Acid catalysis solvent effects

Salomaa P, Kankaanpena A, Lajunen M (1966) Protolytic cleavage of vinyl ethers. General acid catalysis, structural effects, and deuterium solvent isotope effects. Acta Chem Scand 20 1790-1801... 

Sometimes solvents are unavoidable, as in intramolecular reactions (Exercise 14-24), when high dilution is important (Section 9-6). The green solvent of choice is, naturally, water. In fact, as shown in the example, water is not only feasible as a solvent, it can speed up Diels-Alder reactions on its own, in addition to improving stereoselectivity, especially when combined with Lewis acid catalysis. This effect of water has been ascribed to hydrogen bonding and hydrophobic effects (Section 8-2) on the transition state. 

This chapter introduces the experimental work described in the following chapters. Some mechanistic aspects of the Diels-Alder reaction and Lewis-acid catalysis thereof are discussed. This chapter presents a critical survey of the literature on solvent ejfects on Diels-Alder reactions, with particular emphasis on the intriguing properties of water in connection with their effect on rate and selectivity. Similarly, the ejfects of water on Lewis acid - Lewis base interactions are discussed. Finally the aims of this thesis are outlined. 

Unfortunately, the number of mechanistic studies in this field stands in no proportion to its versatility" . Thermodynamic analysis revealed that the beneficial effect of Lewis-acids on the rate of the Diels-Alder reaction can be primarily ascribed to a reduction of the enthalpy of activation ( AAH = 30-50 kJ/mole) leaving the activation entropy essentially unchanged (TAAS = 0-10 kJ/mol)" . Solvent effects on Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reactions have received very little attention. A change in solvent affects mainly the coordination step rather than the actual Diels-Alder reaction. Donating solvents severely impede catalysis . This observation justifies the widespread use of inert solvents such as dichloromethane and chloroform for synthetic applications of Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reactions. 

Studies on solvent effects on the endo-exo selectivity of Diels-Alder reactions have revealed the importance of hydrogen bonding interactions besides the already mentioned solvophobic interactions and polarity effects. Further evidence of the significance of the former interactions comes from computer simulations" and the analogy with Lewis-acid catalysis which is known to enhance dramatically the endo-exo selectivity (Section 1.2.4). 

A combination of the promoting effects of Lewis acids and water is a logical next step. However, to say the least, water has not been a very popular medium for Lewis-acid catalysed Diels-Alder reactions, which is not surprising since water molecules interact strongly with Lewis-acidic and the Lewis-basic atoms of the reacting system. In 1994, when the research described in this thesis was initiated, only one example of Lewis-acid catalysis of a Diels-Alder reaction in water was published Lubineau and co-workers employed lanthanide triflates as a catalyst for the Diels-Alder reaction of glyoxylate to a relatively unreactive diene . No comparison was made between the process in water and in organic solvents. 

Interestingly, at very low concentrations of micellised Qi(DS)2, the rate of the reaction of 5.1a with 5.2 was observed to be zero-order in 5.1 a and only depending on the concentration of Cu(DS)2 and 5.2. This is akin to the turn-over and saturation kinetics exhibited by enzymes. The acceleration relative to the reaction in organic media in the absence of catalyst, also approaches enzyme-like magnitudes compared to the process in acetonitrile (Chapter 2), Cu(DS)2 micelles accelerate the Diels-Alder reaction between 5.1a and 5.2 by a factor of 1.8710 . This extremely high catalytic efficiency shows how a combination of a beneficial aqueous solvent effect, Lewis-acid catalysis and micellar catalysis can lead to tremendous accelerations. 

First of all, given the well recognised promoting effects of Lewis-acids and of aqueous solvents on Diels-Alder reactions, we wanted to know if these two effects could be combined. If this would be possible, dramatic improvements of rate and endo-exo selectivity were envisaged Studies on the Diels-Alder reaction of a dienophile, specifically designed for this purpose are described in Chapter 2. It is demonstrated that Lewis-acid catalysis in an aqueous medium is indeed feasible and, as anticipated, can result in impressive enhancements of both rate and endo-exo selectivity. However, the influences of the Lewis-acid catalyst and the aqueous medium are not fully additive. It seems as if water diminishes the catalytic potential of Lewis acids just as coordination of a Lewis acid diminishes the beneficial effects of water. Still, overall, the rate of the catalysed reaction... 

Sulphuric acid catalysed nitration in concentrated nitric acid, but the effect was much weaker than that observed in nitration in organic solvents ( 3.2.3). The concentration of sulphuric acid required to double the rate of nitration of i-nitroanthraquinone was about 0-23 mol 1, whereas typically, a concentration of io mol 1 will effect the same change in nitration in mixtures of nitric acid and organic solvents. The acceleration in the rate was not linear in the concentration of catalyst, for the sensitivity to catalysis was small with low concentrations of sulphuric acid, but increased with the progressive addition of more catalyst and eventually approached a linear acceleration. 

