Vibrational frequency electron transfer

Figure 14 Comparison of vibrational and electron transfer hopping frequencies. Closed ellipses based on kinetic data open rectangles based on Equation (75). See Table 6.

The discussion thus far in this chapter has been centred on classical mechanics. However, in many systems, an explicit quantum treatment is required (not to mention the fact that it is the correct law of physics). This statement is particularly true for proton and electron transfer reactions in chemistry, as well as for reactions involving high-frequency vibrations. 

Much of tills chapter concerns ET reactions in solution. However, gas phase ET processes are well known too. See figure C3.2.1. The Tiarjioon mechanism by which halogens oxidize alkali metals is fundamentally an electron transfer reaction [2]. One might guess, from tliis simple reaction, some of tlie stmctural parameters tliat control ET rates relative electron affinities of reactants, reactant separation distance, bond lengtli changes upon oxidation/reduction, vibrational frequencies, etc. 

Early studies showed tliat tire rates of ET are limited by solvation rates for certain barrierless electron transfer reactions. However, more recent studies showed tliat electron-transfer rates can far exceed tire rates of diffusional solvation, which indicate critical roles for intramolecular (high frequency) vibrational mode couplings and inertial solvation. The interiDlay between inter- and intramolecular degrees of freedom is particularly significant in tire Marcus inverted regime [45] (figure C3.2.12)). 

While being very similar in the general description, the RLT and electron-transfer processes differ in the vibration types they involve. In the first case, those are the high-frequency intramolecular modes, while in the second case the major role is played by the continuous spectrum of polarization phonons in condensed 3D media [Dogonadze and Kuznetsov 1975]. The localization effects mentioned in the previous section, connected with the low-frequency part of the phonon spectrum, still do not show up in electron-transfer reactions because of the asymmetry of the potential. 

First, we shall discuss reaction (5.7.1), which is more involved than simple electron transfer. While the frequency of polarization vibration of the media where electron transfer occurs lies in the range 3 x 1010 to 3 x 1011 Hz, the frequency of the vibrations of proton-containing groups in proton donors (e.g. in the oxonium ion or in the molecules of weak acids) is of the order of 3 x 1012 to 3 x 1013 Hz. Then for the transfer proper of the proton from the proton donor to the electrode the classical approximation cannot be employed without modification. This step has indeed a quantum mechanical character, but, in simple cases, proton transfer can be described in terms of concepts of reorganization of the medium and thus of the exponential relationship in Eq. (5.3.14). The quantum character of proton transfer occurring through the tunnel mechanism is expressed in terms of the... 

Instead of the quantity given by Eq. (15), the quantity given by Eq. (10) was treated as the activation energy of the process in the earlier papers on the quantum mechanical theory of electron transfer reactions. This difference between the results of the quantum mechanical theory of radiationless transitions and those obtained by the methods of nonequilibrium thermodynamics has also been noted in Ref. 9. The results of the quantum mechanical theory were obtained in the harmonic oscillator model, and Eqs. (9) and (10) are valid only if the vibrations of the oscillators are classical and their frequencies are unchanged in the course of the electron transition (i.e., (o k = w[). It might seem that, in this case, the energy of the transition and the free energy of the transition are equal to each other. However, we have to remember that for the solvent, the oscillators are the effective ones and the parameters of the system Hamiltonian related to the dielectric properties of the medium depend on the temperature. Therefore, the problem of the relationship between the results obtained by the two methods mentioned above deserves to be discussed. 

When the gap is large, the sketch in Fig. 9 shows that a second channel will open when there is a vibrational resonance - that is, when eV = ho, with o one of the vibrational frequencies of the molecule. This is vibronic resonance, and energy will transfer from the momentum of the tunneling electrons into the vibrations of the molecule. The interaction is quite weak (because the tunneling time is so short) ... 

---