Anaerobic carbon oxidation, sulfate reduction

Sulfur fulfills many diverse roles in lakes. As the sixth most abundant element in biomass, it is required as a major nutrient by all organisms. For most algae, S is abundant in the form of sulfate in the water column however, in dilute glacial lakes in Alaska (I) and in some central African lakes (2) low concentrations of sulfate may limit primary production. Sulfur also serves the dual role of electron acceptor for respiration and, in reduced forms, source of energy for chemolithotrophic secondary production. Net sulfate reduction can account for 10-80% of anaerobic carbon oxidation in lakes (3-5), and hence this process is important in carbon and energy flow. Sulfate reduction, whether associated with uptake of sulfate and incorpo-... 

Relative rates of sulfate reduction and methanogenesis in lakes of varying trophic status are claimed to indicate that sulfate reduction rates are limited by the supply of sulfate (4, 5, 13). According to this hypothesis, at high rates of carbon sedimentation, rates of sulfate reduction are limited by rates of sulfate diffusion into sediments, and methanogenesis exceeds sulfate reduction. In less productive lakes, rates of sulfate diffusion should more nearly equal rates of formation of low-molecular-weight substrates, and sulfate reduction should account for a larger proportion of anaerobic carbon oxidation. Field data do not support this hypothesis (Table II). There is no relationship between trophic status, an index of carbon availability, and rates of anaerobic... 

Figure 25 Anaerobic decomposition with sulfate reduction as the terminal step. Fermentation leads to several possible products including low molecular weight organic acids and alcohols and hydrogen and carbon dioxide. Incomplete oxidizers (i) produce acetate as an end product, whereas complete oxidizers (c) mineralize organic compounds, including acetate, to carbon dioxide.

Measurements of S cycling in Little Rock Lake, Wisconsin, and Lake Sempach, Switzerland, are used together with literature data to show the major factors regulating S retention and speciation in sediments. Retention of S in sediments is controlled by rates of seston (planktonic S) deposition, sulfate diffusion, and S recycling. Data from 80 lakes suggest that seston deposition is the major source of sedimentary S for approximately 50% of the lakes sulfate diffusion and subsequent reduction dominate in the remainder. Concentrations of sulfate in lake water and carbon deposition rates are important controls on diffusive fluxes. Diffusive fluxes are much lower than rates of sulfate reduction, however. Rates of sulfate reduction in many lakes appear to be limited by rates of sulfide oxidation. Much sulfide oxidation occurs anaerobically, but the pathways and electron acceptors remain unknown. The intrasediment cycle of sulfate reduction and sulfide oxidation is rapid relative to rates of S accumulation in sediments. Concentrations and speciation of sulfur in sediments are shown to be sensitive indicators of paleolimnological conditions of salinity, aeration, and eutrophication. 

Figure 28. Hypothetical anaerobic nitrogen cycle based on the following thermodynamically permissible reactions (1) ammonium oxidation to dinitrogen by carbon dioxide,. sulfate or ferric iron (no evidence at present, possibly kinetically limited) (2) dinitrogen fixation by various organic and inorganic reductants (known) (3) ammonium oxidation by nitrite or nitrate producing dinitrogen (known) (4) denitrification (known) (5) nitrite or nitrate respiration (known) (6) ferric iron oxidation of ammonium to nitrite or nitrate (no evidence at present) (7) nitrate assimilation (known) (8) ammonium assimilation and di.s,similation (known) (Fenchel etai, 1998).

Only about 5% of the total mineralized organic carbon in marine sediments is ultimately degraded to methane. Why, then, does the anaerobic oxidation of methane with sulfate often generate quasi-linear sulfate profiles that indicate methane to be the dominant energy source for sulfate reduction ... 

---