Complexes valence bond approach

Although the simple valence-bond approach to the bonding in coordination compounds has many deficiencies, it is still useful as a first attempt to explain the structure of many complexes. The reasons why certain ligands force electron pairing will be explored in Chapter 17, but it is clear that high- and low-spin complexes have different magnetic character, and the interpretation of the results of this technique will now be explored. 

The valence bond model constructs hybrid orbitals which contain various fractions of the character of the pure component orbitals. These hybrid orbitals are constructed such that they possess the correct spatial characteristics for the formation of bonds. The bonding is treated in terms of localised two-electron two-centre interactions between atoms. As applied to first-row transition metals, the valence bond approach considers that the 45, 4p and 3d orbitals are all available for bonding. To obtain an octahedral complex, two 3d, the 45 and the three 4p metal orbitals are mixed to give six spatially-equivalent directed cfisp3 hybrid orbitals, which are oriented with electron density along the principal Cartesian axes (Fig. 1-9). 

The structures of two binuclear carbonyls, Mn2(CO)i0 and Fe2(CO)9, are shown in Figure 10-2 note the carbonyl bridges in these molecules. In addition, the metal atoms in each molecule are close enough to each other so there is significant metal-to-metai bonding interaction. The stabilities of such binuclear carbonyls and similar but more complex carbonyl derivatives cannot be convincingly rationalized by the classical valence-bond approach. It is here that molecular orbital theory must be invoked. 

The chemist is accustomed to think of the chemical bond from the valence-bond approach of Pauling (7)05), for this approach enables construction of simple models with which to develop a chemical intuition for a variety of complex materials. However, this approach is necessarily qualitative in character so that at best it can serve only as a useful device for the correlation and classification of materials. Therefore the theoretical context for the present discussion is the Hund (290)-Mulliken (4f>7) molecular-orbital approach. Nevertheless an important restriction to the application of this approach must be emphasized at the start viz. an apparently sharp breakdown of the collective-electron assumption for interatomic separations greater than some critical distance, R(. In order to illustrate the theoretical basis for this breakdown, several calculations will be considered, the first being those for the hydrogen molecule. 

In the course of investigating multiple bonds in molecules and complexes by the valence bond approach, we have recently found that such multiple bonds are more accurately described as bent bonds rather than as a and tt bonds (7-5). In order to understand the potential implications of these results for multiple metal-metal bonds, it is important to brieffy review the basic assumptions of the valence bond model and compare them to those of the more familiar molecular orbital model of bonding. 

A very satisfying feature of the described localized view of transition metal complexes such as CoFg 3 is that there is no necessity to invoke cobalt 4 d orbitals in order to preserve the four unpaired electrons, as is done in the familiar Pauling-type valence bond approach (8). 

Pauling, L. The Nature of the Chemical Bond, 3rd ed., Ithaca, NY Cornell University Press, 1960. A comparison of the valence bond approach with other theories as applied to transition metal complexes can be found in Huheey, J.E. Inorganic Chemistry Principles of Structure and Reactivity. New York Harper and Row, 1972. 

Abstract The wave function of Coulson and Fischer is examined within the context of recent developments in quantum chemistry. It is argued that the Coulson-Fischer ansatz establishes a third way in quantum chemistry, which should not be confused with the traditional molecular orbital and valence bond formalisms. The Coulson-Fischer theory is compared with modern valence bond approaches and also modern multireference correlation methods. Because of the non-orthogonality problem which arises when wave functions are constructed from arbitrary orbital products, the application of the Coulson-Fischer method to larger molecules necessitates the introduction of approximation schemes. It is shown that the use of hierarchical orthogonality restrictions has advantages, combining a picture of molecular electronic structure which is an accord with simple, but nevertheless empirical, ideas and concepts, with a level of computational complexity which renders praetieal applications to larger molecules tractable. An open collaborative virtual environment is proposed to foster further development. 

In Mulliken s valence-bond approach the donor-acceptor complex, DA, is considered to be described by a wave function which may be written... 

Very often a specific semiempirical MO method was adopted to represent Hqu and a specific MM method was used for //mm and the coupling term / qm-mm introduced additional empirical parameters to allow the combined energy to reproduce experiments. Thus they are specific to the MO method and the MM method adopted at the initial definition of the method. The empirical valence bond approach has also been combined with MM for more complex systems. There have been other approaches attempting to incorporate different procedures which show the importance of combining these methods and the difficulty in doing so. Numerous QM/MM studies have been made in the past, including various versions, some applications, " the treatment of charges, application to zeolites and biochemistry, molecular dynamics, and solvent effects. These variations of the so-called QM/MM methods are treated in separate articles. 

The ethylene-metal system provides a useful model by which to describe the bonding in w-bonded metal-organic complexes. As we shall see, such bonding is difficult to treat in terms of a conventional classical valence bond approach. It is more meaningful to use descriptions based on molecular orbital theory. 

In this paper a method [11], which allows for an a priori BSSE removal at the SCF level, is for the first time applied to interaction densities studies. This computational protocol which has been called SCF-MI (Self-Consistent Field for Molecular Interactions) to highlight its relationship to the standard Roothaan equations and its special usefulness in the evaluation of molecular interactions, has recently been successfully used [11-13] for evaluating Eint in a number of intermolecular complexes. Comparison of standard SCF interaction densities with those obtained from the SCF-MI approach should shed light on the effects of BSSE removal. Such effects may then be compared with those deriving from the introduction of Coulomb correlation corrections. To this aim, we adopt a variational perturbative valence bond (VB) approach that uses orbitals derived from the SCF-MI step and thus maintains a BSSE-free picture. Finally, no bias should be introduced in our study by the particular approach chosen to analyze the observed charge density rearrangements. Therefore, not a model but a theory which is firmly rooted in Quantum Mechanics, applied directly to the electron density p and giving quantitative answers, is to be adopted. Bader s Quantum Theory of Atoms in Molecules (QTAM) [14, 15] meets nicely all these requirements. Such a theory has also been recently applied to molecular crystals as a valid tool to rationalize and quantitatively detect crystal field effects on the molecular densities [16-18]. 

Warshel is to utilize a formula identical to (11.22) in this chapter to compute the free energy change. They employed an empirical valence bond (EVB, below) approach to approximately model electronic effects, and the calculations included the full experimental structure of carbonic anhydrase. An H/D isotope effect of 3.9 1.0 was obtained in the calculation, which compared favorably with the experimental value of 3.8. This benchmark calculation gives optimism that quantum effects on free energies can be realistically modeled for complex biochemical systems. 

The empirical valence bond (EVB) approach introduced by Warshel and co-workers is an effective way to incorporate environmental effects on breaking and making of chemical bonds in solution. It is based on parame-terizations of empirical interactions between reactant states, product states, and, where appropriate, a number of intermediate states. The interaction parameters, corresponding to off-diagonal matrix elements of the classical Hamiltonian, are calibrated by ab initio potential energy surfaces in solu-fion and relevant experimental data. This procedure significantly reduces the computational expenses of molecular level calculations in comparison to direct ab initio calculations. The EVB approach thus provides a powerful avenue for studying chemical reactions and proton transfer events in complex media, with a multitude of applications in catalysis, biochemistry, and PEMs. 

---