Methods for Structure Prediction

Computed NMR chemical shifts have been used numerous times to help identify chemical structure. This might be to identify the correct structure from a number of possible constitutional isomers or the proper structure from a selection of possible diastereomers. How one judges the correct selection is the topic of this section. 

Fattorusso and co-workers identified a component of wormwood called artar-borol. Correlation spectroscopy (COSY) and rotating frame nuclear overhauser effect spectroscopy (ROESY) experiments allowed for deduction of four possible diastereomeric structures of artarborol, 2-5. Low energy conformers of 11-14 were obtained through a molecular mechanics (MM) search. These conformers were screened to identify those having a dihedral angle of around 90 for the C-8 and C-9 protons due to a low coupling constant between these protons. Only conformers of 11 and 13 satisfied this criterion. Next, five low energy conformers, two 

---

The modeling approach is generally useful if the query structure is not contained in the database. Although the methods for structure prediction from infrared spectra introduced here can give quite accurate proposals, several considerations have to be taken into account. 

The above study shows that the combination of ab initio method with BH algorithm is not only a powerful method for structure prediction, but also an efficient tool of tracing chemically reaction paths. Nevertheless the application of ab initio BH to configuration search of 2D and onedimensional systems is still limited. 

Two approaches to quantify/fQ, i.e., to establish a quantitative relationship between the structural features of a compoimd and its properties, are described in this section quantitative structure-property relationships (QSPR) and linear free energy relationships (LFER) cf. Section 3.4.2.2). The LFER approach is important for historical reasons because it contributed the first attempt to predict the property of a compound from an analysis of its structure. LFERs can be established only for congeneric series of compounds, i.e., sets of compounds that share the same skeleton and only have variations in the substituents attached to this skeleton. As examples of a QSPR approach, currently available methods for the prediction of the octanol/water partition coefficient, log P, and of aqueous solubility, log S, of organic compoimds are described in Section 10.1.4 and Section 10.15, respectively. 

A useful empirical method for the prediction of chemical shifts and coupling constants relies on the information contained in databases of structures with the corresponding NMR data. Large databases with hundred-thousands of chemical shifts are commercially available and are linked to predictive systems, which basically rely on database searching [35], Protons are internally represented by their structural environments, usually their HOSE codes [9]. When a query structure is submitted, a search is performed to find the protons belonging to similar (overlapping) substructures. These are the protons with the same HOSE codes as the protons in the query molecule. The prediction of the chemical shift is calculated as the average chemical shift of the retrieved protons. 

Methods for the prediction of the secondary structure of a set of homologous proteins can reach an accuracy of about 75%, most of the errors occur at the ends of a helices or p strands. The central regions of these secondary structure elements are often correctly predicted but the methods do not always correctly distinguish between a helices and p strands. 

Approaches of de novo predictions, which try to calculate how the structural elements are folded into the 3D-stmcture (tertiary structure) of complete proteins are nowadays far away from reliable large-scale applications. On the other, hand this topic is under strong development indicated by recent successful results at the contest for structural prediction methods CASP4. With the fast growing number of experimentally solved 3D-stmctures of protein and new promising approaches like threading tools combined with experimental structural constraints, one can expect more reliable de novo predictions for 3D-protein structures in the future. 

Meylan, W.M. Howard, P.H. (2003) A Review of Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship Methods for the Prediction of Atmospheric Qxidation of Qrganic Chemicals. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 22(8), 1724—1732. 

Limit state design methods are used in blast resistant design. These methods provide a comprehensive, reliable and realistic means of predicting failure mechanisms and structural capacities. Limit state design methods for structural steel, cold formed steel, reinforced concrete and reinforced masonry are available. However, as of now, no similar design specification is available for aluminum structures. 

Much effort has been devoted to the development of reliable calculation methods for the prediction of the retention behaviour of analyses with well-known chemical structure and physicochemical parameters. Calculations can facilitate the rapid optimization of the separation process, reducing the number of preliminary experiments required for optimization. It has been earlier recognized that only one physicochemical parameter is not sufficient for the prediction of the retention of analyte in any RP-HPLC system. One of the most popular multivariate models for the calculation of the retention parameters of analyte is the linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) ... 

