Carbonyl ylides using

After completing his initial intramolecular cycloaddition, Hodgson utilized conditions that had been optimized for the intermolecular cycloaddition of DMAD with simple cyclic carbonyl ylides used by Hashimoto and co-workers (139). Hodgson et al. (140) found that the reaction indeed gave excellent overall chemical yield, but the enantioselectivity dropped to 1%, giving essentially a racemic mixture. It appeared that ee ratios were sensitive to the electronic nature of the dipole. Hodgson chose to screen several binaphthol derived rhodium catalysts of the type developed by McKervey and Pirrung, due in part to the reports of... 

Hashimoto and co-workers have shown the enantioselective 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of the ester-derived carbonyl ylides using chiral dirhodium(II) carboxylates [110]. The ester-derived carbonyl ylide from the a-diazo ketone 98 in the presence (1 mol%) of Rh2(S-PTTL)4 99 as the catalyst afforded the cycloadduct 100 with 93% ee (Scheme 30). 

Carbonyl ylides continue to be targets of opportunity because of their suitability for trapping by dipolar addition. High enantiocontrol has been achieved in the process described by Eq. 16 [109], but such high enantioselectivity is not general [110] and is dependent on those factors suggested by Scheme 11. Using achiral dirhodium(II) catalysts, Padwa and coworkers have developed a broad selection of tandem reactions of which that in Eq. 17 is illustrative [111] these... 

Efforts to realize an intramolecular version of the above reactions met with limited success when monocyclic 4-thio-substituted (3-lactams were used. Cu(acac)2-catalyzed decomposition of diazoketone 358 produced the epimeric carbapenams 359 a, b together with the oxapenam derivative 360 341 these compounds correspond to the C4/S insertion products obtained in intermolecular reactions. Oxapenams were obtained exclusively when the acrylate residue in 359 was replaced by an aryl or heteroaryl substituent 275 342). The different reaction mode of diazoketones 290a, b, which furnish mainly or exclusively carbonyl ylide rather than sulfur ylide derived products, has already been mentioned (Sect. 5.2). 

Finally, it is important to mention that there are other related publications in which porphyrin macrocycles are not directly used as dipolarophiles but are transformed into new derivatives that can react with carbonyl ylides via ACE (alkene cyclobutene epoxide) reactions. This idea arose in 1997, when Russell and co-workers found that fused ester-activated cyclobutene epoxides 86 can be ring-opened to give carbonyl ylides 87, and that these can be trapped stereospecifically by ring-strained alicyclic dipolarophiles, such as 2,5-norbomadiene, to form hetero-bridged norbomanes 88 in good yields, through ACE transformations (Scheme 31) <97CC1023>. 

Formate esters behave as typical carbonyl compounds in reactions with a number of ylides, eliminating phosphine oxide and forming vinyl ethers, e.g. (33).35 Stabilized phosphoranes are able to condense with the carbonyl group of cyclic thioanhydrides (34).38 Quinoline derivatives, e.g. (35), are obtained from the condensation of dicar-boalkoxy-ylides with isocyanates.37 Benzoyl isothiocyanates and keto-phosphoranes give quantitative yields of (36), which are unreactive in Wittig reactions but can be readily oxidized by selenous acid.38 The products obtained from reactions (Scheme 9) with the triazolinedione (37) depend upon the stability of the ylide used.39... 

Some examples of transformations involving carbonyl ylides are listed in Table 4.20. Entry 1 illustrates the conversion of P-acyloxy-a-diazoesters into a-acyloxyacrylates by ring fission of a cyclic carbonyl ylide [978]. This reaction has been used for the synthesis of the natural aldonic acid KDO (3-deoxy-Z)-manno-2-octulosonic acid), which is an essential component of the cell wall lipopolysaccharide of gram-negative bacteria (Figure 4.15). 