Nitration in organic solvents is strongly catalysed by small concentrations of strong acids typically a concentration of io mol 1 of sulphuric acid doubles the rate of reaction. Reaction under zeroth-order conditions is accelerated without disturbing the kinetic form, even under the influence of very strong catalysis. The effect of sulphuric acid on the nitration of benzene in nitromethane is tabulated in table 3.3. The catalysis is linear in the concentration of sulphuric acid. 

High Carbon Yield. Furfuryl alcohol and furfural are reactive solvents (monomers) and are effective in producing high carbon yield (heat induced carbonization in a reducing atmosphere). They function as binders for refractory materials or carbon bodies. Furfuryl alcohol usually requires acidic catalysis and furfural basic catalysis. Mixtures of furfuryl alcohol and furfural are generally catalyzed with acid although some systems may be catalyzed with base. 

Alkenes lacking phenyl substituents appear to react by a similar mechanism. Both the observation of general acid catalysis and the kinetic evidence of a solvent isotope effect are consistent with rate-limiting protonation with simple alkenes such as 2-metlQ lpropene and 2,3-dimethyl-2-butene. 

Acid catalysis is an important kinetic phenomenon, and its study often requires the use of concentrated acid solutions, in which the conventional pH scale is not applicable. In sueh solutions (e.g., sulfuric acid-water mixtures covering the full range of compositions) the acid component simultaneously functions both as an acid and as a solvent thus, a medium effect is superimposed on the acidity effect. In this section we briefly describe the acidity function approach to coping with this problem. (A comparable approach can be taken to the study of highly... 

Similar additions may be performed with the enamine 13. However, with 3-buten-2-one or methyl 2-propenoate Lewis acid catalysis is needed to activate the Michael acceptor chloro-trimethylsilane proved to be best suited for this purpose. A remarkable solvent effect is seen in these reactions. A change from THF to HMPA/toluene (1 1) results in a reversal of the absolute configuration of the product 14, presumably due to a ligand effect of HMPA235. 

With 77 % aqueous acetic acid, the rates were found to be more affected by added perchloric acid than by sodium perchlorate (but only at higher concentrations than those used by Stanley and Shorter207, which accounts for the failure of these workers to observe acid catalysis, but their observation of kinetic orders in hypochlorous acid of less than one remains unaccounted for). The difference in the effect of the added electrolyte increased with concentration, and the rates of the acid-catalysed reaction reached a maximum in ca. 50 % aqueous acetic acid, passed through a minimum at ca. 90 % aqueous acetic acid and rose very rapidly thereafter. The faster chlorination in 50% acid than in water was, therefore, considered consistent with chlorination by AcOHCl+, which is subject to an increasing solvent effect in the direction of less aqueous media (hence the minimum in 90 % acid), and a third factor operates, viz. that in pure acetic acid the bulk source of chlorine ischlorineacetate rather than HOC1 and causes the rapid rise in rate towards the anhydrous medium. The relative rates of the acid-catalysed (acidity > 0.49 M) chlorination of some aromatics in 76 % aqueous acetic acid at 25 °C were found to be toluene, 69 benzene, 1 chlorobenzene, 0.097 benzoic acid, 0.004. Some of these kinetic observations were confirmed in a study of the chlorination of diphenylmethane in the presence of 0.030 M perchloric acid, second-order rate coefficients were obtained at 25 °C as follows209 0.161 (98 vol. % aqueous acetic acid) ca. 0.078 (75 vol. % acid), and, in the latter solvent in the presence of 0.50 M perchloric acid, diphenylmethane was approximately 30 times more reactive than benzene. 

The kinetic data based on the demonstration of specific acid catalysis in buffers, solvent isotope effects and acidity functions all support mechanisms where the proton-transfers are fast. It is possible to write equations which accommodate these facts together with the first-order dependence on hydrazo-compound and the concurrent first and second-order dependence on acidity. These are... 

This scheme requires a rate-determining (second) proton-transfer, against which there is considerable experimental evidence in the form of specific-acid catalysis, the solvent isotope effect and the hg dependence discussed earlier. Further, application of the steady-state principle to the 7i-complex mechanism results in a rate equation of the form... 

Smoluchowski see von Smoluchowski) Solvent cage, 198, 202 Solvent effects. 197-199, 204—206 Specific acid-base catalysis,... 

The general acid catalysis, the deuterium solvent isotope effects, and the lack of deuterium incorporation upon partial hydration in D2 0 are particularly convincing evidence for a rate-determining protonation and the discrete intermediacy of a vinyl cation such as 6. 

Both schemes accommodate the kinetics, the primary isotope effect and the induction factor, which indicates that Cr(IV) is the initial stage of reduction of the oxidant. RoCek s mechanism does not accord with the solvent isotope effect of 2.5 per proton, which has just the value to be expected for acid-catalysis, for the O-H bond cleavage should be subject to a primary isotope effect of about 7. The ester mechanism is not open to this criticim. 

---