Alkyl cations, hardness

Cyclic ethers, acetals and cyclic amines belong to the group of hard bases while cyclic sulfides can be considered as soft bases. On the other hand proton is the hardest acid whereas alkyl cations are much softer. Thus, in good agreement with the concept of hard and soft acids and bases (the alike ones react faster giving more stable products), secondary oxonium ions react slower with monomer than their tertiary oxonium counterparts. The same is observed for cyclic amines whereas secondary sulfonium ions apparently react faster with cyclic sulfides than the corresponding tertiary sulfonium ions do l. 

In the gas phase, alkylation of five-membered heterocycles by alkyl cations usually occurs via the usual addition-elimination mechanism of aromatic electrophilic substitution. The phenyl cation behaves differently, however although its substrate discrimination is limited, in accord with its exceedingly high reactivity, it has marked selectivity for the a position, which does not conform with the hard character of this cation. It has, therefore, been suggested that an electron-transfer mechanism is followed this is thermodynamically allowed for the phenylium, and likewise for the methyl cation, but not for other alkyl cations (Scheme 28). This SET mechanism applies also for acyl cations [87]. 

Harding and his co-workers have shown that polyene cyclization termination by y-allenes proceeds exclusively via a six-membered ring vinylic cation rather than the alternative five-membered ring alkylic cation (Scheme 23). Johnson et... 

The solubihty characteristics of sodium acyl isethionates allow them to be used in synthetic detergent (syndet) bars. Complex blends of an isethionate and various soaps, free fatty acids, and small amounts of other surfactants reportedly are essentially nonirritant skin cleansers (66). As a rule, the more detersive surfactants, for example alkyl sulfates, a-olefin sulfonates, and alkylaryl sulfonates, are used in limited amounts in skin cleansers. Most skin cleansers are compounded to leave an emollient residue on the skin after rinsing with water. Free fatty acids, alkyl betaines, and some compatible cationic or quaternary compounds have been found to be especially useful. A mildly acidic environment on the skin helps control the growth of resident microbial species. Detergent-based skin cleansers can be formulated with abrasives to remove scaly or hard-to-remove materials from the skin. 

The proportion of C-alkylation increases in the order OTs < Br < I, a sequence which is often associated with the balance of hardness between nucleophile and nucleofuge (Smith and Hanson, 1971). The work of Kurts et al. (1974) indicates that the overall reaction rate of the crown ether-assisted alkylation increases in the order Na+ < K+ < Rb+ < Cs+, which, according to these authors, reflects the increasing distance between cation and anion in the ion pairs. The high reactivity of the tetraphenylarsenate also fits in with this picture. The decrease of the kc/k0 ratio is only small in good cation-solvating solvents such as dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Alkylation of the sodium derivative of [103] with ethyl iodide in DMSO gave kc/kQ = 15.7 addition of... 

The ammonium catalyst can also influence the reaction path and higher yields of the desired product may result, as the side reactions are eliminated. In some cases, the structure of the quaternary ammonium cation may control the product ratio with potentially tautomeric systems as, for example, with the alkylation of 2-naph-thol under basic conditions. The use of tetramethylammonium bromide leads to predominant C-alkylation at the 1-position, as a result of the strong ion-pair binding of the hard quaternary ammonium cation with the hard oxy anion, whereas with the more bulky tetra-n-butylammonium bromide O-alkylation occurs, as the binding between the cation and the oxygen centre is weaker [11], Similar effects have been observed in the alkylation of methylene ketones [e.g. 12, 13]. The stereochemistry of the Darzen s reaction and of the base-initiated formation of cyclopropanes under two-phase conditions is influenced by the presence or absence of quaternary ammonium salts [e.g. 14], whereas chiral quaternary ammonium salts are capable of influencing the enantioselectivity of several nucleophilic reactions (Chapter 12). 