As with any modern review of the chemical Hterature, the subject discussed in this chapter touches upon topics that are the focus of related books and articles. For example, there is a well recognized tome on the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reaction that is an excellent introduction to the many varieties of this transformation [1]. More specific reviews involving the use of rhodium(II) in carbonyl ylide cycloadditions [2] and intramolecular 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition reactions have also appeared [3, 4]. The use of rhodium for the creation and reaction of carbenes as electrophilic species [5, 6], their use in intramolecular carbenoid reactions [7], and the formation of ylides via the reaction with heteroatoms have also been described [8]. Reviews of rhodium(II) ligand-based chemoselectivity [9], rhodium(11)-mediated macrocyclizations [10], and asymmetric rho-dium(II)-carbene transformations [11, 12] detail the multiple aspects of control and applications that make this such a powerful chemical transformation. In addition to these reviews, several books have appeared since around 1998 describing the catalytic reactions of diazo compounds [13], cycloaddition reactions in organic synthesis [14], and synthetic applications of the 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition [15]. 

Despite this promising beginning, and its growing use for the generation of electrophilic carbenes [5, 6], it was not until many years later that rhodium(II) was used generally for the formation of 1,3-dipoles. Padwa and Stull reported the use of rhodium(II) acetate [Rh2(OAc)4] in the successful formation of a six-membered ring carbonyl ylide (Scheme 19.2) [21]. This work was quickly followed by the use of rhodium(II) for the generation of... 

Many different types of 1,3-dipoles have been described [Ij however, those most commonly formed using transition metal catalysis are the carbonyl ylides and associated mesoionic species such as isomiinchnones. Additional examples include the thiocar-bonyl, azomethine, oxonium, ammonium, and nitrile ylides, which have also been generated using rhodium(II) catalysis [8]. The mechanism of dipole formation most often involves the interaction of an electrophilic metal carbenoid with a heteroatom lone pair. In some cases, however, dipoles can be generated via the rearrangement of a reactive species, such as another dipole [40], or the thermolysis of a three-membered het-erocycHc ring [41]. 

Padwa has reported an approach to the ring system of the ribasine alkaloids 98 [174], using an intramolecular 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of the a-diazo ketone 99 to produce the pentacyclic skeleton 100 (Scheme 19.17). Wood [175] used an intermolecular 1,3-dipolar cycloaddition of a carbonyl ylide for the total synthesis of ( )-epoxysorbicilli-nol 101 (Scheme 19.18). The key cycloaddition in this approach is the conversion of 102 to the natural product core 103, which sets the substitution pattern around the entire ring system in a single step. 

Especially reactive carbonyl compounds such as methyl pyruvate can be used to trap the carbonyl ylide component. For example, ozonolysis of cyclooctene in the presence of methyl pyruvate leads to G, which, when treated with triethylamine, is converted to H, in which the two carbons of the original double bond have been converted to different functionalities.148... 

A similar reaction was successfully carried out with the five-membered cyclic carbonyl ylide 277 (Scheme 4.49), but attempts using a seven-membered ylide failed [318]. 

The structure of the carbonyl ylide reveals that it is a 1,3-dipolar species and is poised to undergo a variety of different reactions. The ability of carbonyl ylides to engage in bond-forming processes has promoted their use in organic synthesis. Although there are several pathways open to these zwitterionic intermediates, there are a few that have been the focus of detailed mechanistic and synthetic investigations (Fig. 4.2). 

The carbonyl ylide 1 can undergo an internal cyclization reaction to generate the corresponding epoxide 2, which is in fact an equilibrium process, and epoxides themselves have frequently served as precursors to carbonyl ylides. Other pathways such as concerted rearrangements and internal proton transfers have also been observed to neutralize the charged ylide intermediate and give substituted ethers as represented by 3. Perhaps the best known studies and most synthetically useful... 

The high levels of reactivity and the wide array of structures that can be accessed from carbonyl ylides has placed them in an excellent position to be used in the... 

Much of the initial synthetically useful carbonyl ylide work originated from the Ibata group. Exploiting simple disubstituted aromatic diazoketo-esters and structurally diverse dipolarophiles, Ibata and co-workers (64—70) prepared several different cycloadducts 167-169 through an intermolecular ylide cycloaddition (Scheme 4.38). 

A further study on six-membered ylide formation examined the use of an aliphatic ester in place of a ketone as the Lewis base donor for carbonyl ylide formation. Although the same keto-substituted system underwent an intramolecular cyclization readily, the ester derivative gave no cycloaddition products. Padwa and co-workers (37,76) points to the major electronic differences between the two carbonyl groups to rationalize the disparity in carbonyl ylide formation. 

