Theorell-Chance mechanism products

Different abortives may be formed with alternative products or substrates. Such procedures can be useful in helping to distinguish Theorell-Chance mechanisms from ordered systems with abortive complexes . In the case of lactate dehydrogenase, the E-pyruvate-NAD+ and E-lactate-NADH abortive complexes may play a regulatory roles in aerobic versus anaerobic metabolism. 

Rate experiments that are typically carried out in the presence of different concentrations of an alternative product (or product analog) while using the normal substrates . This approach can be particularly useful when the normal product cannot be used because it is unstable, insoluble, or ineffective (the latter indicated by a very high Ki value). Moreover, the normal product may be consumed as an essential substrate in a coupled assay system for the primary enzyme. Fromm and Zewe used the alternative product inhibition approach in their study of hexokinase. Wratten and Cleland later applied this procedure to exclude the Theorell-Chance mechanism for liver alcohol dehydrogenase. See Abortive Complexes... 

As pointed out previously in this review the steady-state kinetics of mitochondrial transhydrogenase, earlier interpreted to indicate a ternary Theorell-Chance mechanism on the basis of competitive relationships between NAD and NADH and between NADP and NADPH, and noncompetitive relationships between NAD" and NADP" and between NADH and NADPH, has been reinterpreted in the light of more recent developments in the interpretation of steady-state kinetic data. Thus, although the product inhibition patterns obtained in the earlier reports [75-77] using submitochondrial particles were close to identical to those obtained in a more recent report [90] using purified and reconstituted transhydrogenase, the reinterpretation favors a random mechanism with the two dead-end complexes NAD E NADP and NADH E NADPH. A random mechanism is also supported by the observation that the transhydrogenase binds to immobilized NAD as well as NADP [105] in the absence of the second substrate. 

In the presence of activator, pyruvate, the substrate saturation curves of the R. ruhrum ADP-Glc PPase are hyperbolic at low temperatures. Using kinetic studies its reaction mechanism was studied. The product inhibition patterns eliminated all known sequential mechanisms except the ordered BiBi or Theorell—Chance mechanisms. Small intercept effects suggested the existence of significant concentrations of central transis-tory complexes. Kinetic constants obtained in the study also favored the ordered BiBi mechanism. In addition studies using ATP-[ P]-pyrophosphate isotope exchange at equilibrium supported a sequential-ordered mechanism, which indicated that ATP is the first substrate to bind and that ADP-Glc is the last product to... 

From these and the corresponding, symmetrically related parameters for the reverse direction of reaction it may be seen that, as one would expect, all the relationships listed above for the more general case also apply to the Theorell-Chance mechanism. It does, however, have some diagnostic tests that are uniquely its own. First, not only, as before, is independent of the nature of B, but now also < o> d therefore the maximum rate, is independent of B. This is because in the Theorell-Chance mechanism the maximum rate is determined solely by the rate of dissociation of the outer product, P. It has been shown, for instance, that horse liver alcohol dehydrogenase gives essentially the same maximum rate for a series of primary alcohols [44] and this may be equated with the rate of dissociation of NADH. Conversely, of course, is independent of the nature of Q. From Eqn. 21, which is still obeyed, one may now see that the Dalziel maximum-rate relationships become equalities for the Theorell-Chance mechanism ... 

The product inhibition patterns in the Theorell-Chance mechanism are different from those of the Ordered Bi Bi mechanism. Note that the product inhibition equations are symmetrical Equations (9.34) and (9.38) are symmetrical and so are Eqs. (9.35) and (9.37). Thus, product inhibition studies only identify A-Q and B-P pairs and do not reveal the order of substrate addition and product release. 

Thus, for a simple Ordered Bi Bi mechanism, the above ratios are always greater than unity. Values close to unity indicate that the dissociation of the product Q or a substrate A (usually the coenzymes with dehydrogenases) determines the maximum rate, that is, a Theorell-Chance mechanism. The values much greater than unity are inconsistent with a simple ordered mechanism, and suggest an isomerization of the enzyme-substrate complexes. 

