Alternate explanations

The combined result of two such determinations yielded a leak size figure of 8.8% of the feed flow (with a relative standard deviation of less than 5%). This figure could sufficiently explain the product quality problems experienced, whose alternative explanation in turn was catalyst poisoning. 

An alternative explanation that has been advanced is that at the lower temperatures... 

While pressure melting may be important for snow and ice near 0°C, it is possible that even here an alternative explanation will prove important. Ice is a substance of unusual structural complexity, and it has been speculated that a liquidlike surface layer is present near the melting point [17,18] if this is correct, the low /t values observed at low sliding speeds near 0°C may be due to a peculiarity of the surface nature of ice rather than to pressure melting. 

This olionge involves the oxidation of the alcohol grouping of C or C to carbonyl by the action of a second molecule of phenylhydrazine the latter is reduced to aniline and ammonia. Alternative explanations of this reaction have been advanced, but these cannot be discussed here (see, however. Section 111,139,6). 

In summary, it seems that for most Diels-Alder reactions secondary orbital interactions afford a satisfactory rationalisation of the endo-exo selectivity. However, since the endo-exo ratio is determined by small differences in transition state energies, the influence of other interactions, most often steric in origin and different for each particular reaction, is likely to be felt. The compact character of the Diels-Alder activated complex (the activation volume of the retro Diels-Alder reaction is negative) will attenuate these eflfects. The ideas of Sustmann" and Mattay ° provide an attractive alternative explanation, but, at the moment, lack the proper experimental foundation. 

Further evidence pointing in the same direction was provided by Pierce, Wiley and Smith, who found that on steam activation of a particular char at 900°C the saturation uptake increased three-fold, yet the isotherm was still of Type I. They argued that even if the width of the pores was only two molecular diameters before activation, it would increase, by removal of oxides, during the activation so that the second Type I isotherm would correspond to pores more than two molecular diameters wide. (The alternative explanation, that activation produced new pores of the same width as the old, seems unlikely.)... 

The iaterpretation of the spectroscopy of SBSL is much less clear. At this writing, SBSL has been observed primarily ia aqueous fluids, and the spectra obtained are surprisiagly featureless. Some very interesting effects are observed when the gas contents of the bubble are changed (39,42). Furthermore, the spectra show practically no evidence of OH emissions, and when He and Ar bubbles are considered, continue to iacrease ia iatensity even iato the deep ultraviolet. These spectra are reminiscent of blackbody emission with temperatures considerably ia excess of 5000 K and lend some support to the concept of an imploding shock wave (41). Several other alternative explanations for SBSL have been presented, and there exists considerable theoretical activity ia this particular aspect of SBSL. 

The procedure given in Fig. 30-15 leaves much to analysts. Criteria for selecting the number ana location of measurements for a particular piece of equipment or unit have not been established in the literature. Therefore, there is heavy reliance on examining alternative models at the bottom of the procedure. The creativity of analysts to develop alternative explanations for performance or hypotheses explaining why the present model might be wrong is a particularly important skill. 

The presence of organisms (large or small) in proximity to corrosion by itself is not proof of biologically influenced corrosion, any more than a correlation of lunar phases with stock market fluctuations establishes a lunar-financial connection. It should be stressed vigorously that all evidence must be consistent with any single corrosion mode before a definitive diagnosis can be made (see Critical Factors above). Further, all alternative explanations must be carefully examined. 

An alternative explanation which has been advanced for the first-order reaction is tlrat one molecule is activated during a bitrrolecular collision, and catr retain the activation energy until it finally decomposes some time after the... 

These effects are attributed to differences in the c-donor character of the C—C bonds as a result of substitution. Electron-attracting groups diminish the donor capacity and promote syn addition. An alternative explanation invokes a direct electrostatic effect arising from the C-X bond dipole. 

This particular reaction has quite a high activation energy, which suggests that a nonconcerted mechanism might be involved. An alternative explanation for the observed stereochemistry has been advanced. 

An alternative explanation has been proposed by Quesnel [62]. Assuming that the adhesion-induced deformation could be treated as a Hertzian indentor, with the load due to the force arising from the surface energy, Quesnel calculated the indentation in a self-consistent manner. That is to say, Quesnel recognized that the attractive force would vary as the particle or substrate deformed, owing to the increased circumference of the contact patch. He also recognized that, due to... 

Huffman found that treatment of cholan-12-one (65b) with lithium and ammonia for 2 hours followed by addition of propanol gives 40 % of a pinacol together with 48.5 % of 12-ols in which the ratio of 12j5 12a is 19 1. This predominance of the 12 -ol was interpreted in terms of slow formation of a dianion of type (62) followed by its equilibration to the thermodynamically most stable configuration, i.e. one which affords the 12j5-ol upon protonation. An alternative explanation is that reduction in the presence of methanol involves protonation of a ketyl such as (61) by methanol, whereas in the absence of methanol reduction proceeds via the dianion (62) which is protonated on... 

