Kinetic analysis general methods

The interactions between physics and biology govern large-scale microbial production and also heavily influence reaction rates on the laboratory scale. This fact is to be considered in the case of process kinetics analysis. All methods used for quantification in bioprocessing (cf. Chapters 3 and 4) should be critically considered, and standards would be desirable (cf. EFB, Dechema 1984) for development of a general methodology for biotechnology. 

In addition to the main general methods of analysis outlined above there are also certain specialised techniques which are applied in special circumstances. Among these are X-ray methods, methods based upon the measurement of radioactivity, mass spectrometry, the so-called kinetic methods, and thermal methods. 

This method is primarily concerned with the phenomena that occur at electrode surfaces (electrodics) in a solution from which, as an absolute method, through previous calibration a component concentration can be derived. If desirable the technique can be used to follow the progress of a chemical reaction, e.g., in kinetic analysis. Mostly, however, potentiometry is applied to reactions that go to completion (e.g. a titration) merely in order to indicate the end-point (a potentiometric titration in this instance) and so do not need calibration. The overwhelming importance of potentiometry in general and of potentiometric titration in particular is due to the selectivity of its indication, the simplicity of the technique and the ample choice of electrodes. 

General Methods. Methanol used in kinetic runs was distilled from sodium methoxide or calcium hydride in a nitrogen atmosphere before use. Freshly distilled cyclohexanol was added to the methanol in the ratio 6.0 ml cyclohexanol/200 ml MeOH and was used as an internal standard for gas chromatographic (GC) analysis. Benzaldehyde was distilled under vacuum and stored under nitrogen at 5°. Other aldehydes (purchased from Aldrich) were also distilled before use. The corresponding alcohols (purchased from Aldrich) were distilled and used to prepare GC standards. All metal carbonyl cluster complexes were purchased from Strem Chemical Company and used as received. Tetrahydrofuran (THF) was distilled from sodium benzophenone under nitrogen before use. 

Equation (25) is general in that it does not depend on the electrochemical method employed to obtain the i-E data. Moreover, unlike conventional electrochemical methods such as cyclic or linear scan voltammetry, all of the experimental i-E data are used in kinetic analysis (as opposed to using limited information such as the peak potentials and half-widths when using cyclic voltammetry). Finally, and of particular importance, the convolution analysis has the great advantage that the heterogeneous ET kinetics can be analyzed without the need of defining a priori the ET rate law. By contrast, in conventional voltammetric analyses, a specific ET rate law (as a rule, the Butler-Volmer rate law) must be used to extract the relevant kinetic information. 

Various types of possible interactions between reactions are discussed. Some of them are united by the general idea of chemical reaction interference. The ideas on conjugated reactions are broadened and the determinant formula is deduced the coherence condition for chemical interference is formulated and associated phase shifts are determined. It is shown how interaction between reactions may be qualitatively and quantitatively assessed and kinetic analysis of complex reactions with under-researched mechanisms may be performed with simultaneous consideration of the stationary concentration method. Using particular examples, interference of hydrogen peroxide dissociation and oxidation of substrates is considered. 

Today, there is an increasing interest in the theoretical study and the practical application of integrated reactive separation processes such as reactive distillation columns [1-3] or membrane-assisted reactors [37]. However, to date there is no general method available for designing such processes. For practical applications, it is important to be able to evaluate quickly whether a certain reactive separation process is a suitable candidate to reach certain targets. Therefore, feasibility analysis tools being based on minimal thermodynamic and kinetic information of the considered system are valuable. 

Obtaining initial rate data is, of course, a first step in the kinetic analysis of an enzyme-catalyzed reaction, and the reader is referred to the General References for several reviews and monographs describing the methods for this analysis. 