A system for describing kinetic mechanisms for enzyme-catalyzed reactions . Reactants (ie., substrates) are symbolized by the letters A, B, C, D, eto., whereas products are designated by P, Q, R, S, etc. Reaction schemes are also identified by the number of substrates and products utilized (i.e.. Uni (for one), Bi (two), Ter (three occasionally Tri), Quad (four), Quin (five), etc. Thus, a two-substrate, three-product enzyme-catalyzed reaction would be a Bi Ter system. In addition, reaction schemes are identified by the pattern of substrate addition to the enzyme s active site as well as the release of products. For a two-substrate, one-product scheme in which either substrate can bind to the free enzyme, the enzyme scheme is designated a random Bi Uni mechanism. If the substrates bind in a distinct order (note that, in such cases, A binds before B for ordered multiproduct release, P is released prior to Q, etc.), the scheme would be ordered Bi Uni. If the binding scheme is different than the release of product, then that information should also be provided for example, a two-substrate, two-product reaction in which the substrates bind to the enzyme in an ordered fashion whereas the products are released randomly would be designated ordered on, random off Bi Bi scheme. If one or more Theorell-Chance steps are present, that information is also given (e.g., ordered Bi Bi-(Theorell-Chance)), with the prefixes included if there is more than one Theorell-Chance step. 

A sequential enzyme-catalyzed binding mechanism for a two substrate-two product system in which substrates A and B have to bind in a certain order but either P or Q can be released in a Theorell-Chance step upon the binding of B. Following this step, the other substrate is... 

A two-substrate, two-product enzyme-catalyzed reaction scheme in which either substrate, A or B, can bind first. However, the second substrate participates in a Theorell-Chance step in which either one of the two products is released. See Multisubstrate Mechanisms... 

Theorell-Chance This special case of the ordered bi-bi mechanism occurs if the first product P dissociates from the enzyme very rapidly and an EAB-, EPQ-complex does not occur in a significant concentration. (Example alcohol-dehydrogenase)... 

The main value of product inhibition studies of dehydrogenases has been to distinguish between ordered and random mechanisms and to provide additional kinetic estimates of the dissociation constants of enzyme-coenzyme compounds. On both counts the method has been especially useful for reactions that are essentially irreversible or for other reasons cannot be studied in both directions 122,138). It is also in such circumstances that product inhibition studies are most reliable because, as Alberty (7) emphasized when proposing the method, with readily reversible reactions it may be difficult to estimate true initial rates with small concentrations of substrates in the presence of a product. The reality of ternary complexes in an ordered mechanism of the Theorell-Chance type has also been demonstrated with several enzymes (134) by product inhibition studies. 

Such mechanisms are sequential and proceed through an EABC complex. The ABC term is always present except in a Theorell-Chance type of mechanism in which the reaction of the third substrate to add results in such a rapid reaction and release of products, that V appears infinite. 

Chance (1943) and Theorell Chance (1951) observed the formation and decomposition of complexes of enzymes with substrates and products by following changes in light absorption. In these pioneering studies the theories and techniques of pre-steady-state kinetics were only applied to reactions in which the complexes had distinct absorption spectra. It became apparent that transients of a much wider range of enzyme reactions could be studied when the initial rate of product formation is analysed (Gut-freund, 1955). Observations with a time resolution of milliseconds showed that there are often three distinct phases in product formation. These are determined in turn by the rate of formation of the enzyme-substrate complex, the enzyme-product complex and of free product. Of course, as we shall see, the most fruitful investigations into enzyme mechanisms resulted when it was possible to combine the observation of transients of product formation with those of spectral changes of complexes. 

The classical steady-state studies of Theorell and Chance showed that the increased affinity for substrate by the NADH-bound enzyme leads to a distinct sequence of the binding of coenzyme and substrate and subsequent reaction.1442. The binding of coenzyme is a compulsory step prior to substrate binding. Release of products from the enzyme site occurs via reversal of the sequence. This mechanism, known as an ordered bi-bi mechanism because of the required order of association and dissociation of the coenzyme and substrate with ternary complex formation is summarized in Scheme 6, where E, S and P represent enzyme, substrate and product respectively. 

Early evidence for the sequential mechanism proposed by Theorell and Chance 332) has been reviewed in a previous chapter on LADH (1). The requirements of this mechanism are satisfied under certain conditions for primary alcohols and aldehydes but not for secondary alcohols 295,322,333-336). Thus, the first step is the binding of the coenzyme and the last and rate limiting step dissociation of the coenzyme. Formation of the productive ternary complexes E NAD Alc and E NADH Ald have been demonstrated 333,334,337-339). The interconversion of these complexes are not kinetically important for the above-mentioned conditions as required by the mechanism. It has been suggested, however, that this step is rate limiting during different conditions 324,336). Substrate dissociation constants for the ternary complexes have been estimated 340). 

---