Design model, validity

Future needs in support of model validation and performance testing must continue to be in the area of coordinated, well-designed field data collection programs supplemented with directed research on specific topics. The FAT workshop produced a listing of the field data collection and research needs for the air, streams/lakes/estuaries, and runoff/unsaturated/saturated soil media categories, as follows ... 

On the basis of different assumptions about the nature of the fluid and solid flow within each phase and between phases as well as about the extent of mixing within each phase, it is possible to develop many different mathematical models of the two phase type. Pyle (119), Rowe (120), and Grace (121) have critically reviewed models of these types. Treatment of these models is clearly beyond the scope of this text. In many cases insufficient data exist to provide critical tests of model validity. This situation is especially true of large scale reactors that are the systems of greatest interest from industry s point of view. The student should understand, however, that there is an ongoing effort to develop mathematical models of fluidized bed reactors that will be useful for design purposes. Our current... 

Model validation is a process that involves establishing the predictive power of a model during the study design as well as in the data analysis stages. The predictive power is estimated through simulation that considers distributions of PK, PD, and study-design variables. A robust study design will provide accurate and precise model-parameter estimations that are insensitive to model assumptions. 

We have introduced many practical software based numerical procedures to solve physico-chemical models for simulation and design purposes. Therefore, we hope that our readers now feel comfortable and ready to handle more complex industrial problems from the modeling stage through the numerical solution and model validation stages on her/his own. 

Third, the validation is often adapted to the final objective in the search for a pharmacophore. Whether its is to be used as a query for virtual screening, to predict accurately the activity of a series of molecule or to serve as a guide for drug design, some validation approaches can be emphasized over others. So, if the title of this chapter were to be rephrased, we could have asked Are you sure you have the right model... for the envisaged application ... 

Brown JQ. Modeling, design, and validation of fluorescent spherical enzymatic glucose microsensors using nanoengineered polyelectrolyte coatings. Louisiana Tech University, 2005. 

A variety of assays have been designed and validated to measure specific antibodies in the sera of treated animals. In addition efforts have been paid to minimizing the immunogenicity of therapeutic proteins. As these issues are addressed comprehensively in another chapter of this volume, the focus here will be on predicting problems that may ensue from the presence of such antibodies, namely hypersensitivity reactions. Presumably because allergic reactions have long been considered to be nonreproducible in animal models, limited efforts have been paid to designing predictive animal models until recently. Unexpectedly, the consequence is that no adequately standardized and validated model is available at the present time. 

In practice, it generally will be found that one-dimensional models are entirely adequate for optimization, provided that they are validated in some kind of pilot-scale tubular reactor. Validation comprises the adjustment of parameters in the reactor model equations so that observed and predicted temperature and concentration profiles match as closely as possible. Typical parameters are the relative catalyst activity factors Bj and, if necessary, the overall heat-transfer coefficient, U. A statistically-designed set of experiments in the pilot-plant is invaluable for model validation, and such a set was used in this project. 

The considerations and the experimental evidence just described suggest that the reactor design as well as the definition of process conditions need a tool, able to provide reliable predictions for the on-set of fluidization worsening and bed defluidization. Mastellone and Arena [37] proposed a predictive defluidization model valid for low-temperature pyrolysis... 

Simulation data on mixture adsorption can be used to screen zeolites as adsorbents, but experimental data are necessary to validate the simulations and to accurately design the separation process. The first step of the process design is to obtain such data. However, the experimental assessment of multi-component adsorption equilibria and kinetics is not straightforward and is highly time-consuming. As a result, some theories have been developed that predict adsorption behaviour for a mixture based on the pure component equilibria [1,3]. The isotherm data have to be correlated before their use in a design model... 

When a model has been obtained, it is necessary to evaluate the fit of the model, by comparing for each of the points the experimental value obtained for the response and the value predicted with the model. Important differences indicate that the model is not adequate and that a more complex model (see below) may be needed. To have still more confidence in the model, validation can be carried out. This requires that new chromatograms be obtained at different x-values from those obtained with the experimental design. Again the experimental and predicted response values are compared. 

Further experiments may be added to a D-optimal design to validate the model (laek of fit) and... 

---