Solving puzzles

If you enjoy solving puzzles, you might like to read through the two accounts of structural determination (myrcene and citral) below, without looking at the figures and work out the structures for yourself from the evidence as it unfolds. 

Cleady, an interest in buildii things or taking things apart or solving puzzles is not all that is... 

This section contains the sample puzzles gathered from the various resources. At RIT, for third year Automobile Engineering course, students were encouraged to solve puzzles during practical sessions. We got an overwhelming response from students while solving puzzles. Some of the points noted are ... 

Students showed enthusiasm while solving puzzles. 

Students actively participated in solving puzzles, which shows their group discussion ability. 

Solving puzzles showed the students critical thinking ability. 

Training an NPC to do what you tell it Balance Solving puzzles... 

FIGURE 20.2 The organic acids observed by Krebs to be oxidized in suspensions of liver and kidney tissue. These substances were the pieces in the TCA puzzle that Krebs and others eventually solved. 

An understanding of covalent hydration is essential for all who work with heteroaromatic compounds containing doubly bonded nitrogen atoms. As chemists become more aware of the circumstances in which hydration occurs, and the means for detecting it, many new examples will probably be discovered and many puzzling discrepancies solved. Many of the values for ionization constants and ultraviolet spectra which are in the literature refer to partly hydrated equilibrium mixtures and should be replaced by values for the pure substances. 

All these techniques have provided a unanimous answer to the above questions. A combination of the results of any two or three of them would have sufficed to put together the puzzle. But each one of them has something new to offer, some new facet of the surface chemistry to reveal. So each of them will be discussed in this chapter in a sequence which in many cases coincides with the chronological order in which they were employed in order to solve the puzzle and understand the origin of electrochemical promotion. 

The relationship between structure and anticoagulant activity of heparin was a conundrum that puzzled Stacey. He did not solve the problem, but demonstrated that certain structural features of heparin (for example, extensive release of amino groups) alone were not responsible for the biological activity. 

The results cited in this section indeed appear very promising and encouraging, but there are still many problems to solve. Chemical and optical yields are extremely sensitive to experimental conditions such as current density and electrolyte composition Some experimental details in the asymmetric reduction of citraconic acid are indeed puzzling, such as a temperature maximum of the optical yield, and the fact the same product enantiomer is formed regardless if D or l polyvaline was used... 

There must be dissatisfaction with the existing conceptions. Scientists and students are unlikely to make major changes in their concepts until they believe that less radical changes will not work. Thus, before an accommodation can occur it is reasonable to suppose that individuals must have collected a store of unsolved puzzles or anomalies and lost faith in the ability of their current concepts to solve these problems. 

Making the completed layout is much like solving a puzzle where pieces have to fit together in a certain way. In fact, some planners like to cut out pieces of heavy paper representing the various laboratory components and juggle them around until a reasonable layout is obtained. 

This observation is the first part of the cancellation puzzle [20, 21, 27, 29]. We know from Section lll.B that we should be able to solve it directly by applying Eq. (19), which will separate out the contributions to the DCS made by the 1-TS and 2-TS reaction paths. That this is true is shown by Fig. 9(b). It is apparent that the main backward concentration of the scattering comes entirely from the 1-TS paths. This is not a surprise, since, by definition, the direct abstraction mechanism mentioned only involves one TS. What is perhaps surprising is that the small lumps in the forward direction, which might have been mistaken for numerical noise, are in fact the products of the 2-TS paths. Since the 1-TS and 2-TS paths scatter their products into completely different regions of space, there is no interference between the amplitudes f (0) and hence no GP effects. 

Read the entire laboratory activity. Decide upon the best strategy for solving the puzzle. 

Using the Internet Was there a particular web site or type of web site that you found most useful for solving the puzzle If so, which web site, and why ... 

Georg Brandt (1694-1768) solved the puzzle of blue glass. In his dissertation he described the new element and finally shed light on the mysterious blue. Brandt was considered a great chemist, but nevertheless there is no picture of him. 

Stringer, Ch. (1993), In Search of the Neanderthals Solving the Puzzle of Human Origins, Thames and Hudson, New York. 

In the case of a total unknown it is a case of the more data, the better. Solving this sort of problem is like doing a jigsaw puzzle. You piece together information from a variety of sources to come up with a feasible structure. You then test that structure with more experiments to ensure you get a consistent answer. As a minimum you should consider COSY, HSQC, HMBC, 1D 13C. Don t forget-NMR is not the only technique so look at mass spectrometry (accurate mass in particular) and IR to help. 

---