Symmetry concept

An interesting approach to both enantiomers of biologically active cyclo-phellitol, based on the latent symmetry concept, from the same common starting material D-xylose was proposed by Kireev et. al. Functionalization of this monosaccharide at the C-l provided compound 64, while similar processes initiated from the end (C5) afforded the ent-64 (Fig. 23).36 Proper functionalization of these intermediates led to both enantiomers of cyclophellitol. 

This chapter consists of the application of the symmetry concepts of Chapter 2 to the construction of molecular orbitals for a range of diatomic molecules. The principles of molecular orbital theory are developed in the discussion of the bonding of the simplest molecular species, the one-electron dihydrogen molecule-ion, H2+, and the simplest molecule, the two-electron dihydrogen molecule. Valence bond theory is introduced and compared with molecular orbital theory. The photo-electron spectrum of the dihydrogen molecule is described and interpreted. 

The symmetry concepts of Chapter 2 and those of molecular orbital theory were applied to the construction of molecular orbitals for a range of diatomic molecules. 

A number of investigations have previously been carried out to elucidate the spectroscopy and dynamics of CHD. Experimental investigations [2-7] have been paired with quantum chemical calculations [8-11], to refine the orbital symmetry concepts developed by Woodward and Hoffman, and van der Lugt and Osterhoff [12]. However, a direct and unambiguous experimental study regarding the timescales involved in the curve-crossing from the initially excited state to the ground state, for isolated molecules in the gas phase, is not yet available. 

Symmetry concepts come about in physics in two ways. First, since any physical process occurs in a real space, we have to make use of one or another coordinate system. The isotropy and homogeneity of space make physically meaningful only those mathematical relationships that remain unchanged under rotations of the axes of the coordinate system, and that impose fairly rigorous constraints on the possible physical laws. Second, every physical object and process features a symmetry which should be taken into account by the physical theory. 

For quasirigid molecules a symmetry concept has been used very early in some branches of molecular research, e.g. stereochemistry2,3 This symmetry concept was based on the concept of isometric mappings4) and formed the basis of extended applications to molecular dynamics since 1930, developed first by Wigner5). 

Although the multi-chain dynamical symmetries concept of the IBM is successful in anchoring the various types of collective structures, the full microscopic justification for each chain is still not entirely transparent. Thus, on a purely theoretical level, we deem it important to know whether the multi-chain dynamical symmetries of the IBM are ... 

The various experimental tools that are utilized today to solve structural problems in chemistry, such as Raman, infrared, NMR, magnetic measurements and the diffraction methods (electron, X-ray, and neutron), are based on symmetry considerations. Consequently, the symmetry concept as applied to molecules is thus very important. 

To illustrate how symmetry concepts are applied to molecules, several examples will be considered. 

The above examples illustrate that we like to consider symmetry in a broader sense than how it just appears in geometry. The symmetry concept provides a good opportunity to widen our horizons and to bring chemistry closer to other fields of human activities. An interesting aspect of the relationship of chemistry with other fields was expressed by Vladimir Prelog in his Nobel lecture [4] ... 

Chemical symmetry has been noted and investigated for centuries in crystallography which is at the border between chemistry and physics. It was more physics when crystal morphology and other properties of the crystal were described. It was more chemistry when the inner structure of the crystal and the interactions between its building units were considered. Later, descriptions of molecular vibrations and the establishment of selection rules and other basic principles happened in all kinds of spectroscopy. This led to another uniquely important place for the symmetry concept in chemistry with practical implications. 

The discovery of handedness, or chirality, in crystals and molecules brought the symmetry concept nearer to the chemical laboratory. All this, however, concerned more the stereochemist, the structural chemist, the crystallographer, and the spectroscopist rather than the synthetic chemist. Symmetry used to be considered to lose its significance as soon as the molecules entered the chemical reaction. Orbital theory and the discovery of the conservation of orbital symmetry have encompassed even this area. It was signified by the 1981 Nobel Prize in chemistry awarded to Kenichi Fukui and Roald Hoffmann (Figure 1-1) for their theories, developed independently, concerning the course of chemical reactions [6],... 

During the past half a century, fundamental scientific discoveries have been aided by the symmetry concept. They have played a role in the continuing quest for establishing the system of fundamental particles [7], It is an area where symmetry breaking has played as important a role as symmetry. The most important biological discovery since Darwin s theory of evolution was the double helical structure of the matter of heredity, DNA, by Francis Crick and James D. Watson (Figure 1-2) [8], In addition to the translational symmetry of helices (see, Chapter 8), the molecular structure of deoxyribonucleic acid as a whole has C2 rotational symmetry in accordance with the complementary nature of its two antiparallel strands [9], The discovery of the double helix was as much a chemical discovery as it was important for biology, and lately, for the biomedical sciences. 

The term antisymmetry has occurred several times above, and it is a whole new idea in our discussion. It is again a point where chemistry and other fields meet in a uniquely important symmetry concept. 

