Total reflux columns

7 APPLICABILITY OF RCMs TO CONTINUOUS PROCESSES 2.7.1 Total Reflux Columns 

FKiURK 2.11 Total reflux distillation column. Packing segment of height Az shown, with associated flows and compositions as indicated. 

X is the composition of the liquid, as a function of position, y is the composition of the vapor, as a function of position, and Az is an arbitrarily chosen packing height, or change in position (m). 

In a total reflux column, all the vapor leaving the top of the column is completely condensed and then returned to the column. Similarly, all the liquid at the bottom of the column is completely vaporized and sent back to the column. Thus, there are no products from the column, and hence no feed is required. It is obvious then that such a column has no practical use. However, as will be shown here, analysis of this column gives great insight into both inflnite and finite reflux operation. 

A material balance around the boundary labeled 1 gives 

---

For more than two species and a reflux ratio set to 1.2 times the minimum, a rule of thumb is to compute the total number of trays required for a total reflux column to produce the separation desired and then double this number as a first guess (Douglas, 1988). The next decision is select the tray on which to feed the column. For multispecies columns, the placement is not obvious. Typically, one must search by placing it on any one of a range of trays using a tray-by-tray simulation, thereby discovering which tray location requires the least reflux to effect the desired separation. 

It will become evident in the mathematical derivation that the feed location in a total reflux column is immaterial. Hence, although the model is developed for... 

The feed stream defined below is to be separated in a distillation column between propane and n-butane. Based on the total-reflux column model, calculate the number of stages and products rates and compositions if it is desired to have in the bottoms 10 kmol/h propane and 360 kmol/h n-butane. The relative volatility values provided may be assumed constant. (Ref Example 12.2)... 

This is a remarkable result it is showing that a certain type of continuous column can be modeled exactly using a simple batch experiment. In other words, the exact trajectory mapped out when boiling a liquid of a certain mixture is exactly the same path followed by the liquid down a continuously operated total reflux column. 

Although an infinite reflux column is still impractical, it does have feed and product streams associated with it. Thus, unlike the total reflux column, the infinite reflux column has an external mass balance. The mass balance is for the column shown in Figure 1.1 is very simple, and can be summarized as... 

Having established that there are topological similarities between CPMs and RCMs, it is of interest to determine what the exact relationship between the two is. In Section 2.6.2, it was shown that a liquid profile in a total reflux column follows a residue curve exactly, and that the liquid composition in an infinite reflux column will sufficiently approximate a residue curve too. Thus, it should come as no surprise then that when taking the limit in the DPE such that we observe that the DPE... 

Equation 9.12 implies that both flows and compositions are the same at the top of the MCS. This is equivalent to describing a total reflux column, and also sufficiently expresses an infinite reflux column, as discussed by Peters et al. [13]. Refer to Chapter 2 (Section 2.6) for the equivalent discussions on total and infinite reflux in simple distillation columns. 

It will become evident in the mathematical derivation that the feed location in a total reflux column is immaterial. Hence, although the model is developed for a single feed, multiple feeds can be handled just as well, as long as they are not intended to serve as external reflux or stripping streams. The model may be extended to simulate multiple product columns as described in Section 12.1.5. 

Beyond certain limits increase of the reflux ratio does not appreciably increase the separating power or efficiency of the column. As a rough guide, if the column has an efficiency of n plates at total reflux, the reflux ratio should be between 2>t/3 and 3n/2. 

FIG. 13-37 McCabe-Thiele diagrams for limiting cases, a) Minimum stages for a column operating at total reflux with no feeds or products, (h) Minimum reflux for a binary system of normal volatility. 

Equations (13-31) and (13-32) are rigorous relationships between the splits obtained for components i and r in a column at total reflux. However, the correct value of Ot must always be estimated, and this is where the approximation enters. It is usually estimated from... 

In operation, a batch of liquid is charged to the pot and the system is first brought to steady state under total reflux. A portion of the overhead condensate is then continuously withdrawn in accordance with the established reflux pohcy. Cuts are made by switching to alternate receivers, at which time operating conditions may be altered. The entire column operates as an enriching section. As time proceeds, composition of the material being distilled becomes less rich in the more volatile components, and distillation of a cut is stopped when accumulated distillate attains the desired average composition. 

Other control methods. A cychng procedure can be used to set the pattern for column operation. The unit operates at total reflux until equilibrium is established. Distillate is then taken as total draw-... 

