Cycloaddition reactions radical cation-initiated

Unlike thermal [2 + 2] cycloadditions which normally do not proceed readily unless certain structural features are present (see Section 1.3.1.1.), metal-catalyzed [2 + 2] cycloadditions should be allowed according to orbital symmetry conservation rules. There is now evidence that most metal-catalyzed [2 + 2] cycloadditions proceed stepwise via metallacycloalkanes as intermediates and both their formation and transformation are believed to occur by concerted processes. In many instances such reactions occur with high regioselectivity. Another mode for [2 + 2] cyclodimerization and cycloadditions involves radical cation intermediates (hole-catalyzed) obtained from oxidation of alkcnes by strong electron acceptors such as triarylammini-um radical cation salts.1 These reactions are similar to photochemical electron transfer (PET) initiated [2 + 2] cyclodimerization and cycloadditions in which an electron acceptor is used in the irradiation process.2 Because of the reversibility of these processes there is very little stereoselectivity observed in the cyclobutanes formed. 

A radical-cation initiated intramolecular cycloaddition of 3 to 4 has been reported to occur using tris(4-bromophenyl)amminium hexachloroantimonate (TBAH).22 A number of Bronsted acids including trifluoroacetic acid can also effect this reaction. 

Electron transfer from the alkene leads to a radical cation that can undergo coupling (Scheme la). The radical cation can also react with the nucleophilic heteroatom of a reagent to afford addition or substitution products (Scheme lb). Adducts can be likewise obtained by oxidation of the nucleophile to a radical that undergoes radical addition. Reactions between alkenes and nucleophiles can be realized too with chemical oxidants that are regenerated at the anode (mediators) (see Chapter 15). Finally, cycloadditions between alkenes can be initiated by a catalytic anodic electron transfer. These principal reaction modes are subsequently illustrated by selected conversions. 

It is important to note that the reactions are fundamentally different from similar radical cation Diels-Alder reactions initiated with the use of a photochemical electron-transfer reaction [35, 36]. In photochemical reactions, a one-electron oxidation of the substrate leads to a cycloaddition that is then terminated by a back electron transfer . No net change is made in the oxidation state of the substrate. However, the reaction outlined in Scheme 13 involves a net two-electron oxidation of the substrate. Hence, the two pathways are complementary. 

One of the problems associated with thermal cyclodimerization of alkenes is the elevated temperatures required which often cause the strained cyclobutane derivatives formed to undergo ring opening, resulting in the formation of secondary thermolysis products. This deficiency can be overcome by the use of catalysts (metals Lewis or Bronsted acids) which convert less reactive alkenes to reactive intermediates (metalated alkenes, cations, radical cations) which undergo cycloaddilion more efficiently. Nevertheless, a number of these catalysts can also cause the decomposition of the cyclobutanes formed in the initial reaction. Such catalyzed alkene cycloadditions are limited specifically to allyl cations, strained alkenes such as methylenccyclo-propane and donor-acceptor-substituted alkenes. The milder reaction conditions of the catalyzed process permit the extension of the scope of [2 + 2] cycloadditions to include alkene combinations which would not otherwise react. 

These reactions can lead to carbon-carbon or carbon-heteroatom bonds, and their course can be intermolecular or intramolecular. Furthermore, cycloadditions can be initiated by anodic generation of the dienophile or by inducing a chain reaction with a radical cation as dienophile. 

Oxidation of aryl hydrazones by thianthrene radical cation have also been suggested to occur via electron-transfer and such reactions have been reviewed previously [110]. Reaction of oximes with thianthrene radical cation produces cycloaddition products [56,57], nitriles, and carbonyl compounds. The cycloaddition products are believed to be formed via initial one-electron oxidation of the oxime. 

In the electron-transfer-sensitized reaction of the 2-vinylindole 27 with dienes it has been found that the indole rather than the diene usually [41c], although not always [41b], becomes the diene partner in the 2-1-4 cycloaddition reaction styrenes also add to 27 in this manner and the initial adducts are further oxidized to the carbazole 28 under the reaction conditions (Scheme 11) [41c]. Formation of the indole radical cation and its attack on the styrene to give intermediate 29 explains the regioselectivity observed. 