Although a complete survey of the experimental methods which have been used for the study of reacting systems is outside the scope of this book, it is well to consider some of the more general methods which have been employed and some of the difficulties inherent in such studies. The general problem involved in any experimental study of a kinetic system is to obtain a complete description of the state of the system over the duration of the reaction. Of the variables of the system, the temperature is generally kept constant (by employing a thermostat), and its effect on the rate is studied independently. Also, the volume is kept constant or nearly constant. The principal problem then resolves itself into devising methods for the chemical analysis of the system as a function of time. 

For a long time the main topic of research in the area of sensitivity analysis was to find an accurate and effective method for the calculation of local concentration sensitivities. This question now seems to be settled, and the decoupled direct method (ddm) is generally considered the best numerical method. All the main combustion simulation packages such as CHEMKIN, LSENS, RUNIDL and FACSIMILE calculate sensitivities as well as the simulation results and, therefore, many publications contain sensitivity calculations. However, usually very little information is actually deduced from the sensitivity results. It is surprising that the application of principal component analysis is not widespread, since it is a simple postprocessing method which can be used to extract a lot of information from the sensitivities about the structure of the kinetic mechanism. Also, methods for parameter estimation should always be preceded by the principal component analysis of the concentration sensitivity matrix. 

We shall show that the analysis of the structure of kinetic systems can provide such a general method. Since the new method arises from an under-... 

Rajeshwar I52) determined the kinetics of the thermal decomposition of Green River oil shale kerogen by using direct Arrhenius. Freeman and Carroll, and Coats and Redfern methods. The E, A, and values are given in Table 2.7. Rajeshwar concluded that the ability to resolve multiple processes hinges on the efficacy of the particular kinetic analysis employed and is not an inherent difficulty with nonisothermal TG techniques in general. The direct Arrhenius and Coats and Redfern methods clearly indicate the presence of two reactions with distinctly different kinetic parameters. On the olher hand, the Freeman and Carroll method is handicapped at low fractional... 

In principle spectroscopic methods have turned out to be preferable in kinetic analysis. Nowadays a large variety of spectroscopic methods exist which allow the progress of the photochemical reaction to be monitored. However, none of them perfectly satisfies under all conditions the requirements stated above. Even though it is difficult to state a general procedure, some generalised ideas are discussed next to find arguments for the selection of certain analytical tools. 

In general many mechanisms can result in the same functional relationship between concentration and time. For this reason the mechanism determined and in consequence the rate constants obtained are not all unambiguous. Furthermore accuracy and reproducibility of the measurements are limited. They vary with the method used for the determination of the concentrations with time. Thus the limitation in the measured signals and the variety of rate laws increase the many mechanisms fitting to the signals measured. For this reason the only positive result of any kinetic analysis can be in principle ... 

In addition to gravimetric analysis, TG has also been used to elucidate the kinetics of decomposition reactions. This involves analyzing the shape of the TG curve. In general, the rate of reaction at any measured temperature is proportional to the slope of the curve, but a number of uncertainties sometimes make these analyses of questionable value. Freeman and Carroll [/. Phys. Chem., 62, 389 (1958)] describe the most popular of the kinetics-analysis methods, while Clarke et al. [Chem. Comm., 266 (1969)] present the major objections to kinetics analysis by TG. 

General Methods of Kinetic Analysis and Specific Ecological Correlates... 

Many of these methods are based on the rate law shown in Eq. (8.6), which is not a general rate law because it can not be put in a form to describe diffusion control or Avrami rate laws (see Chapter 7). In 1983, Reich and Stivala removed the constraint imposed by Eq. (8.6) by developing a kinetic analysis procedure that tests most of the common types of rate laws including Avrami, diffusion control, and others not covered by Eq. (8.6). The method is based on a computer program that fits the (a,T) data to the rate laws and computes the standard error of estimate (SEE) for each so that the rate law that provides the best fit to the data can be identified. It is stiU true that when data from a large number of runs are considered, it is rare that a given rate law fits the data from all the runs. It is still necessary to make a large number of runs and examine the results to determine the rate law that fits the data from most of the runs. 

---