Direct Scale-Up of Laboratory Distillation Ljficiency Measurements It has been found by Fair, Null, and Bolles [Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev., 22, 53 (1983)] that efficiency measurements in 25- and 50-mm (1- and 2-in-) diameter laboratory Oldersbaw columns closely approach tbe point efficiencies [Eq. (14-129)] measured in large sieve-plate columns. A representative comparison of scales of operation is shown in Fig. 14-37. Note that in order to achieve agreement between efficiencies it is necessaiy to ensure that (1) tbe systems being distilled are tbe same, (2) comparison is made at tbe same relative approach to tbe flood point, (3) operation is at total reflux, and (4) a standard Oldersbaw device (a small perforated-plate column with downcomers) is used in tbe laboratoiy experimentation. Fair et al. made careful comparisons for several systems, utibzing as large-scale information tbe published efficiency studies of Fractionation Research, Inc. 

FIG. 14-47 Efficiency characteristics of packed columns (total-reflux distillation.)... 

For total-reflux distillations carried out in packed columns, regions of loading and flooding are identified by their effects on mass-transfer efficiency, as shown in Fig. 14-47. Gas and liquid rate increase... 

FIG. 14-62 Comp arisen of composition profiles at different bed freights and two sizes of ceramic rascfiig rings. Column diameter =1.2 m, eyelofiexane/ n-fieptane system at 1,65 bar and total reflux, [Silvey and KaUet- I, Chem, E, Synrp, Ser, No, 32, 2.96.9,]... 

FK . 14-63 Efficiency of beds of 51 mm Pali rings with two different distributors. Column diameter =1.2 m, cyclohexane/n-heptane system at 1.65 bar and total reflux. [Shariat and Kunesh, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 34 1273 (1995).] Reproduced with permission. Copyright 1995, American Chemical Society. 

FIG. 14-74 HETP values for Max-Pak structured packing,. 35 kPa (5 psia), two column diameters. Cyclohexane/n-heptane system, total reflux. For 0.4.3 m (1.4 ft) column perforated pipe distributor, 400 streams/m2, 3.05 m (10 ft) bed height. For 1.2 m (4.0 ft) column tubed drip pan distributor, 100 streams/m ,. 3.7 m (12 ft) bed height. Smaller column data. University of Texas/Austin Larger column data. Fractionation Research, Inc. To convert (ft/s)(lb/ft ) to (m/s)(kg/m ) , multiply by 1.2199. (Couiiesy Jaeger Troducts, Inc., Housion, Texas.)... 

Colburn relationship found that the optimum number of trays varies from 2 to 3 times the number at total reflux. Gilliland [Ind. Eng. Chem, . 32, 1220 (1940)] from the establishment of an empirical relationship between reflux ratio and theoretical trays based on a study of existing columns indicated that... 

The dominant mechanism of purification for column ciystallization of sohd-solution systems is reciystallization. The rate of mass transfer resulting from reciystallization is related to the concentrations of the solid phase and free hquid which are in intimate contac t. A model based on height-of-transfer-unit (HTU) concepts representing the composition profQe in the purification sec tion for the high-melting component of a binaiy solid-solution system has been reported by Powers et al. (in Zief and Wilcox, op. cit., p. 363) for total-reflux operation. Typical data for the purification of a solid-solution system, azobenzene-stilbene, are shown in Fig. 22-10. The column ciystallizer was operated... 

FIG. 22-10 Steady-state separation of azobenzene and stilbene in a center-fed column crystallizer with total-reflux operation. To convert centimeters to inches, multiply by 0.3937. (Zief and Wilcox, Fractional Solidification, vol. 1, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1967, p. 356.)... 

Methyl trichlorosilane [75-79-6] M 149.5, b 13,7 /101mm, 64.3 /710.8mm, 65.5 /745mm, 66.1 /atm, d 1.263, n 1.4110. If very pure distil before use. Purity checked by Si nmr, 6 in MeCN is 13.14 with respect to Me4Si. Possible contaminants are other silanes which can be removed by fractional distillation through a Stedman column of >72 theoretical plates with total reflux and 0.35% take-off (see p. 441). The apparatus is under N2 at a rate of 12 bubbles/min fed into the line using an Hg manometer to control the pressure. Sensitive to H2O. [J Am Chem Soc 73 4252 7957 J Org Chem 48 3667 7955.]... 

N,n = Minimum theoretical stages at total reflux Q = Heat transferred, Btu/hr U - Overall heat transfer coefficient, Btu/hrfP"F u = Vapor velocity, ft/sec U d = Velocity under downcomer, ft/sec VD(js = Downcomer design velocity, GPM/fL Vioad = Column vapor load factor W = Condensate rate, Ibs/hr Xhk = Mol fraction of heavy key component Xlk = Mol fraction of the light key component a, = Relative volatility of component i versus the heavy key component... 

A small amount of dimethylamine is always present in the crude product. This is removed before collection of the product by operating the column under total reflux for 1-2 hours. The vent of the still head should be connected to a hood during this operation. If foaming does not subside after this treatment the use of a 1-1. still pot is indicated. 

---