Brpnsted a-values

Another striking feature of these reactions actually helps us visualize how this need for reorganization can contribute to the intrinsic barrier. This feature is the disparity or imbalance in measured structure-reactivity coefficients such as Brpnsted a and (3 values. Indeed, the Brpnsted a values obtained by varying a remote substituent in the carbon acid, for example, Z in I (equation 2), are usually larger than the Brpnsted (3 values obtained by varying the base, that is, / = a — (3 > 0 (Table II). 

The mechanism of reaction between barbiturate and 1,3-dimethylbarbiturate ions with o-nitro-, j -nitro-, and 2,4-dinitrobenzaldehyde has been explored rate dependence on solvent viscosity is indicative of involvement of a diffusion-controlled proton transfer in the rate-determining step at pH 2-4. Unexpected values of Brpnsted a for the acid-catalysed process have been explained. 

There are a number of limitations on the Brpnsted relationship. First of aU, the relation holds only for similar types of acids (or bases). For example, carboxylic acids may have a different a values compared to sulfonic acids or phenols. Because charge, and likewise solvation, can greatly influence the reaction rate, deviations of net charge from one catalyst to another can also influence Brpnsted plots. Another limitation on this relationship relates to temperature. Reaction rates and the corresponding dissociation constants for the acids must all be measured at the same temperature (and, most rigorously, in the same solvent). For some systems, this may prove infeasible. A third limitation is that the reaction must indeed be subject to general acid (or base) catalysis. For certain catalysts, deviations from a linear relationship may indicate other modes of action beyond general acid/... 

Rowlett and Silverman used a Brpnsted plot to examine the interaction of external buffers with human carbonic anhydrase II. The buffers act as proton acceptors in the removal of the proton generated by the enzyme-catalyzed reaction. The Brpnsted plot displays a plateau at a value of about 10 for the catalytic rate... 

It is accepted that the acmal nucleophile in the reactions of oximes with OPs is the oximate anion, Pyr+-CH=N-0 , and the availability of the unshared electrons on the a-N neighboring atom enhances reactions that involve nucleophilic displacements at tetravalent OP compounds (known also as the a-effect). In view of the fact that the concentration of the oximate ion depends on the oxime s pATa and on the reaction pH, and since the pKs also reflects the affinity of the oximate ion for the electrophile, such as tetra valent OP, the theoretical relationship between the pATa and the nucleophilicity parameter was analyzed by Wilson and Froede . They proposed that for each type of OP, at a given pH, there is an optimum pK value of an oxime nucleophile that will provide a maximal reaction rate. The dissociation constants of potent reactivators, such as 38-43 (with pA a values of 7.0-8.5), are close to this optimum pK, and can be calculated, at pH = 7.4, from pKg = — log[l//3 — 1] -h 7.4, where is the OP electrophile susceptibility factor, known as the Brpnsted coefficient. If the above relationship holds also for the reactivation kinetics of the tetravalent OP-AChE conjugate (see equation 20), it would be important to estimate the magnitude of the effect of changes in oxime pX a on the rate of reactivation, and to address two questions (a) How do changes in the dissociation constants of oximes affect the rate of reactivation (b) What is the impact of the /3 value, that ranges from 0.1 to 0.9 for the various OPs, on the relationship between the pKg, and the rate of reactivation To this end, Table 3 summarizes some theoretical calculations for the pK. ... 

Kinetic Acidities in the Condensed Phase. For very weak acids, it is not always possible to establish proton-transfer equilibria in solution because the carbanions are too basic to be stable in the solvent system or the rate of establishing the equilibrium is too slow. In these cases, workers have turned to kinetic methods that rely on the assumption of a Brpnsted correlation between the rate of proton transfer and the acidity of the hydrocarbon. In other words, log k for isotope exchange is linearly related to the pK of the hydrocarbon (Eq. 13). The a value takes into account the fact that factors that stabilize a carbanion generally are only partially realized at the transition state for proton transfer (there is only partial charge development at that point) so the rate is less sensitive to structural effects than the pAT. As a result, a values are expected to be between zero and one. Once the correlation in Eq. 13 is established for species of known pK, the relationship can be used with kinetic data to extrapolate to values for species of unknown pAT. 

