Correlation analysis of solvent effects

Correlation analysis of solvent effects on the heterolysis of p-methoxyneophyl tosyl-ate has been performed by using the Koppel-Palm and Kamlet-Taft equations. The reaction rate is satisfactorily described by the electrophilicity and polarity parameters of solvents, but a possible role for polarizability or nucleophilicity parameters was also examined. 

The application of correlation analysis of solvent effects to mechanistic studies of solvolysis has been reviewed by Takeuchi in Japanese.110 The article mainly covers die behaviour of tertiary chloro compounds. Tins author s research group has continued experimental studies in this area.111-113 Rates of solvolysis of 2-chloro-2,4-trimethylpentane have been measured in 17 solvents and analysed through the extended Grunwald-Winstein equation, which includes a term for nucleophilic participation.111... 

R. W. Taft (1922-1996) was professor of chemistry at Pennsylvania State College and then for thirty years at the University of California, Irvine. He did distinguished work in several fields of physical organic chemistry, e.g. structure-reactivity relationships, gas-phase reactivity of organic compounds, and the correlation analysis of solvent effects.299,300... 

Another statistical treatment of a set of 32 solvent parameter scales for 45 solvents using the program SMIRC ( election of a set of minimally mterrelated columns) has been carried out by Palm et al. [246], who, incidentally, introduced the first multi(four)-parameter equation for the correlation analysis of solvent effects in 1971 [cf. Eq. (7-50) in Chapter 7]. The minimum sufficient set of residual descriptors for the multilinear description of solvent effects consists of nine solvent parameter scales. This set of nine (purified) descriptors has been successfully applied to an extended set of 359 different solvent-dependent processes for more details, see reference [246]. 

The general SPP scale of solvent dipolarity/polarizability and the specific SB and SA scales of solvent HBA basicity and HBD acidity, respectively, are orthogonal to one another and they can be used in the correlation analysis of solvent effects in single- or, in combination with the others, in two- or three-parameter correlation equations, depending on the solvent-influenced process under consideration see also Section 7.7. Examples of the correlation analysis of a variety of other solvent-dependent processes by means of SPP, SB, and SA values, including those used for the introduction of other solvent polarity parameters, can be found in references [335-337, 340-342]. In particular, comparisons with Kamlet and Taft s n scale [340] and Winstein and Grunwald s Y scale [341] have been made. 

From the previous Sections, we can conclude that there are many empirical solvent scales, the most comprehensive of which are the solvatochromic ones cf. for example Table 7-3. Unfortunately, too many solvent scales have been proposed during the last decades. Around 35 different solvent scales are known. Only about ten of them have found wider application in the correlation analysis of solvent effects, i.e. Y, Z, t(30), a,... 

General multiparameter correlation analysis of solvent effects... 

Another problem that has been tackled by multivariate statistical methods is the characterization of the solvation capability of organic solvents based on empirical parameters of solvent polarity (see Chapter 7). Since such empirical parameters of solvent polarity are derived from carefully selected, strongly solvent-dependent reference processes, they are molecular-microscopic parameters. The polarity of solvents thus defined cannot be described by macroscopic, bulk solvent characteristics such as relative permittivities, refractive indices, etc., or functions thereof. For the quantitative correlation of solvent-dependent processes with solvent polarities, a large variety of empirical parameters of solvent polarity have been introduced (see Chapter 7). While some solvent polarity parameters are defined to describe an individual, more specific solute/solvent interaetion, others do not separate specific solute/solvent interactions and are referred to as general solvent polarity scales. Consequently, single- and multi-parameter correlation equations have been developed for the description of all kinds of solvent effects, and the question arises as to how many empirical parameters are really necessary for the correlation analysis of solvent-dependent processes such as chemical equilibria, reaction rates, or absorption spectra. 

At present, the situation is not quite as bad as in the correlation analysis of substituent effects, where even more substituent parameters than common substituents seem to be known. It has been suggested that new solvent polarity scales should only be introduced into the literature if they exhibit significant advantages over existing solvent scales [235]. 

This solvatochromic solvent effect equation has been probably the most widely used one in the analysis of solvent effects40 and it has been applied to literally hundreds of processes in solution and for the correlation of all kinds of solvents effects39-43. 

Most of the data in Table 12 come from the work of Shvo et al. (78). Careful band-shape analysis and solvent-effect studies permitted evaluation of the rate constants and AG values at 298 K, which renders the discussion of substituent effects more meaningful than usual. The authors obtained reasonably linear Hammett plots when correlating log km with Or (79) for X and Y, holding one of these substituents constant. They also found that the dihydropyridine system may act as an unusually efficient donor, giving a AG of 17.6 kcal/mol with X, Y = H, CN, the only barrier below 25 kcal/mol reported for any donor-substituted cyanoethylene. However, with other acceptor combinations the dihydropyridine moiety is not so outstanding, and this illustrates the difficulty of measuring donor and/or acceptor effects by rotational barriers alone (vide infra). 

