Ideal controllers

By similar procedures we obtain from equations 7.3, 7.4 and 7.5, for PI control  

---

The horn fly Haematobia irritans an important bloodsucking pest of catde, was found to be completely controlled by ear tags which slowly released permethrin and fenvalerate. These were found to give almost 100% control for 24 weeks. However, following almost universal appHcation of this ideal control measure, control failures of the pyrethroid insecticides were widely reported in North America in 1982 ndash 1983 and the practice is now abandoned. 

In the application described here, a simulation study was performed to develop the ideal control strategy. Additionally, a good model of the system enables the controller parameters to be optimized during the initial engineering phase. This, in turn, means that commissioning time can be substantially reduced. 

Bone and tooth enamel from modem animals were collected in 1984 and 1993 from skeletons exposed on the surface in Sibiloi National Park, located on the east shore of Lake Turkana in northern Kenya. In addition to its interest as the site of numerous fossil hominid discoveries, the Turkana area provides an ideal controlled situation for the present study. The park is a circumscribed area surrounded by human pastoral groups and the nondomestic fauna remain to a great extent within its confines. Water sources are limited to the lake, ephemeral streams, a limited number of waterholes, and the plants eaten by the animals. The streams last on the order of days and in dry years do not flow at all. The non-domestic animals from which the bone and enamel were collected likely obtained most of their drinking water from the lake itself Domestic animals entered the park in 1984 during a severe drought. Their drinking water sources may have varied widely. 

It is useful to consider the ideal situation. If we could design an ideal controller without any regard for physical realizability, what would the ideal elosed-loop regular and servo transfer functions be Clearly, we would wish a load disturbance to have no effect on the controlled variable. So the ideal closedloop regulator transfer function is zero. For setpoint changes, we would like the controlled variable to track the setpoint perfectly at all times. So the ideal servo transfer function is unity. 

Typical log modulus Bode plots of these two closedloop transfer functions are shown in Fig. 13.10a. If it were possible to achieve perfect or ideal control, the two ideal closedloop transfer functions would be... 

The basic idea in multivariable IMC is the same as in single-loop IMC. The ideal controller would be the inverse of the plant transfer function matrix. This would give perfect control. However, the inverse of the plant transfer function matrix is not physically realizable because of deadtimes, higher-order denominators than numerators, and RHP zeros (which would give an openloop unstable controller). 

If we don t have such an ideal control sample, but only one with a matrix different from the routine sample (e.g. a standard solution) than we have to consider also the uncertainty component arising from changes in the matrix. For this purpose we use the (repeatability) standard deviation calculated from repeated measurements of our routine samples (performed e.g. for a range control chart). When we estimate the reproducibility within laboratory we now have to combine both contributions by calculating the square root of the sum of squares. 

CRMs would be the ideal control samples, but they normally are too expensive and very often not available. In-house reference materials that are regularly checked against a CRM under repeatability conditions are a good alternative. 

However, the ideal control algorithm would have no overshoot, no offset, and a quick response characteristic. For this purpose, a proportional action (P), an integral action (I), and a differential action (D) were combined as a PID controller as follows. 

Analyzing control materials alongside the test samples greatly improves proficiency in mycotoxin analysis. Certified reference materials (CRMs) represent ideal control materials, due to their statement of uncertainty and traceability, and they should be routinely used as much as possible. Unfortunately, as outstanding as the improvements made in the last decade have been, even though the list of CRMs in the area of mycotoxins is rather long, it is still insufficient. A list of the available reference materials in the mycotoxins area is reported in Table 1 the issue has been reviewed by Boenke (27). 

Even under ideally controlled laboratory conditions using pure chemicals, the dissolution of a solid compound in water may involve several complex reactions and the formation of numerous dissolved species. As an example, the dissolution of slightly soluble AS2S3 (orpiment) in water can be investigated in a laboratory closed system at 25°C and 1 bar pressure. Nordstrom and Archer (2003), 9 proposed the following reaction to describe the dissolution of orpiment, which initially forms H3ASO30 and H2S° ... 

The most appropriate control for any immunostain would be an internal control because it would have been subjected to identical pre-analytical and analytical variables as the test tissue. However, such controls are invariably non-lesional or benign cells that express the antigen of interest at levels different to the tumor cells and are thus not ideal controls. Nonetheless, they are currently the best controls available. 

Choice D is an ideal control because the impact of water at 0 °C on room temperature water is simpler than the impact of metals at 0 °C on room temperature water, and nothing new is added. 

Ideally, controls should be assayed in duplicate at three concentrations corresponding to below, within, and above the therapeutic range. (Suggested values for some drugs are given in Table 1.)... 

The fact that irradiation of a dye solution in the absence of a photocatalyst decomposes the dye negligibly has often been described in the papers to support negligible photoinduced reaction by photoexcited dye molecules. However, the photoinduced electron injection requires an acceptor, such as titania, and thereby there are no ideal control experiments to exclude the possibility of photoinduced electron injection, as shown in Fig. 11. When organic dyes themselves are a pollutant to be decomposed, visible light-induced, but not photocatalytic, reaction can be a useful technique, e.g., Chen, X. Zheng, Z. Ke, X. Jaatinen, E. Xie, T. Wang, D. Guo, C. Zhao, J. Zhu, H. Green Chem. 2010, 12, 414. 

Evaluate design requirements for adequate transient control performance using ideal control analysis or optimal PI control performance estimates... 

In a well-engineered system, measurement noise is unlikely to affect the performance of a PI controller significantly (Section V.A.2), but it may limit the use of derivative control action and will certainly limit the performance of advanced control schemes that attempt to approach ideal control (Section V.A.5). Our approach to PID control has been to optimize PI controllers and leave the possible benefit of derivative action to the commissioning engineers. 

Summary. The greatest scope for moving performance toward the ideal control bound lies in reducing measurement lag and improving understanding of meas-... 

---