Gay-Lussac (1778-1850) wrote in 1809 We are perhaps not far removed from the time when we shall be able to submit the bulk of chemical phenomena to calculaton [31], One hundred and ten years later, in 1998, John Pople shared the Nobel Prize in Chemistry for his development of computational methods in chemistry, with Walter Kohn (in his case, for his development of the density-functional theory ), Figure 6-33. So even if Gay-Lussac was, perhaps, somewhat too optimistic, eventually his dreams came true—the development of computational chemistry has been amazing. Quantum chemistry is not a topic of this book, we are only mentioning it briefly because of its inherent relationship to the symmetry concept. For discussion of the topic we refer the reader to a few of the available monographs [32-36],... 

As crystallography is becoming more general, transforming itself into the science of structures, so may we anticipate a broadening application of the symmetry concept in the description and understanding of all possible structures [156],... 

It is gratifying to launch the third edition of our book. Its coming to life testifies about the task it has fulfilled in the service of the community of chemical research and learning. As we noted in the Prefaces to the first and second editions, our book surveys chemistry from the point of view of symmetry. We present many examples from chemistry as well as from other fields to emphasize the unifying nature of the symmetry concept. Our aim has been to provide aesthetic pleasure in addition to learning experience. In our first Preface we paid tribute to two books in particular from which we learned a great deal they have influenced significantly our approach to the subject matter of our book. They are Weyl s classic, Symmetry, and Shubnikov and Koptsik s Symmetry in Science and Art. 

Chirality is a very general symmetry concept, and its consequences are not limited to the optical properties of systems. An electrical conductor for instance may be chiral because of several reasons. The material may crystallize in a chiral space group, like tellurium or /9-manganese [30], or be composed of chiral subunits like chiral conducting polymers [31] and Langmuir-Blodgett films [32] or vapors [33] of chiral molecules. Even if the material itself is nonchiral, it may still be formed into a chiral shape, like a helix. In all these cases, the conductor can exist in two enantiomeric forms. 

Symmetry is a common quality in science most properties of elementary particles, atoms, and molecules are symmetric, Brandmiiller (1986), Brandmiiller and Winter (1985), Brandmuller and Claus (1988). Since symmetry strictly defines relations between molecular spectra and molecular structures, the present section focuses on the mathematical tools which are necessary to apply symmetry concepts to vibrational spectroscopy. 

Force constant calculations are facilitated by applying symmetry concepts. Group theory is used to find the appropriate linear combination of internal coordinates to symmetry-adapted coordinates (symmetry coordinates). Based on these coordinates, the G matrix and the F matrix are factorized, which makes it possible to carry out separate calculations for each irreducible representation (c.f. Secs. 2.133 and 5.2). The main problem in calculating force constants is the choice of the potential function. Up until now, it has not been possible to apply a potential function in which the number of force constants corresponds to the number of frequencies. The number of remaining constants is only identical with the number of internal coordinates (simple valence force field SVFF) if the interaction force constants are neglected. If this force field is applied to symmetric molecules, there are often more frequencies than force constants. However, the values are not the same in different irreducible representations, a fact which demonstrates the deficiencies of this force field (Becher, 1968). 

Symmetry concepts can be extremely useful in chemistry. By analyzing the symmetry of molecules, we can predict infrared spectra, describe the types of orbitals used in bonding, predict optical activity, interpret electronic spectra, and study a number of additional molecular properties. In this chapter, we first define symmetry very specifically in terms of five fundamental symmetry operations. We then describe how molecules can be classified on the basis of the types of symmetry they possess. We conclude with examples of how symmetry can be used to predict optical activity of molecules and to determine the number and types of infrared-active stretching vibrations. 

Syntopy and syntopy groups were introduced in an early approach to a fuzzy set representation of approximate symmetry, where imperfect symmetry is regarded as fuzzy symmetry. Whereas any symmetry is a discrete property within a metric space, it is natural to consider a fuzzy set approach for a continuous extension of the discrete symmetry concept to quasisymmetric objects, such as some almost symmetric molecular structures. The syntopy approaches take into account the nonlocalized, quantum-mechanical, fuzzy nature of nuclear arrangements of molecules. 

Imperfect symmetry can be regarded as fuzzy symmetry. The theory of fuzzy sets has found applications in many fields of engineering and natural sciences (see, e.g., references [386-393]), in particular, for the description of fuzzy molecular arrangements [103,106,251]. It is natural to consider fuzzy sets for a continuous extension of the discrete point symmetry concept to quasi-symmetric molecular structures [252,394,395]. 

Since our surroundings are three-dimensional, we tend to assume that crystals are formed by periodic arrangements of atoms or molecules in three dimensions. However, many crystals are periodic only in two, or even in one dimension, and some do not have periodic structure at all, e.g. solids with incommensurately modulated structures, certain polymers, and quasicrystals. Materials may assume states that are intermediate between those of a crystalline solid and a liquid, and they are called liquid crystals. Hence, in real crystals, periodicity and/or order extends over a shorter or longer range, which is a function of the nature of the material and conditions under which it was crystallized. Structures of real crystals, e.g. imperfections, distortions, defects and impurities, are subjects of separate disciplines, and symmetry concepts considered below assume an ideal crystal with perfect periodicity. ... 

---