Nair et al. (87) was able to extend this methodology with five-, six-, and seven-member carbonyl ylides. The five-membered ylide was the same carbonyl ylide as that used by Padwa for the synthesis of the illudins. The use of the seven-membered ylide was novel due to the fact that ylides greater than six atoms are generally difficult to form and indeed the yield of the cycloaddition with isatin (187) suffered and the product was isolated in only 32% yield. 

Padwa and co-workers (60,106,107) have been highly active in using carbonyl ylides for the synthesis of a number of bioactive alkaloids (Scheme 4.51). In an approach to the aspidosperma alkaloids, a push-pull carbonyl ylide was used to generate a bicyclic ylide containing a tethered indole moiety. This strategy ultimately allowed for the synthesis of the dehydrovindorosin skeleton (108). Starting from a quaternary substimted piperidone (200), elaboration of the 3-carboxylic acid provided p-ketoester amide 201. Addition of the indole tethered side chain provided a very rapid and efficient method to generate the cycloaddition precursor 203. 

Lycorine is an alkaloid that has attracted attention from both the synthetic community and pharmacologists. Prior synthetic approaches have included inter-and intramolecular Diels-Alder cycloaddition. Based on a similar retrosynthetic disconnection, Padwa and co-workers (106,109) chose to use a push-pull carbonyl ylide cycloaddition with a disubstituted pyrrolidinone core to generate a tricyclic substrate. The major difference for this synthetic smdy was the availability of a labile proton a to the carbonyl moiety (Scheme 4.53). 

Thus far, in the alkaloid series discussed, the nitrogen atom has always been part of the core of the alkaloid strucmre, rather than acting in a dipolarophilic manner in the cycloaddition of the carbonyl ylide. Recently, Padwa et al. (117) addressed this deficiency by conducting model studies to synthesize the core of ribasine, an alkaloid containing the indanobenzazepine skeleton with a bridging ether moiety (Scheme 4.57). Padwa found that indeed it was possible to use a C = N 7i-bond as the dipolarophile. In the first generation, a substimted benzylidene imine (219) was added after formation of the putative carbonyl ylide from diazoketone 218. The result was formation of both the endo and exo adduct with the endo adduct favored in an 8 1 ratio. This indicates that the endo transition state was shghtly favored as dictated by symmetry controlled HOMO—LUMO interactions. 

Padwa and co-workers (120-122) also utilized this carbonyl ylide cycloaddition strategy to advance to the aromatic pterosin family of compounds. The same intermediates used to approach the nonaromatic illudins and ptaqualosides are also useful for aromatic formation through cleavage and dehydration (Scheme 4.62). 

Friedrichsen and co-workers (135), along with Padwa, has utilized the carbonyl ylide cycloaddition to generate reactive furan moieties that can be further used in inter- or intramolecular Diels-Alder reactions to prepare aza- and carbocyclic compounds. Friedrichsen conducted a number of synthetic and theoretical studies on the reactivity, regioselectivity, and stereoselectivity of substituted furan formation and subsequent Diels-Alder reaction (Scheme 4.69). 

Hashimoto and co-workers (139) further looked at an intermolecular carbonyl ylide cycloaddition screening several different chiral rhodium catalysts. The Hashimoto group chose to study phthaloyl amino acid derivatives for enantiocon-trol of the cycloaddition reactions (Fig. 4.8). Using fluorinated or ethereal solvents with the phthaloyl catalysts gave ee ratios of 20-69%. 

There are very few examples of photolysis being used for preparation of a carbonyl ylide. The Dittami protocol follows work completed from his lab with aryl vinyl sulfides. Photolysis, followed by cycloaddition, led to the cycloadduct 305 in excellent yield and stereoselectivity. If the aryl vinyl ether 304 was subjected to irradiation in a mixed solution of toluene-methanol at 366 nm rather than a single solvent of toluene, cyclized product was obtained, but no cycloadduct was formed. If a simple phenyl aryl ether was subjected to the same tandem conditions, the cyclized product was generated, but no cycloadduct was detected. 

---