Carbocation carbanion salts

A few observations of the isolation of carbocation-carbanion salt containing heteroatoms, such as oxygen and nitrogen, have been reported. Over 30 years ago LeGoff and LaCount (1963) reported the formation of a... 

NMR spectroscopy is ideal for detecting charged fluorinated intermediates and has been applied to the study of increasingly stable carbocation and carbanion species. Olah [164, 165] has generated stable fluorocarbocations m SbFj/SOjClF at low temperatures The relatively long-lived perfluoro-rerr-butyl anion has been prepared as both the cesium and tris(dimethylamino)sulfonium (TAS) salts by several groups [166, 167, 168], Chemical shifts of fluonnated carbocations and carbanions are listed m Table 23. 

By combining a very stable carbanion with a very stable carbocation, Okamoto et al. were able to isolate the salt 17, as well as several similar salts, as stable solids. These are salts that consist entirely of carbon and hydrogen. 

The synthetic procedures for isolation of the salt appear to be rather simple. First, one prepares a solution in which the carbocation and carbanion coexist free from any combination reactions. Then, the hydrocarbon cation-anion salt is isolated after separation of the concomitant inorganic salt and evaporation of the solvent. For the purification of the crude salt recrystallization or reprecipitation with proper solvents is used. 

Sufficient stability of the hydrocarbon ions, as the salt or in the solution, is an obvious prerequisite for these procedures, and, in practice, selecting or designing the stable ions and choosing a proper solvent are tasks of primary importance. As an ordinary stability index for the ions, thermodynamic scales referred to the water molecule, i.e. p CR+ and pKa values, are chosen for the carbocation and carbanion, respectively. 

In the course of the salt synthesis, it was found that a hydrocarbon [3-2], which was formed by an unfavourable cation-anion combination reaction, dissociates into the original carbocation and carbanion in a polar aprotic solvent (Okamoto et ai, 1985) (1). This was the first example of ionic dissociation of the carbon-carbon a bond in genuine hydrocarbons, although a few cases of heterolytic dissociation of carbon-carbon tr bonds had been reported by Arnett (Arnett et al., 1983 Troughton et al., 1984 Arnett and Molter, 1985) for compounds bearing cyano and nitro groups, e.g. [4-6] and [5-6] as in (2). 

Structural factors necessary for carbocation and carbanion stability are discussed briefly. The mechanistic problems of dissociation of the carbon-carbon a bond are then discussed, and finally the physicochemical nature of hydrocarbon salts and the related novel hydrocarbons. 

The Stability of hydrocarbon ions is discovered intuitively by observing whether the hydrocarbon ion can be isolated as a salt, for example, a sodium salt of the carbanion or a tetrafluoroborate salt of the carbocation. Conversely, a single hydrocarbon ion produced in the gas phase is obviously an unstable and short-lived species. Thus, many of the aliphatic carbocations in the gas phase are merely observable species but are not usable for synthesis. 

Unlike such unstable intermediates, the first, rare example of reversible dissociation of a carbon-carbon a bond into a stable carbocation and carbanion was reported for a nitro-dicyano compound (20) prepared from trimethyl- and triphenyl-cyclopropenylium tetrafluoroborate ([4" ]BF4 and [5 JBFJ) with the potassium salt of p-substituted-phenylmalononitrile anions (Arnett et al., 1983 Troughton et al., 1984 Arnett and Molter, 1985). Other ionically dissociative malononitrile derivatives have been prepared from such carbocations as the tropylium [S ] (Arnett and Troughton, 1983) and the tris(p-methoxyphenyl)methylium [93 j (Arnett and Troughton, 1983) ions. 

The complete dissociation of the hydrocarbons [l 2 ], [28" 2 ] and [40" 2 ] in DMSO has been demonstrated by quantitative generation of both Kuhn s carbanion [2 ] and carbocations [1" ], [28" ] and [40" ] as determined by UV-vis spectra (Table 6 and Eig. 4). However, since carbocation [24 ] has no absorptions at a wavelength region longer than 220 nm in the UV spectrum, there remained an ambiguity that this cation might have decomposed in the DMSO solution. A clue to this problem could be obtained by determination of the electric conductivity of DMSO solutions of hydrocarbon salts (Table 7) (Okamoto et al., 1990). 

The electron affinity of the carbocations as measured by red is a useful index for the stability of the carbocations. It is of great interest to correlate the occurrence of three principal reactions between a carbocation and a carbanion, i.e. covalent bond formation (36), single-electron transfer (37) and salt formation (38), with the magnitude of the E ed for the carbocations. 

Considering the long saga of hydrocarbon chemistry, it is surprising that two new classes of hydrocarbon - ionically dissociative hydrocarbons and hydrocarbon salts - have been discovered in the last decade. The syntheses of authentic samples as analytically pure solids have revealed the very existence of such novel hydrocarbons in an unquestionable way, but the investigation of their basic features is just in the inchoate stage. The search for such novel hydrocarbons depends primarily on the synthesis and examination of highly stabilized hydrocarbon cations and anions. As mentioned above, until now such elaboration has been concentrated on the carbocation side, and examination of the carbanion moiety has only just started. 

A rare species of salts consisting of a heteroatom-stabilized carbocation and a heteroatom-stabibzed carbanion has been formed by deprotonating methyl (Z)- or (E)-3-hydroxy-2,3-dimesitylpropenoate with tetrakis(dimethylamino)methane the resonance stabilization of the cation [(CH3)2N]3C+ and enolate anion, which is of E-configuration exclusively, since the guanadinium ion is incapable of forming a chelate, prevents a spontaneous O- or C-alkylation.12... 

The reactive intermediates used in chain-growth polymerizations include radicals, carbanions, carbocations, and organometallic complexes. Of the three common metal catalyzed polymerizations - coordination-insertion, ring-opening metathesis and diene polymerization - the last appears to possess the greatest tolerance toward protic solvents. The polymerization of butadiene in polar solvents was first reported in 1961 using Rh salts [18]. It was discovered that these polymerizations could be performed in aqueous solution with an added emulsifier (sodium dodecyl sulfate, for example). 

Both the carbanion and carbocations are stable provided they contain [An+ 2) K electrons. For example, cyclopentadienyl anion, cyclopropenium cation, and tropyhum cation exhibit unusual stability. Stable carbanions do, however, exist. In 1984 Ohnstead presented the lithium crown ether salt of the diphenylmethyl carbanion from diphenylmethane, butyllithium, and 12-crown-4 at low temperatures. Addition of n-butyUithium to triphenyhnethane in THF at low temperatures followed by 12-crown-4 resulted in a red solution and the salt complex precipitated at —20°C. The central C-C bond lengths are 145 pm with the phenyl ring propelled at an average angle of 31.2° (Scheme 3.11). 

---