past sixteen years is that our proposal underwent an unusual degree of scrutiny, and that the rebuttal of the objections (and the failure of alternative explanations) reinforced our original explanation. In some cases, an analysis of the objections provided further support for the hypothesis (see [vii] below for an example). 

In this chapter, we will consider the objections to selection, that were not accompanied by alternative explanations, whereas the following chapter will address the alternative explanations that were proposed. We will begin with the most popular, yet logically weakest, objection to the thermodynamic stability hypothesis. 

To sum up, the results of Galtier and Lobry (1997) have no bearing on our conclusions concerning vertebrates. In fact, they do not even shed light on the problem of the correlation between growth temperature and GC levels of protein-coding sequences in the case of Eubacteria and Archaea (see note added in proof at the end of this chapter). 

Even if the observations of Hughes et al. (1999) were correct, they would only confirm the existence of a limited formation of GC-rich isochores in crocodile and turtle, a point previously shown by Aissani and Bernard (1991a,b), but not mentioned by Hughes et al. (1999). However, both the DNA properties (asymmetry, heterogeneity of DNA profiles see Part 4) and the absence of CpG islands in the two species under consideration (see Part 5) make them quite different from bona fide warm-blooded vertebrates, as well as from reptiles showing a very low asymmetry and heterogeneity of DNA profiles. 

---

The examples of inappropriate methods given, were found as a result of personal experience Seven years ago (1984) I surveyed the recent literature on new synthetic methods with the objectives to select good candidates for experimental testing in an advanced course on "Preparative organic chemistry" for graduate students. I scrutinized more than 2000 recent papers, some of them published in "prestige" journals. Of these papers, only four (4) presented new methods which had been adequately optimized. 

From standpoint of aims of the technical diagnostics (TD) it is necessary to select two probable states of the NDT objects (NDTO). The first, when defect in the material already has been formed might characterize as defective state of material (DSM). And second - when defect is not yet formed, but exist so changes in the spatial (volume) distribution (SD) of the physical-mechanical features (PMF) of the material, of its tense-deformed state (TDS), which under certain conditions will initiate defect origination. This is predefective state of material (PDSM). 

The procedure of testing must include measurements which have to provide reliable information about the quality of the object to be tested. The list of characteristics of measurement errors is selected on the basis of the required end results, methods of its calculation, form of presentation of the accuracy factors, reliability of the end result. These factors are of utmost attention in attestation of the procedure of testing. 

Commercial flavor enhancers for pet foods have become big business. Flavor enhancers, primarily so-called digests, provide high acceptance of pet foods and enable the pet to select one food over another. Commercial companies compete with flavors based on the types that pets like. However, owner objections minimize the use of some acceptabiUty enhancers such as some fish products, onions, and gadic. 

The objective in selecting a support for a catalytic appHcation is to provide a suitable, stable base for the active catalytic component. The support should be chemically inert so that it does not interfere with the role of the catalytic component, and it should possess acceptable physical properties for the intended apphcation. The support should retain its dimensions and chemical integrity under the conditions necessary to operate the catalytic process. 

Tests on plant-scale dryers are usually carried out to obtain design data for a specific material, to select a suitable diyer type, or to check present performance of an existing diyer with the objective of determining its capacity potential. In these tests overall performance data are obtained and the results used to make heat and material balances and to estimate overall drying rates or heat-transfer coefficients. 

QRA practitioners can use to satisfy some QRA objectives. Also, the American Institute of Chemical Engineers (AIChE) has sponsored a project to expand and improve the quality of component failure data for chemical industry use. And many process facilities have considerable equipment operating experience in maintenance files, operating logs, and the minds of operators and maintenance personnel. These data can be collected and combined with industrywide data to help achieve reasonable QRA objectives. However, care must be exercised to select data most representative of your specific system from the wide range available from various sources. Even data from your own plant may have to be modified (sometimes by a factor of 10 or more) to reflect your plant s current operating environment and maintenance practices. 

