Concerted mechanism, technique

In addition to conventional ab initio methods, techniques based on the density functional theory (DFT) have also been used to study the Diels-Alder reaction between butadiene and ethylene97-99. With these kinds of methods, a concerted mechanism through a symmetric transition state is also predicted. Several kinds of density functionals have been used. The simplest one is based on the Local Density Approach (LDA), in which all the potentials depend only on the density. More sophisticated functionals include a dependence on the gradient of the density, such as that of Becke, Lee, Yang and Parr (BLYP). 

The discussion above provides the necessary elements to answer the question posed in the heading. If the intermediate does not exist (i.e., its lifetime is shorter than one vibration), the concerted mechanism is necessarily followed. Conversely, however, if the intermediate exists, the reaction pathway does not necessarily go through it, depending on the molecular structure and the driving force. Dichotomy and competition between the two mechanisms is a general problem of chemical reactivity. The example of electron transfer/bond reactions has allowed a detailed analysis of the problem, thanks to the use of electrochemical techniques on the experimental side and of semiempirical models on the theoretical side. 

The concerted mechanism (equation 5) is often encountered (or experimental techniques are not sensitive enough to detect very rapid consecutive steps). Unless otherwise stated a concerted mechanism will be presumed. In a number of examples to be cited, however, the final word is doubtless not yet in. 

Many stereochemical results like these, and the consistent observation of nonthermodynamic products that would not be expected from two-step mechanisms, have accumulated to support the operation of the pericyclic mechanism in most cases. Recent advances in experimental and theoretical techniques have allowed chemists to probe the mechanisms of pericyclic reactions at time scales far shorter than the time required to rotate about a C—C cr bond, and these experiments have supported concerted mechanisms for some pericyclic reactions and nonconcerted mechanisms for others. In practical terms, though, if no experimental or theoretical evidence rules it out, Occam s razor compels one to propose a concerted mechanism in favor of a nonconcerted one. 

The technique can be applied to dissociative processes (Scheme 10) and distinguishes between a concerted mechanism and a stepwise process. The break-point in the free energy correlation would occur at the value of the parameter giving a symmetrical termolecular intermediate for example (Nu2.PO3. Nu1) in the pyridinolysis of A-phospho-isoquinolinium ion (Figure 7). The example shown is the first system to be studied by the quasi-symmetrical technique. 

Bimolecular ion-molecule reactions such as those in Reactions 2.2-2.4 are often very fast, by which we mean that they can often occur on every collision, which makes them useful for efficient ionization of target molecules in mass spectrometry. Furthermore, the energy available to deposit into the product cation is typically low, and may be well under 1 eV if an appropriate Cl reagent is chosen. This low excess energy means that CI-MS is considered to be a soft ionization technique since it tends to leave parent ions intact. However, it is also wise to bear in mind that some ion-molecule reactions can occur via concerted mechanisms which lead to fragmentation even with much smaller excess energies, so soft ionization is not necessarily fragment-free. 

Finally, Nagaoka et al have made a very interesting study applying MC-FEP techniques to the vinyl alcohol - acetaldehyde tautomerism.32 Using a cluster of the solute with three water molecules as a solute , the free energy for the tautomerism was calculated along different reaction pathways, which had been previously found by ab initio calculations including an SCRF solvation term. They were able to deduce that a two-step mechanism is favoured over a concerted one for the transfer of the proton. 

As an example of this technique we consider 12C/13C isotope effects in the Diels-Alder condensation of isoprene and maleic anhydride (Equation 7.32). The terminal carbons of isoprene carbons are numbered 1 and 4, the methyl substituted carbon is number 2. The reaction proceeds via a concerted and slightly asynchronous mechanism. 

The reaction mechanisms of organic electrode reactions are thus composed of at least one ET step at the electrode as well as preceding and follow-up bond-breaking, bond-forming, or structural rearrangement steps. These chemical steps may be concerted with the electron transfer [15, 16]. The instrumental techniques described in this chapter allow the investigation of the course of the reaction accompanying the overall electrolysis. 

Campos, Sampedro and Rodriguez studied theoretically in 1998 the competition of the concerted and stepwise mechanism of hydrogen migration and lithium iodide a-eUmination in the trihydrate 1-iodo-l-lithioethene 28. Since the lithiated derivative of 1-iodoethane readily decomposes to ethylene, experimental techniques are found to be of less use. Their ab initio theoretical calculations indicate that the preferred mechanism is the concerted rather than stepwise pathway as illustrated in Eigure 33. Their studies also suggest that 1-iodo-l-thioethene prefers to be a monomer in THE and the activation barriers for the cis and trans hydrogen migration are nearly the same. 

One of the most widely applied cycloaddition techniques for the preparation of thietanes is the reaction of sulfenes with enamines. The stereochemistry of these reactions has been extensively investigated by Truce and Rach. Whether the mechanism is a two-step or a concerted process, both in accordance with the stereoselective formation of the cis form in Scheme 1, is still unresolved. The special orientation of the 1,4-dipolar intermediate 64, in which the charged phenyl and dimethylamino moieties are in proximity, enforces the cis geometry of the resulting thietane dioxide. In the concerted mode of reaction, formation of the orthogonal oriented unsaturated system, 65 should also yield the cis cycloadduct. 

The convolution analysis is based on the use of convolution data and further manipulation to obtain information on the ET mechanism, standard potentials, intrinsic barriers, and also to detect mechanism transitions. It is worth noting that the general outlines of the methodology were first introduced in the study of the kinetics of reduction of terf-nitrobutane in dipolar aprotic solvents, under conditions of chemical stability of the generated anion radical. For the study of concerted dissociative ET processes, linear scan voltammetry is the most useful electrochemical technique. 

A review of direct observation of the transition state has traced the development of the femtosecond reaction dynamic technique, which has been used to demonstrate that the retro-Diels-Alder reaction can proceed by a stepwise mechanism as well as the usual concerted process.28 The oxide anion accelerated retro-Diels-Alder reaction has also been reviewed29 and the promise of this mild reaction for synthetic application has been emphasized. 

In 1970, Chauvin and Herisson presented a study of the co-metathesis of cycloalkene/alkene mixtures using a WOCLj/SnBuj pro-catalyst mixture [12]. Whilst the fully quantitative analysis of the product mixtures was made complicated by the range of techniques that were required for the low, medium and high molecular weight products (mono alkenes, telomers and polymers), it became clear that product ratios were not consistent with what would be predicted by either mechanism in Scheme 12.14. The analysis and associated mechanistic interpretation were seminal and worthy of consideration in some detail here. The key point is that both mechanisms in Scheme 12.14 are pairwise, i.e. each turnover of the catalyst cycle involves two alkenes that undergo concerted alkylidene exchange. When a single alkene, e.g. pent-2-ene (C5), is considered, the products of alkylidene metathesis... 

---