The cycloaddition of l,l-bis(2-thienyl)ethylene (prepared in situ from the ethanol (169) with strong electron acceptors such as TCNE or ddq has been shown to proceed via a radical ion pair formed by electron transfer (Scheme 29) <90H(3i)i873>. The reaction with TCNE is rapid and quantitative, taking place at room temperature in 15 min. With ddq, the initial product (170) is further oxidized to (171). When the ethanol (169) is heated alone in the dark at 150°C, it generates the aromatized cycloadduct (173) in 70% yield. Other minor products possibly result from a radical process <91CB1203>. On the other hand, irradiation of the alcohol (169) generates l,l-bis(2-thienyl)ethylene cleanly, which is subsequently transformed to the cycloadduct (172). A radical cation may be implicated in this photochemical [4 + 2] cycloaddition also. 

Cycloaddition reactions of alkene radical cations have been the subject of a number of mechanistic studies and are potentially useful synthetic reactions. - - - Most of the initial work on radical cation mediated cycloadditions focused on the dimerization of arylalkenes. with one of the first examples being Ledwith s report of the chloranil-sensitized dimerization of M-vinylcarba-zole to generate a diarylcyclobutane. This work led to the development of the mechanism outlined in Scheme 2, in which addition of the radical cation to neutral alkene generates an acyclic 1,4-radical cation as the primary intermediate. This intermediate cyclizes to a cyclobutane radical cation that is then reduced by the neutral alkene and regenerates a second radical cation to carry the chain. 

Despite the demonstrated utility of alkene radical cation cycloadditions, little kinetic data for these reactions are currently available. However, two recent studies have provided rate constants for the initial step in the cyclobutanation or Diels-Alder reactions of a number of styrene radical cations.Previous work by Bauld had shown that the rrradical cation reacts with a variety of alkenes to generate either cyclobutane or Diels—Alder adducts (Eqs. 23, 24) 110 j, g [jnetic data for the styrene radical cation cycloadditions, in combination with the dimerization results discussed above, provide a detailed assessment of the effects of radical cation and alkene structure on dimerization and cross addition reactions. 

The kinetic data discussed above demonstrate the effects of varying the structure of both the styrene radical cation and the alkene on the initial step in the cycloaddition reaction. However, the transient experiments do not provide any evidence that would permit one to distinguish between a concerted or stepwise mechanism. The kinetic data obtained for additions to a range of alkenes do show considerable similarities to those reported for the addition of carbenium ions to the same substrates. For example, rate constants for the addition of the bis(4-methyl-phenyl)methyi cation to a series of ring-substituted styrenes also correlate with the Hammett a and a parameters with p and p values of-5.2 and -5.0, respectively." The latter reactions are thought to proceed via a partially bridged transition slate and might, therefore, be expected to show similarities to concerted... 

These results provide the first detailed calibration for a series of intramolecular radical cation probes based on cycloaddition chemistry. The cyclization rate constants cover several orders of magnitude in timescale, an ideal case for using 1—3 as probes for radical cations of different lifetimes. However, the time-resolved experiments demonstrate that the application of radical cation probes, at least those based on aryl alkene cycloaddition chemistry, may be considerably less straightforward than similar experiments with free radical probes or clocks. Some of the problems that need to be addressed include the variation of products with the reaction conditions and method of radical cation generation, and the possibility of reversibility of the initial adduct formation. Furthermore, at least some radical cation reactions are quite sensitive to solvent and this may mean that calibrations for radical cation cycloadditions will have to be done in a variety of solvents. 

In cycloaddition reactions of tetra-t-butylcyclobutadiene with either dicyanoacetylene or tetracyanoethylene it is suggested that the initial step may be oxidation of the cyclobutadiene by the cyano compound to a radical cation which recombines with the radical anion of the cyano compound to provide the adduct [53],... 

---