Equation 2.13 is an example of the Brpnsted equation (see section A3). Here, the Brpnsted /3 value measures the sensitivity of the reaction to the pKa of the conjugate acid of the base. The A is a constant for the particular reaction. 

Similar behavior was discovered in subsequent studies for ZSM-5 (772,174) and ZSM-11 (173) zeolites synthesized with aluminum and boron in the zeolite lattice and for boron-synthesized ZSM-11 zeolites (173). The modification of the ZSM-5 and ZSM-11 samples produced a minor improvement in shape selectivity and a large decrease in acidity and hence activity. The initial heat for the B-ZSM-11 sample decreased from 160 kJ mol" for Al-ZSM-11 to 65 kJ mor , and the acidity decreased to 10% of the original value. The q-d curve also showed a maximum at high coverages, which was attributed to the formation of a NH NHa) complex on reacting B—OH—NH3 with NH3. Dehydroxylation at 1073 K increased the initial heat to 170 kJ mol", a value comparable to the initial heat of 185 kJ mol" on Al-ZSM-11, and it sharpened the maximum in the q-9 curve. This behavior is apparently due to the formation of a few strong Lewis acid sites. The sample synthesized with both boron and aluminum behaved differently than those with only aluminum or boron. The q-6 curve for this sample showed maxima at about 145-175 kJ mol" and at about 60-70 kJ mol for 673 and 1073 K dehydroxylation temperatures, respectively. The acidity of this sample was 30% lower than an Al-ZSM-11 sample with similar Si/Al ratio. The initial heat for the aluminum zeolite was 170 to 190 kJ mol". It was shown, with IR spectroscopy of adsorbed ammonia, that the boron-modified samples showed little or no Brpnsted acidity. 

Hie value of Si/Al ratio can be converted to Al content and thus, as in Al NMR, to a value for Brpnsted acid sites density. 

An equilibrium constant for Equation 7.2 would have a value of infinity. The proton exists in water as a hydrated ion, the hydronium ion, HsO" ". Higher hydrates probably exist, particularly H904. The hydronium ion is written as HaO" for convenience and to emphasize Brpnsted behavior. 

Nitrile-forming eliminations from 2,4,6-trinitrobenzaldehyde 0-oxime derivatives promoted by amines in MeCN have been studied kinetically. The reactions are second-order and exhibit substantial Hammett p and Brpnsted ft values. The second-order rate constant for elimination from ( )-2,4,6-trinitrobenzaldehyde 0-pivaloyloxime promoted by /-Pr2NH in MeCN falls on a single line in the Hammett plot for different j0-aryl substituents, which have been shown to react by the E2 mechanism. The change of the /3-aryl group from phenyl to thienyl to furyl shifted the reaction mechanism from E2 to ElcE) f ... 

A base is a substance that accepts a proton (Brpnsted-Lowry). Basic compounds are good proton acceptors as the conjugate acids, formed on protonation, are relatively stable. Consequently, strong bases (B or B ) give conjugate acids (BH" " or BH) with high pA a values. 

You have reviewed the Brpnsted-Lowry definition of acids and bases and the meanings of pH and p a- You have learned to identify the most acidic hydrogen atoms in a molecule based on a comparison of p a values. You will see in many cases that Brpnsted-Lowry acid-base reactions either initiate or complete an organic reaction, or prepare an organic molecule for further reaction. The Lewis definition of acids and bases may have been new to you. However, you will see over and over again that Lewis acid-base reactions which involve either the donation of an electron pair to form a new covalent bond or the departure of an electron pair to break a covalent bond are central steps in many organic reactions. The vast majority of organic reactions you will study are either Brpnsted-Lowry or Lewis acid-base reactions. 

---