A variety of containment strategies employ floating solid objects to control the rate of gaseous emissions from surface impoundments. These include synthetic membrane covers, rafts, and hollow plastic spheres. Synthetic membrane covers are feasible where the out-gassing of volatiles due to biological activity is not expected. Selection of the liner material must be... 

When the objective of water treatment is to provide drinking water, then we need to select technologies that are not only the best available, but those that will meet local and national quality standards. The primary goals of a water treatment plant... 

The crucial objective is to identify what effects can be produced by exposure to chemical agents and to select which effects should be considered... 

The fundamental objective in this section is to describe the factors and procedures to select the right material for a specific structural application. The right stuff for a material, as for a fighter pilot or an astronaut, is a complex combination of characteristics. To select the proper material requires being able to characterize and evaluate various composite materials (or metalsl) and to compare their attractive characteristics with the behavioral features required for a particular structure. Finally, a materials selection example of a space truss design problem will be addressed. 

Show how. by suitable selection of the index n, the power law may be used to describe the behaviour of both shear-thinning and shear-thickening non-Newtonian fluids over a limited range of shear rates. What are the main objections to the use of the power law Give some examples of different types of shear-thinning fluids. 

A smaller number of individuals, 132 samples, was analyzed for stable isotopes of nitrogen. There were two objectives to the nitrogen isotope analysis 1) to determine the amount of animal protein in the diet and to look for variation between the sexes and 2) to determine when infants were weaned from the breast. These objectives were addressed by selecting at least ten individuals, when available, from a number of age classes. Figure 1.1 illustrates the age distribution of the sample. Table 1.3 shows the results of these analyses. Individual 5 N values are provided in Herring et al. (1998). 

The cycle time for the sequence, tc..K.uJS, should be minimized to find the optimal sequence of batches for the UIS policy. The form of the objective function implies that the optimization of a schedule for UIS with minimum cycle time simply reduces to selecting any sequence of batches with slack times of bottleneck stage(s) set to zero. 

The task now is to select the linear combinations that will most probably correspond to independent parts of the reaction network with easily interpretable stoichiometry. A simplification of the data in the matrix can be achieved by such a rotation that the axes go through the points in Fig. A-2 (this is equivalent to some zero-stoichiometric coefficients) and that the points of Fig. A-3 are in the first quadrant (this corresponds to positive reaction extents) if possible. Rotations of the abscissa through 220° and the ordinate through 240° lead to attaining both objectives. The associated rotation matrix is ... 

In a more sophisticated version of this technique, called the k-nearest neighbour method (k-NN method), one selects the k nearest objects to u and applies a majority rule u is classified in the group to which the majority of the k objects belong. Figure 33.12 gives an example of a 3-NN method. One selects the three nearest neighbours (A, B and C) to the unknown u. Since A and B belong to L, one... 

It can be shown that this can be generalized to the case of more than two variables. The standard solution of a linear programming problem is then to define the comer points of the convex set and to select the one that yields the best value for the objective function. This is called the Simplex method. 

The life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) is used to assess the results of the LCA and evaluate the impact on the environment in the various impact categories. These impact categories include, for example, human health, GWP, energy, water use, eutrophication, ozone depletion, aquatic toxicity, and land use (ISO, 2006b). LCA may focus on one or more impact categories. The results may be normalized, weighted, and aggregated in optional steps of the LCIA for comparison to political objectives, for example. In addition, sensitivity analyses are often conducted over the entire LCA to evaluate the variation in the results due to selected factors. 

The objective in selecting the reaction conditions for a preparative nucleophilic substitution is to enhance the mutual reactivity of the leaving group and nucleophile so that the desired substitution occurs at a convenient rate and with minimal competition from other possible reactions. The generalized order of leaving-group reactivity RSOj" I- > BF > CF pertains for most Sw2 processes. (See Section 4.2.3 of Part A for more complete data.) Mesylates, tosylates, iodides, and bromides are all widely used in synthesis. Chlorides usually react rather slowly, except in especially reactive systems, such as allyl and benzyl. 

---