CIDNP and

One aspect of both EPR and CIDNP studies that should be kept in mind is that either is capable of detecting very small amounts of radical intermediates. This sensitivity makes both techniques quite useful, but it can also present a pitfall. The most prominent features of either EPR or CIDNP spectra may actually be due to radicals that account for only minor amounts of the total reaction process. An example of this was found in a study of the decomposition of trichloroacetyl peroxide in alkenes. 

In triethylamine instead of benzene the reaction products are completely different, and are indicative of a homolytic process involving an initial electron transfer from triethylamine followed by a hydrogen atom transfer. Scheme 10-68 gives the major products, namely 1,3,5-tri-tert-butylbenzene (10.36, 20%), the oxime 10.39 (18%), formed from the nitroso compound 10.38, and the acetanilide 10.37 (40%). ESR and CIDNP data are consistent with Scheme 10-68. In their paper the authors discuss further products which were found in smaller yields. 

The first reports of the observation of transient emission and enhanced absorption signals in the H-n.m.r. spectra of solutions in which radical reactions were taking place appeared in 1967. The importance of the phenomenon, named Chemically Induced Dynamic Nuclear Spin Polarization (CIDNP), in radical chemistry was quickly recognized. Since that time, an explosive growth in the number of publications on the subject has occurred and CIDNP has been detected in H, C, N, and P as well as H-n.m.r. spectra. Nevertheless, the number of groups engaged in research in this area is comparatively small. This may be a consequence of the apparent complexity of the subject. It is the purpose of this review to describe in a quahtative way the origin of CIDNP and to survey the published applications of the phenomenon in... 

Although it is now established that CIDNP has a quite different origin from DNP, the two effects were initially thought to be related. Thus the Overhauser effect, in which saturation of unpaired electron spins leads to polarization of nuclei coupled to the electrons through the hyperfine couphng constant (ajj), can be observed in organic radicals, and CIDNP 3... 

Two more recent studies of the nature of the sulfur-carbon bond cleavage in sulfoxide photolyses have been conducted, using ESR and CIDNP detection methods, respectively. In the latter case there is some evidence for a triplet process being involved in the photocleavage of aryl methyl sulfoxides. 

The mechanistic proposal of rate-limiting hydrogen atom transfer and radical recombination is based on the observed rate law, the lack of influence of CO pressure, kinetic isotope effects [studied with DMn(CO)s] and CIDNP evidence. In all known cases, exclusive formation of the overall 1,4-addition product has been observed for reaction of butadiene, isoprene and 2,3-dimethyl-l,3-butadiene. The preferred trapping of allyl radicals at the less substituted side by other radicals has actually been so convincing that its observation has been taken as a mechanistic probe78. 

The photochemical dissociation of Me2Ge from 7,7-dimethyl-l,4,5,6-tetraphenyl-2,3-benzo-7-germanorbomadiene (14) has been studied by flash photolysis, low-temperature matrix isolation and CIDNP 3H NMR techniques30. The results suggest that a biradical (15) is formed as an intermediate species in the photoreaction. The biradical is initially formed in the singlet state, which undergoes conversion to the triplet state before irreversible decomposition to form Me2Ge and tetraphenylnaphthalene (TPN) (reaction 19). 

ESR and CIDNP studies intended to detect the radical intermediates failed [63], Conjugate addition of a vinylcuprate reagent to an enone takes place with retention of the vinyl geometry indicating that no vinyl radical intermediate is involved [64, 65], Kinetic isotope effects and substituent effects in cuprate addition to benzophenone indicate that C-C bond formation is rate-determining, which is not consistent with the involvement of a radical ion pair intermediate [66]. 

Such treatment of CIDNP results produced serious objections. Lippmaa et al. (1973), investigating the same reaction, revealed a strong N, C, and CIDNP effect. The C nuclei in the phenoxyl part of the azo dye were not polarized. At the same time, polarization of N nuclei of the azo bond and C nuclei at positions 1 and 2 of the free-of-hydroxyl phenyl ring connected with... 