Original methods for developing predictive models for structure-vitro relationships using BioPrint data have been a strong research focus at Cerep for many years. These are detailed in previous publications (see Ref. 7 and references therein) and can be partitioned into two categories ... 

Laurie ATR, Jackson RM (2005) Structural bioinformatics Q-SiteFinder an energy-based method for the prediction of protein—ligand binding sites. Bioinformatics 21 1908-1916... 

Many known drug receptors, and many prospective drug targets, exist as molecular arrays within membrane-bound macromolecules that cannot be readily crystallized neither can they be isolated or purified for the application of NMR methods. Moreover, even if an amino acid sequence were available, rule-based methods for the prediction of secondary structure, being derived as they are from a database of soluble proteins, cannot be applied with any confidence to the membrane-bound state. 

The method presented in this chapter serves as a link between molecular properties (e.g., cavities and their occupants as measured by diffraction and spectroscopy) and macroscopic properties (e.g., pressure, temperature, and density as measured by pressure guages, thermocouples, etc.) As such Section 5.3 includes a brief overview of molecular simulation [molecular dynamics (MD) and Monte Carlo (MC)] methods which enable calculation of macroscopic properties from microscopic parameters. Chapter 2 indicated some results of such methods for structural properties. In Section 5.3 molecular simulation is shown to predict qualitative trends (and in a few cases quantitative trends) in thermodynamic properties. Quantitative simulation of kinetic phenomena such as nucleation, while tenable in principle, is prevented by the capacity and speed of current computers however, trends may be observed. 

Two types of information are obtained from any molecular mechanics study, the minimum value of the strain energy and the structure associated with that minimum. Agreement between the energy-minimized and experimental (crystallographic) structures has often been used as the primary check on the validity of the force field and to refine the force field further, but often little predictive use has been made of the structures obtained. As force fields become more reliable, the potential value of structure predictions increases. More importantly, when no unequivocal determination of a structure is available by experimental methods then structure prediction may be the only means of obtaining a three-dimensional model of the molecule. This is often the case, for instance, in metal-macromolecule adducts, and structures obtained by molecular mechanics can be a genuine aid in the visualization of these interactions. In this chapter we consider the ways in which structure prediction by molecular mechanics calcluations has been used, and point to future directions. 

This is the main easily accessible method for direct prediction of a property from chemical structure alone. Fragment methods view a molecule as composed of specified parts, which contribute individually to the compound property. 

The two major independent in silico methods for the prediction of toxicity are quantitative-structure-activity-relationship (QSAR) and expert systems (e.g. DEREK, MultiCASE). QSAR means the quantitative relationship between a chemical structure and its biological/ toxicological activity with the help of chemical descriptors that are generated from the... 

Smart, O. S., Breed, J., Smith, G. R., and Sansom, M. S. (1997). A novel method for structure-based prediction of ion channel conductance properties. Biophys. J. 72, 1109-1126. 

The basic principles on which the Hansch multiple parameter method for structure-activity correlation depends are described. These are compared with the basic features of the Free-Wilson method for assigning additivity constants to structural features of related compounds. An example is given for which the two methods of analysis have led to similar structure-activity relationships. Factors which determine the particular method to use in a new situation are discussed. The Free-Wilson method is presented in considerable operational detail with special emphasis on the detection and avoidance of situations which lead to singularity problems in solution of the matrix. Favorable analyses, which result in additivity constants that can be correlated with known physical constants, may lead to predictions for new compounds not covered in the original matrix. 

Another well-established method for building predictive models is partial least squares (PLS) regression. PLS is a modem relative of MLR, having been established in the 1960 s by Wold. The method reaches beyond linear regression by replacing the descriptors with a matrix of latent variables distilled from both the structural features of the training compounds and their experimental results. In PLS, the use of the term latent variables differs from its formal definition in other regression methods. ... 

---