In this context, it should be pointed out that the correlation between aromatic solvent-induced shifts (ASIS) and the axial or equatorial orientation of protons in cyclic sulfoxides and sulfites is quite distinct (211-213) and may be utilized in the assignment of configurations. For instance, the absolute configuration at sulfur was assigned to the penicillin sulfoxide 202 based on analysis of the effect of aromatic solvents on the chemical shifts of protons of the thiazolidine ring (214,215). 

Clearly, for any specific order of turning on the interaction U lc, X,), we shall obtain a different expansion on the rhs of Eq. (9.4.2). In the particular expansion written on the rhs of Eq. (9.4.2) we have classified all the functional groups on the surface of a (i.e., those FGs that are exposed to the solvent) into different classes. The first consists of all the FGs that are independently solvated. The second consists of all pairs of correlated FGs, and so on. We shall see in the next two sections that this particular form of expansion of AG is convenient for a qualitative analysis of the types of solvent effect we may expect on cooperativity. 

Laurence51 has derived cr/ values (he uses the symbol correlation analysis of the carbonyl stretching frequencies of 4-substituted camphors in carbon tetrachloride. The value of 0.11 is given for the vinyl group, in good agreement with the reactivity-based values discussed above, in spite of the use of a non-polar medium. Laurence compares this with a statistical value of 0.06 from Taft and Topsom57, said to refer to effects on physical properties in either the gas phase or in hydrocarbon or similar solvents. 

First-order dependence is observed with respect to both the oxidant and reductant in the oxidation of substituted anilines with peroxomonosulfate anion. Addition of acid causes retardation of the reaction. Yukawa-Tsuno correlation of the rates gave a negative reaction constant (p -1.7) and analysis of the effect of solvent in terms of Grunwald-Winstein equation (m 0.4) indicated an S -type reaction. 

An analysis of these results in terms of solvent effects leads to the observation of similarities with Ritchie s work on the N+ relation. Thus the constant selectivities obtained in the solvolysis reactions of certain methyl derivatives (Table 9) may indicate the existence of a basic similarity between the rate-determining process in these reaction and in the electrophile-nucleophile combination reactions correlated by the IV+ relation. The failure of the methyl halides to conform to this pattern might suggest that their substitution reactions are fundamentally different, and that the free energy of activation is dependent on factors other than desolvation. 

A mechanistic model involving nucleophilic assistance, but not taking into account the variable electrophilic assistance in different solvents, has been proposed (54, 55) for the solvolysis of tert-butyl halides. The analysis was based on a comparison of solvent effects on the solvolysis rates of tert-butyl and adamantyl substrates. The solvent properties were analyzed in terms of parameters N and Y the electrophilic assistance was incorporated into Y (54, 56). Such an approximation had been acceptable in the original wor4c (14-16), which dealt mostly with aqueous alcohols as solvents. This approximation is no longer permissible when materials like TFA and fluori-nated alcohols are used as solvents. In fact, Fainberg and Winstein (56) pointed out that different solvent mixtures could not be placed on the same correlation line. 

Despite all these advantages, alternative chemical methods of synthesis are being developed and improved [19-25] that will partly take the place of electrosynthesis, even for electrochemical applications such as batteries and sensors. This is associated in part with the great difficulties in correlating the properties of the material with the conditions of synthesis. This is a consequence of the complexity of electrochemical synthesis, which involves different experimental variables, both chemical (nature of the solvent, the monomer, and the dopant salt) and physical (temperature, electrical conditions, nature and shape of the electrodes, geometry of the cell). In addition, the effects of all these variables are interdependent. As a consequence, adequate control of polymer electrosynthesis, and hence of the polymer properties, will require analysis of the effects of the individual parameters and their reciprocal dependence. This will be the objective of the first part of the chapter. 

The level of electronic structure theory used by Mikkelsen et al. [37] is given by the multiconfigurational (MC) selfconsistent field (SCF) where the wavefunction is fully optimized with respect to all variational parameters these include both orbital and configurations. The main deficiency of standard SCF ab initio procedures, namely, lack of correlation effects, is overcome in this MCSCF approach. The level of solvent-effects theory is the standard spherical cavity immersed in a continuum dielectric an early formalism proposed by Rinaldi and Rivail was used (see Ref. [6] for an extensive analysis). 

---