The interfacial mechanism provides an acceptable explanation for the effect of the more lipophilic quaternary ammonium salts, such as tetra-n-butylammonium salts, Aliquat 336 and Adogen 464, on the majority of base-initiated nucleophilic substitution reactions which require the initial deprotonation of the substrate. Subsequent to the interfacial deprotonation of the methylene system, for example the soft quaternary ammonium cation preferentially forms a stable ion-pair with the soft carbanion, rather than with the hard hydroxide anion (Scheme 1.8). Strong evidence for the competing interface mechanism comes from the observation that, even in the absence of a catalyst, phenylacetonitrile is alkylated under two-phase conditions using concentrated sodium hydroxide [51],... 

These observations have been interpreted in terms of the hard-soft acid-base theory (77CJC4112), in which the salts of the harder cations, such as the Li+ ion, lead to C-alkylation, whilst the salts of the soft cations, such as the quaternary ammonium salts, are TV-alkylated. This interpretation is particularly relevant in understanding the reactivity of the heteroaryl-magnesium salts. The Mg2+ ion is a harder cation than the Li+ ion and, with the more strongly associated Grignard compounds, C-alkylation predominates. Generally, the pyrrole... 

Enolate ions, which are usually strong nucleophiles, are more important in preparative applications than are the enols. In additions to carbonyl groups, the carbon end, rather than the oxygen end, attacks but in SA,2 substitutions on alkyl halides, significant amounts of O-alkylation occur. The more acidic compounds, such as those with the j3-dicarbonyl structure, yield enolates with the greater tendency toward O-alkylation. Protic solvents and small cations favor C-alkylation, because the harder oxygen base of the enolate coordinates more strongly than does the carbon with these hard Lewis acids.147... 

There are various types of organic proton exchangers (34, 35, 38). Diesters of phosphoric acid, (RO)2P = 0(0H), phosphonic acids, R(RO)P = 0(0H), and phos-phinic acids, R2P = 0(0H), where R represents linear or branched alkyl or phenyl substituents, are the most common cation exchangers developed in liquid-liquid extraction for the extraction of trivalent 4/and 5/elements. They were initially developed for the American TALSPEAK and the Japanese DIDPA processes and have recently been introduced in the French DIAMEX-SANEX process. As for previously described NOPCs, these organophosphorus acids present oxygen-donor atoms (hard bases) in their structures and therefore will easily coordinate trivalent lanthanide and actinide cations, but they will not allow complete discrimination of the two families of elements. However, contrary to previously described neutral organophosphorus... 

The comparison of CMC data in distilled vs. hard river water shows that the decrease in CMC with hardness has the order anionics cationics nonionics (Rosen et al., 1996). Hardness increases the dependence of the CMC on alkyl carbon chain length of CnE0mS04, indicating that in hard water the influence of additional carbon atoms is the same for CnE0mS04 as for CnEOm surfactants (Rosen et al., 1996). The influence of ionic strength on micellization of nonionic surfactants is due to a salting out effect of the hydro-phobic moiety of the surfactant molecule (Carala et al., 1994). 

Pyridone is O-alkylated more readily than normal amides, because the resulting products are aromatic. With soft electrophiles, however, clean N-alkylations can be performed (Scheme 1.7). The Mitsunobu reaction, on the other hand, leads either to mixtures of N- and O-alkylated products or to O-alkylation exclusively, probably because of the hard, carbocation-like character of the intermediate alkoxyphosphonium cations. Electrophilic rhodium carbene complexes also preferentially alkylate the oxygen atom of 2-pyridone or other lactams [20] (Scheme 1.7). 

The O-alkylation of carboxylates is a useful alternative to the acid-catalyzed esterification of carboxylic acids with alcohols. Carboxylates are weak, hard nucleophiles which are alkylated quickly by carbocations and by highly reactive, carbocation-like electrophiles (e.g. trityl or some benzhydryl halides). Suitable procedures include treatment of carboxylic acids with alcohols under the conditions of the Mitsunobu reaction [122], or with diazoalkanes. With soft electrophiles, such as alkyl iodides, alkylation of carboxylic acid salts proceeds more slowly, but in polar aprotic solvents, such as DMF, or with non-coordinating cations acceptable rates can still be achieved. Alkylating agents with a high tendency to O-alkylate carboxylates include a-halo ketones [42], dimethyl sulfate [100,123], and benzyl halides (Scheme 6.31). 

---