Aromatics substitution, orientation

A brief account of aromatic substitution may be usefully given here as it will assist the student in predicting the orientation of disubstituted benzene derivatives produced in the different substitution reactions. For the nitration of nitrobenzene the substance must be heated with a mixture of fuming nitric acid and concentrated sulphuric acid the product is largely ni-dinitrobenzene (about 90 per cent.), accompanied by a little o-dinitrobenzene (about 5 per cent.) which is eliminated in the recrystallisation process. On the other hand phenol can be easily nitrated with dilute nitric acid to yield a mixture of ortho and para nitrophenols. It may be said, therefore, that orientation is meta with the... 

Consideration of the orientation of substitution Orientation is an important factor to be considered in recognising both changes in the effective electrophile and in the nature of the aromatic substrate. Cases of the former type, which will be met at several places... 

Sometimes the orientation of two substituents m an aromatic compound precludes Its straightforward synthesis m Chloroethylbenzene for example has two ortho para directing groups m a meta relationship and so can t be prepared either from chloroben zene or ethylbenzene In cases such as this we couple electrophilic aromatic substitution with functional group manipulation to produce the desired compound... 

Diazo coupling follows the rules of orientation of substituents in aromatic systems in accordance with the mechanism of electrophilic aromatic substitution and the concept of resonance. 

Resonance effects are the primary influence on orientation and reactivity in electrophilic substitution. The common activating groups in electrophilic aromatic substitution, in approximate order of decreasing effectiveness, are —NR2, —NHR, —NH2, —OH, —OR, —NO, —NHCOR, —OCOR, alkyls, —F, —Cl, —Br, —1, aryls, —CH2COOH, and —CH=CH—COOH. Activating groups are ortho- and para-directing. Mixtures of ortho- and para-isomers are frequently produced the exact proportions are usually a function of steric effects and reaction conditions. 

Reactivity and orientation in electrophilic aromatic substitution can also be related to the concept of hardness (see Section 1.2.3). Ionization potential is a major factor in determining hardness and is also intimately related to the process of (x-complex formation when an electrophile interacts with the n HOMO to form a new a bond. In MO terms, hardness is related to the gap between the LUMO and HOMO, t] = (sujmo %omo)/2- Thus, the harder a reactant ring system is, the more difficult it is for an electrophile to complete rr-bond formation. 

At this point, attention can be given to specific electrophilic substitution reactions. The kinds of data that have been especially useful for determining mechanistic details include linear ffee-energy relationships, kinetic studies, isotope effects, and selectivity patterns. In general, the basic questions that need to be asked about each mechanism are (1) What is the active electrophile (2) Which step in the general mechanism for electrophilic aromatic substitution is rate-determining (3) What are the orientation and selectivity patterns ... 

Trialkyltin substituents are also powerful ipso-directing groups. The overall electronic effects are similar to those in silanes, but the tin substituent is a better electron donor. The electron density at carbon is increased, as is the stabilization of /S-carbocation character. Acidic cleavage of arylstannanes is formulated as an electrophilic aromatic substitution proceeding through an ipso-oriented c-complex. ... 

Table 12.2 summarizes orientation and rate effects in electrophilic aromatic substitution reactions for a variety of frequently encountered substituents. It is arianged in order of decreasing activating power the most strongly activating substituents are at the top, the most strongly deactivating substituents are at the bottom. The main features of the table can be summarized as follows ... 

In the discussion of electrophilic aromatic substitution (Chapter 11) equal attention was paid to the effect of substrate structure on reactivity (activation or deactivation) and on orientation. The question of orientation was important because in a typical substitution there are four or five hydrogens that could serve as leaving groups. This type of question is much less important for aromatic nucleophilic substitution, since in most cases there is only one potential leaving group in a molecule. Therefore attention is largely focused on the reactivity of one molecule compared with another and not on the comparison of the reactivity of different positions within the same molecule. 

The frontier orbital theory was developed for electrophilic aromatic substitution (Chapter Elements of a Chemical Orbital Theory by Inagaki in this volume). Application is successful to the ortho-para orientation (Scheme 23a) for the benzenes substituted with electron donating groups. The ortho and para positions have larger HOMO amplitudes. The meta orientation (Scheme 23b) for the electron accepting groups is under control of both HOMO and the next HOMO [25]. 

With the ArH ArTlX2 Arl reaction sequence available as a rapid and reliable probe for aromatic thallation, a detailed study was undertaken of the various factors affecting orientation in this electrophilic metallation process (153). The results, which are summarized below, demonstrate that aromatic thallation is subject to an almost unprecedented degree of orientation control coupled with the ease with which thallium can then be displaced by other substitutent groups (this aspect of the synthetic exploitation of aromatic thallation is discussed in detail below), the sequential processes of thallation followed by displacement represent a new and versatile method for aromatic substitution which both rivals and complements the classic Sandmeyer reaction. 

While at Leeds from 1924 to 1930, Ingold s laboratory focused on three main topics of research (1) the nature and mechanism of orienting effects of groups in aromatic substitution (mainly nitration) (2) the study of prototropic rearrangements (shifts of H+) and aniontropic rearrangements (shifts of anions) as the ionic mechanisms of tautomerism and (3) the effect of polar substituents on the velocity and orientation of addition reactions to unsaturated systems. One of Ingold s students at Leeds, John William Baker, wrote a widely read book on tautomerism. 16... 

N. Vass, "The Nature of the Alternating Effect in Carbon Chains. Pt. XXIII. Anomalous Orientation by Halogens, and Its Bearing on the Problem of the Ortho-Para-Ratio in Aromatic Substitution," JCS 131 (1928) 417425. 

The structural theory of organic chemistry was developed in the last half of the nineteenth century. It led to the concept that chemical, physical and biological properties of all kinds must be a function of structural change. The earliest structure-property relationships (SPR) were qualitative. Examples are the directional effect of substituents on the benzene ring with respect to electrophilic aromatic substitution and orientation in... 

Electron-donating substituents make the aromatic subsU ate more reactive than benzene and lead to o,/ -orientation, while electron-withdrawing substituents decrease the reactivity and give mostly m-orientation products. The detailed mechanism of the formation of the a complex has been studied by oxygen-18 labeling of the sulfonyl oxygen in p-nitrobenzenesulfonyl peroxide. The ionic mechanism for aromatic substitution by sulfonyl peroxides has been confirmed by carrying out the substitution reaction in the presence of redox catalysts such as copper and cobalt salts and aluminum chloride. Small differences in the rate of the products can be found in the presence or absence of these additives, and it has been concluded that the ionic mechanism accounts satisfactorily for these results. ... 

---