Spectroscopic evidence indicates that protonation of 2-fluoro-and 2-chloro-quinoline is not appreciable in O.OlJf aqueous hydrochloric acid. Protonation becomes evident in more strongly acidic solution in the case of the chloro compound without any accompanying decomposition, but the fluoro compound hydrolyzes to carbostyril under the latter conditions. The hydrolysis is acid-catalyzed, but it is doubtful whether protonation on the heterocyclic nitrogen is responsible, owing to its low basicity (presumably below that for the chloro compound). An alternative explanation in this case would be hydrogen bond formation with fluorine, Ar—F. .. H-O+H2. 

The lack of a uniform order of relative reactivity of the halogens in reactions of certain nucleophiles with nitro- and polynitro-phenyl halides led Parker and Read to propose a one-stage mechanism for some aromatic nucleophilic substitutions. An alternative explanation within the framework of the two-stage S Ar2 mechanism had been proposed earlier. A range of mechanisms has been considered in the past by Chapman, who properly points out that only in a limited number of examples is the evidence for the two-stage mechanism compelling even though the balance of evidence favors it. 

An alternative explanation for the photoinduced absorption in the bulk polymer has been discussed by the Cambridge group [28]. It was shown that the amount of stimulated emission depends critically on the degree of photooxidation of the conjugated polymer. Figure 10-5 compares the stimulated emission of pristine PPV (see Fig. 10-5 a) and its heavily photooxidized counterpart (sec Fig. 10-5b). 

These ideas might be used to explain the interesting results obtained recently by Williams et al.53 These workers observed formation of crystalline polystyrene when the reaction was initiated by triphenyl methyl potassium (or some other potassium metallo-organic compounds) in a hexane solution, but an amorphous polymer was formed in benzene. They point out that the catalyst is soluble in benzene but insoluble in hexane, and suggest that the heterogeneity of the catalyst is responsible for the results. Although this might be the case, an alternative explanation could be advanced.42 1... 

In some cases, an alternative explanation is possible. It may be assumed that any very complex organic counterion can also interact with the CP matrix with the formation of weak non-ionic bonds, e.g., dipole-dipole bonds or other types of weak interactions. If the energy of these weak additional interactions is on the level of the energy of the thermal motion, a set of microstates appears for counterions and the surrounding CP matrix, which leads to an increase in the entropy of the system. The changes in Gibbs free energy of this interaction may be evaluated in a semiquantitative way [15]. 

Alternative explanations of the high conductivity of composite materials obtained by polymerization filling are given in works [62, 63] where conductivity higher than that of the graphite proper is attributed to a polymer interlayer between graphite particles, are, in our opinion, insufficiently convincing and cannot explain the whole of the experimental data. 

It has also been proposed that the ring-opened radicals may undergo ring-closure to a cyclobutane (Scheme 4.23).202,2 8 At this stage the only evidence for this pathway is observation of signals in the NMR spectrum of the polymer that cannot be rationalized in terms of the other structures. There is no precedent for 1,4-ring-closure of a 3-butenyl radical in small molecule chemistry and the result is contrary to expectation based on stcrcoclcctronic requirements for intramolecular addition (Section 2.3.4). However, an alternate explanation has yet to be proposed. The possibility of carbonium ion intermediates should not be discounted. 

The above argument is also at odds with the conventional wisdom that the well-known tendency for monomer alternation in copolymerization can primarily be attributed to polar factors. It was suggested9 that, in most cases, radical stabilization could provide an alternate explanation. A discussion on the relative importance of steric polar and radical stabilization effects on radical addition appears in Section 2.3. 

There is considerable scope for alternative explanations (see Sect. 3.6.3, 3.7, and 4). Most of the deductions from the data ignore the variation in tre due to the kinetic nature of the process, despite claims within the theory that this should have a large effect [122]. Equilibrium uncertainties as described in Sect. 2.3 are completely ignored. When the parameters within LH theory are also considered it no longer seems surprising that self-consistency can be obtained. 

Another reaction mechanism, which is conveniently mentioned under this heading, is due to Hill [479] who suggested that ions (atoms or molecules) frorh the product may move through the dislocation network of the reactant and activate potential nuclei, particularly in the vicinity of the reaction interface. Thus a reaction zone, within which potential nucleusforming sites are activated, is developed in front of an advancing interface. With appropriate assumptions, this reaction model provides an alternative explanation of the exponential rate law, eqn. (8), which in Sect. 3.2 was discussed with reference to chain reactions. 

An alternative explanation suggested by the authors for the non-linearity of R° with dose is the formation of reactive solvent species capable of intercepting the scission reaction, with a yield which becomes greater the higher the absorbed dose per pulse. However, this mechanism does not explain the effect of oxygen. 

An alternative explanation for the exclusive formation of the even-numbered cyclic oligomers would be that they are produced by the polymerization of the cyclic dimer. However, the cyclic dimer isolated from the reaction mixture was found not to polymerize under the reaction conditions used for the oligomerization. Therefore, if this concept were correct, another cyclic dimer with a different configuration and higher reactivity must have been formed during the reaction. Its presence, however, has not yet been verified by experiment. 

---