A study of the photo-sensitized ring-opening reactions of the radical cations (76) of arylcyclopropanes (75) with methanol, water, and cyanide nucleophiles suggests a three-electron 5k2 mechanism (Scheme 11).185 The isolated products are methyl propyl ethers, derived from nucleophilic attack of methanol on the radical cation (76). They were detected by UV-VIS spectroscopy and shown to react with nucleophiles by transient kinetic methods. The benzyl radical (77) reacts with the DCB radical anion to afford monoaromatic ether (78) by oxidation and protonation or the disubstituted ether (79) by addition of DCB. Regio- and stereo-selectivity of the substitution were complete regiochemistry and rate constant were profoundly effected by the electronic nature of the aryl substituents.186 Elsewhere, a combined ab initio and CIDNP study... 

The electron transfer reaction of gem-diarylmethylenecyclopropanes (60) with singlet sensitizers results in the exchange of the exo-methylene and the secondary cyclopropane carbons [241], The chloranil photo-sensitized reaction generates two unusual cycloaddition products (61, 62) [242], whereas the tetracyanoethylene sensitized oxygenation produces the respective dioxolanes [238]. These reactions are compatible with a ring-opened radical cation, and CIDNP experiments have... 

In summary, the existence of these three different structure types suggests a rather delicate balance between the different minima on this interesting potential energy surface. Molecular orbital calculations at the highest levels currently practical are certainly quite useful in elucidating the nature of these structures. This is also an area where one may safely predict continuing efforts and where we anticipate additional insights by both ESR and CIDNP spectroscopy. 

It would probably be useful to carry out a more detailed investigation of these reactions using ESR and CIDNP techniques. Further nitration of 2-nitroamino-5-nitrothiazole leads to 2-nitroimino-3,4,5-trinitro-3//-thiazoline [203] (Scheme 25). 

It is now well established that both CIDEP and CIDNP have their origins in the formation and removal reactions of free radicals. As a result of this, it is now possible to gain information, not normally obtained from magnetic resonance studies, for those photochemical reactions which show CIDEP and CIDNP. An example of this is those photochemical reactions in which the primary radicals react immediately to regenerate the starting compounds. The regenerated compounds may show CIDNP, and this is often the only evidence that this reaction has occurred. In the radical-pair mechanism, spin polarization is caused by the spin-selective reaction. While it is generally not possible to monitor by esr the selective reactivity of the radical pairs as a function of their nuclear spin states, CIDNP has proved to be a valuable tool to probe the small difference in reactivity of the nuclear spin states of the radical pairs. 

Based upon the current theories of CIDEP and CIDNP, we propose that in many photochemical systems the primary photochemical reaction of the excited triplet state contributes to magnetic polarization via the triplet mechanism. The secondary reaction of the polarized primary radicals may transfer their initial polarization to the "secondary radicals" provided that the radical reactions can compete with the radical spin-lattice relaxation process (59,97). On the other hand, secondary reactions of the primary radical pair or the uncorrelated F pair contribute to polarization by the radical-pair mechanism. A general scheme showing the possible and simultaneous operations of both the... 

In contrast, most of the photochemical CIDNP experiments are carried out with conventional or FT spectrometers with slow response time (T n > x > t /2) The recent efforts by Closs (37) and Barbara (21) may beat the nuclear relaxation problem and lead to quantitative measurements of the CIDEP enhancement factor. We will restrict ourselves mainly to deal with photochemical CIDEP and CIDNP experiments, although the reader should consult the excellent papers by Verma and Fessenden (124), Trifunac and Nelson (121) on radiolysis systems, and the flow technique of Lawler and Halfon (90) on thermolysis. 

In this section no attempt is made to present a comprehensive review of all the work that has been done in the magnetic polarization field. Instead, we shall emphasize those examples which illustrate the principle of CIDEP and CIDNP in photochemistry and which may be of special interest to the practicing photochemist. Interesting relationships between CIDEP and CIDNP... 

The question of whether it, it triplets of aromatic ketones have some intrinsic chemical property has been a controversial subject in organic photochemistry (130). Recently, the correlation of structure and reactivity of some excited triplet biphenyl ketones was approached by a combined esr, CIDEP, and CIDNP study (129). The low-temperature esr confirmed the assignment of the ir, ir triplet as the lowest triplet state in these biphenyl ketones. 

---