The Structural Approach

Our approach to understanding the role of the hydrogen bond in determining the three-dimensional structure of molecular shapes and interactions in biological systems is analogous to the modern meaning of epidemiology. That is, the prediction of the most probable behavior by means of surveys of the behavior of similar species, or the same species in different habitats. 

With this concept in mind, we have analyzed the metrical properties and pattern characteristics of the hydrogen bonds in terms of the types of molecules involved, rather than survey a type of bond in a variety of different molecules. 

Hydrogen-bonding metrics and patterns are characteristic properties of molecules. It is by no means certain that a )NH 0=C bond will have exactly the same metrical properties when it occurs in a peptide, a barbiturate, and a nucleoside. In fact, as will be shown later, there are small, but significant, differences in these metrical properties. There are also differences in the pattern characteristics. The patterns that are observed in the crystal structures of these various types of small biological molecules provide a portfolio of observed hydrogen bond structures. These can be used as models for interpretations of structure and for hypotheses concerning intermolecular interactions in those situations where direct observation of the position of the hydrogen atom is experimentally impossible. 

As will become apparent in the later chapters, the statistical nature of the conclusions is such that the present amount of data in the crystallographic data base is inadequate. We find ourselves presenting results that show well-defined trends, but in doing so, have come to realize that we need a tenfold increase in the information from X-ray and neutron crystallography before the conclusions drawn can become really definitive. This tenfold increase in structural data will surely come within the next decade, and will be useful only if the publication, data storage, and retrieval mechanisms keep pace with the accelerating rate of data acquisition. 

We are cognizant that the structural data on hydrogen bonds derived from crystal structure analyses refer particularly to the hydrogen bond in the solid state. These data are subject to crystal field effects caused by other intermolecular forces. Just as with any discussion of covalent or ionic bonds observed in crystals, these crystal field effects have to be taken into consideration when extrapolating from the precise data available from the crystalline state to the imprecise data that applies to the liquid state in which most chemical and biochemical reactions take place. 

To this point this account of instances of concomitant polymorphs has been phenomenological. We have discussed the thermodynamic and kinetic crystallization of polymorphs. There is still the question if any insight concerning controlling the polymorph obtained can be gained from the study of the crystal structure of concomitantly crystallized polymorphs. A qualitative attempt was made to see if details of the 

It is of interest to note that another similar squarylium dye 3-XXV has also been shown to concomitantly crystallize in a green monoclinic phase and a purple triclinic phase (Ashwell etal 1996). The structurehas been reported for the former, but crystals of the latter were not of sufficient quality to determine the crystal stmcture. 3-XXV 

These studies suggest the existence of similar aggregates leading to the different polymorphs, as a function of thermodynamic and kinetic conditions, as investigated recently by Wojtyk et al. (1999). 

---

The primaiy oojective of the structured approach is to separate cleanly the following two aspects of the batch logic ... 

Elemental phosphorus itself exists in several polymeric forms. If the white allotropic form, which consists of P4 tetrahedral molecules, is put under high pressure, preferably at elevated temperatures, it can be catalytically converted to other modifications.41 It first becomes red, then violet, then black as the degree of polymerization increases. These materials are very difficult to characterize because of branching and the formation of cyclics. In the extreme limit, the structure approaches that of graphite, and shows good electrical conductivity.42 No evidence exists at all for the formation of high-molecular-weight, linear chains of elemental phosphorus. 

S. Iijima (NEC Corporation, Japan). I used molecular mechanics to optimize the geometry of giant fullerenes up to C960. Contrary to Professor Kroto s observation, as we optimize the structure approaches a sphere, so the strain is apparently distributed throughout the molecule. 

Pyshnograi GV (1996) An initial approximation in the theory of viscoelasticity of linear polymers and non-linear effects. J Appl Mech Techn Phys 37(1) 123—128 Pyshnograi GV (1997) The structure approach in the theory of flow of solutions and melts of linear polymers. J Appl Mech Techn Phys 38(3) 122—130 Pyshnograi GV, Pokrovskii VN (1988) Stress dependence of stationary shear viscosity of linear polymers in the molecular field theory. Polym Sci USSR 30 2624—2629 Pyshnograi GV, Pokrovskii VN, Yanovsky YuG, Karnet YuN, Obraztsov IF (1994) Constitutive equation on non-linear viscoelastic (polymer) media in zeroth approximation by parameter of molecular theory and conclusions for shear and extension. Phys — Doklady 39(12) 889-892... 

The structural approach to ion-solvent interactions has been developed so far by considering that the electrical equivalent of a water molecule is an idealized dipole, i.e., two charges of equal magnitude but opposite sign separated by a certain distance. Is this an adequate representation of the charge distribution in a water molecule ... 

The structured approach helps develop skills in ontlcal thinking, creative thinking, and problem-solving, by employing open-ended questions and stressing the Socratic method. 

The information needed about the chemical kinetics of a reaction system is best determined in terms of the structure of general classes of such systems. By structure we mean quahtative and quantitative features that are common to large well-defined classes of systems. For the classes of complex reaction systems to be discussed in detail in this article, the structural approach leads to two related but independent results. First, descriptive models and analyses are developed that create a sound basis for understanding the macroscopic behavior of complex as well as simple dynamic systems. Second, these descriptive models and the procedures obtained from them lead to a new and powerful method for determining the rate parameters from experimental data. The structural analysis is best approached by a geometrical interpretation of the behavior of the reaction system. Such a description can be readily visualized. 

The structural approach will also contribute to the analysis of the thermodynamics of nonequilibrium systems. It is the aim and purpose of thermod5mamics to describe structural features of systems in terms of macroscopic variables. Unfortunately, classical thermodynamics is concerned almost entirely with the equilibrium state it makes only weak statements about nonequilibrium systems. The nonequihbrium thermodynamics of Onsager (f), Prigogine (2), and others introduces additional axioms into classical thermodynamics in an attempt to obtain stronger and more useful statements about nonequilibrium systems. These axioms lead, however, to an expression for the driving force of chemical reactions that does not agree with experience and that is only applicable, as an approximation, to small departures from equilibrium. A way in which this situation may be improved is outlined in Section VII. 

The structured approach of the Working Method is inherent in the Spider Diagram, phase I, which can be extended to more advanced species. Phase II and particularly, phase III, to the factual descriptive main group or transition metal chemistry of the elements. 

The performance of systematic risk assessments is a task often taken by federal agencies like US EPA, US FDA, EU EFSA or national institutions. The result of a risk assessment is a starting point for the risk manager, e.g., the ministries, to develop adequate measures, like controls, limits or use restrictions. In the structured approach to the risk analysis the precautionary principle can be particularly relevant to the risk management. It shall be applied in those circumstances where scientific evidence is insufficient or imcertain and when there are indications for concern [95]. In order to prevent a disproportionately intensive use measures based on the precautionary principle should be... 

The Table illustrates that the moments of inertia vary smoothly as the coordinate is traversed, and that an approximately spherical distribution of ligands is maintained, since lx + Iy + Iz deviates little from 5 for all intermediate structures. As the structures approach the transition states the sum of the moments of inertia deviates most from 5, which reflects the fact that the transition states are less symmetric than the initial trigonal bipyramid. Figure 15 illustrates the approximate coplanarity of the points. 

---